Agencies · Southern Maine coast · Kittery to Cape Elizabeth
By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Published October 19, 2026 · Google data checked October 19, 2026

Key takeaways
  • We list 10 local independent insurance agencies (12 office listings) along Route 1 from Kittery and Eliot through York, Wells and the Kennebunks to South Portland, next to Cape Elizabeth, town by town from south to north.
  • Several have long histories by their own accounts: Cole Harrison (since 1882), Batchelder Bros. and Ellis (since 1874) and Chalmers (168 years of history).
  • Noyes Hall & Allen in South Portland (167 Google reviews) and Seaside Insurance Agency in Kennebunk (90) had the most reviews as of October 2026.
  • Seasonal homes shape insurance here: Census data put about 65% of Ogunquit’s housing units and about 44% of Wells’s in seasonal use.
  • Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is licensed in Maine and serves the southern coast from Portsmouth, NH, minutes from Kittery and York. We have no Maine office.

Looking for an independent insurance agency in southern Maine? The coast from Kittery to Cape Elizabeth has agencies with roots in the 1800s alongside newer offices built around summer homes and condos. What they have in common is the work: year-round houses in Kittery and Eliot, seasonal cottages in York Beach, Ogunquit and Wells, shingled summer homes in Kennebunkport, and older homes everywhere that winter tests every year. This guide lists the independent agencies we found in each town, south to north along Route 1, with what each says it does and its Google rating and review count as of October 2026. We’re Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, an independent agency across the river in Portsmouth, NH, licensed in Maine. We don’t have a Maine office, so we explain how we fit in separately.

Nubble Light and its white keeper's house on a rocky island at Cape Neddick in York, Maine, under a clear blue sky
Nubble Light at Cape Neddick, York. Photo: Dubang chang / Pexels.

How we built this list

  • Towns. We searched Google Maps for insurance agencies in Kittery, Eliot, York, Ogunquit, Wells, Kennebunk, Kennebunkport, Cape Elizabeth and Scarborough. Ogunquit, Kennebunkport and Cape Elizabeth have few independent home-and-auto agency offices of their own, so we list the nearest ones.
  • Date checked. Ratings and review counts are from each office’s public Google Maps listing on October 19, 2026, about 8:30 to 8:50 AM Eastern.
  • Independent agencies only. Each says on its website that it is independent or represents several insurance companies. We left out captive agents (such as State Farm, Allstate and Nationwide), AAA, banks, insurance companies and health-and-Medicare-only agencies.
  • Ordered by place, not ranked. Offices are listed south to north. Google ratings are shown for reference; a small office with a handful of reviews can be a great fit.
  • Founding years come from each agency’s own website. Where none is listed, we say so.
  • Our own agency. We have no Maine office, so we are not in the table.

Disclosure: Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote and publishes this page. We did not contact, pay or receive anything from the agencies listed. Counts change daily, so check the live listing for the current number. For the statewide counts, see our New England agency review-count study.

Southern Maine independent agencies at a glance

TownAgency (Google listing)Founded (per its website)Google ratingGoogle reviews
KitteryCole Harrison Insurance Agency18825.010
Kittery and EliotWilliam E. Dennett AgencyNot listed5.01
EliotFord Insurance Agency19104.916
YorkChalmers Insurance Group168 years of history4.842
YorkTapley Insurance Agency19934.731
YorkBatchelder Bros. and Ellis Insurance Agencies18744.84
YorkSchmid Insurance Agency20035.04
WellsSevigney-Lyons Insurance Agency19844.620
KennebunkLyons Agency for Insurance (part of Sevigney-Lyons)Not listed4.823
KennebunkCole Harrison Insurance Agency18825.024
KennebunkSeaside Insurance AgencyNot listed5.090
South Portland (next to Cape Elizabeth)Noyes Hall & Allen Insurance19334.9167
Google ratings and review counts as of October 2026 (checked October 19, 2026), listed south to north along the coast. Founding years are from each agency’s own website. Portsmouth Atlantic has no Maine office, so it is not listed.

Kittery and Eliot

Cole Harrison Insurance Agency, Kittery and Kennebunk

Cole Harrison says it has insured Maine and New Hampshire since 1882 and calls itself one of the Seacoast’s largest independent agencies. It has offices on Walker Street in Kittery and Main Street in Kennebunk, and its site covers personal, business, life and flood insurance.

William E. Dennett Agency, Kittery and Eliot

Dennett is an independent agency with offices on Wentworth Street in Kittery and State Road in Eliot, offering personal and business insurance in Maine and New Hampshire. Its site lists the insurance companies it represents. Its Kittery Google listing had one review when we checked.

Ford Insurance Agency, Eliot

Ford says it was founded in 1910 and grew into a full personal and commercial agency, now on Dow Highway in Eliot. Insurance Journal reported in June 2025 that COVU, a San Francisco-based agency group, acquired Ford and planned to keep the Ford name. For homes in these towns, see our Kittery and Eliot and South Berwick pages.

York

Chalmers Insurance Group, York Street

Chalmers describes itself as a fourth-generation, family-owned agency with 168 years of history and locations in Maine and New Hampshire. Its site has a private client group for higher-value homes, a flood page and specialty programs such as youth camps. It had the most Google reviews of the York offices we checked.

Tapley Insurance Agency, York Street

Tapley’s motto is “Solutions, Not Sales,” and it says it has been in business since 1993, shopping policies with 20+ carriers. Its site covers personal and commercial lines and flood insurance.

Batchelder Bros. and Ellis Insurance Agencies, York Street

The York office of Batchelder Bros. and Ellis (still listed on Google as Ellis Insurance) is part of an agency that says it has served Maine since 1874, with another office in Sanford. Its site has pages for high-net-worth homes, yachts and watercraft, and pages explaining water damage and flood gaps.

Schmid Insurance Agency, Route 1

Schmid is an independent agency on Route 1 in York that says it has served Maine and New Hampshire since 2003, offering home, auto, life and business insurance. Our York, Maine home insurance page covers York Beach rentals, York Harbor estates and Cape Neddick.

Wells, Ogunquit and the Kennebunks

Sevigney-Lyons Insurance Agency, Wells

Sevigney-Lyons says its founder opened the agency in his hometown of Wells in 1984, and his sons later took it over. It has grown by acquiring agencies in South Berwick, Kennebunk and Portland, and offers condominium and waterfront programs plus flood insurance, which speaks to the condos and cottages common in Ogunquit and Wells.

Lyons Agency for Insurance, Kennebunk

Lyons Agency on Fletcher Street has been part of Sevigney-Lyons since 2018 and keeps its own Kennebunk office and Google listing.

Seaside Insurance Agency, Kennebunk

Seaside is an independent agency on Portland Road in Kennebunk serving southern Maine and New Hampshire. Its site covers home, auto, recreational vehicles, business, life, and farm and equine insurance. It had the most Google reviews of the Kennebunk-area offices we checked. Our Kennebunk and Kennebunkport and Ogunquit and Wells pages cover those towns.

Next to Cape Elizabeth: South Portland

Noyes Hall & Allen Insurance, South Portland

Noyes Hall & Allen says it has been locally owned and independent since opening in Portland in 1933, and today works from Ocean Street in South Portland, the next town over from Cape Elizabeth. It calls itself one of Maine’s most experienced condo insurance agents and also offers home, auto, boat and business coverage. It had the most Google reviews of any office on this list.

Other insurance agency offices we found on the same searches, without full profiles: Rousseau Insurance Agency and Methot Insurance Agency (Biddeford), Garnsey Brothers Insurance (Sanford), Foy Insurance (Scarborough) and Peoples Insurance (Ogunquit).

Own a home in Kittery, York or the Kennebunks?
We’re licensed in Maine and compare 40+ carriers from Portsmouth, NH, minutes from Kittery and York. We don’t charge additional fees.
Talk to our team: (603) 431-4020 · Request a coverage review

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance: minutes from Kittery and York

We’re an independent, family-owned agency founded in 2005, based on Islington Street in Portsmouth, NH. Kittery is just across the Piscataqua River and York is a short drive up Route 1. We don’t have a Maine office; we are licensed in Maine among 10 states and insure southern Maine homes from Portsmouth. That works well for the many families here with a house on each side of the bridge, because one agency can handle the New Hampshire home, the Maine cottage, the cars and an umbrella.

  • Carriers. We compare 40+ carriers, including Chubb and Cincinnati, which write homes at any dwelling limit, and Openly, which we’re appointed with in Maine.
  • Flood. We place new NFIP flood policies through Selective and quote private flood through Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge where they write the property.
  • Reviews. We’re New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. Read our client feedback.
  • Maine group discounts. Some carriers offer group discounts for educators and other professions; see our Maine teacher and educator discounts page.
  • No fees. We don’t charge additional fees.

What to look for in a southern Maine insurance agency

On this coast, the hard questions are about how a house is used, how it gets through winter and what a storm off the Gulf of Maine can do. Ask any agency, including us, these:

Is the house seasonal, rented or empty part of the year?

Share of housing units held for seasonal, recreational or occasional use
Ogunquit65.5%
Wells43.9%
Kennebunkport32.7%
York32.4%
Kennebunk12.7%
Kittery5.5%

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2019-2023 5-year estimates, tables B25004 and B25001. Our calculation: seasonal units divided by total housing units. Small-town estimates have margins of error.

In Ogunquit roughly two homes in three are seasonal, and in Wells, Kennebunkport and York it’s roughly one in three or more. Carriers ask who checks the house, whether the heat is monitored and whether the water is shut off and drained for winter. Weekly summer rentals change the policy too; many homeowners policies limit coverage for regular rentals, and a house rented most of the season may need a dwelling policy. Our Maine homeowners and second-home insurance page goes deeper.

How does the policy handle ice dams and frozen pipes?

Interior water damage from an ice dam is usually covered, but many policies don’t pay to remove the dam itself. Frozen-pipe damage is generally covered only if you kept the heat on or shut off and drained the water, and vacancy rules can apply to a cottage closed for the winter. Low-temperature and water-flow sensors help with both claims and underwriting. Our guide to snow and ice damage insurance in the Northeast explains the usual gaps.

What happens in a coastal storm?

Winter storms, not just hurricanes, do much of the damage here. FEMA declared a major disaster for Maine’s January 9 to 13, 2024 severe storms and flooding, and York County was among the counties included for public assistance. Maine law (24-A M.R.S. §3061) and Bureau of Insurance Rule Chapter 960 limit when a hurricane deductible can apply: only from a National Weather Service hurricane warning for a forecast zone that includes part of your town until 24 hours after the last warning ends. Some coastal policies also carry a separate windstorm deductible figured as a percentage of the dwelling limit, so ask for it in dollars.

Is flood a separate policy, and how is it rated?

Yes. Homeowners policies exclude flood, whether the water comes from storm surge at Long Sands, the Webhannet marsh in Wells or the Mousam River in Kennebunk. Check your address on FEMA’s Flood Map Service Center and ask whether an elevation certificate exists. NFIP coverage generally starts 30 days after purchase, with exceptions such as a policy bought with a new mortgage, so line it up before closing. See our flood insurance page.

Does the agency understand older homes and condos?

About 46% of Kittery’s housing units were built before 1960, per the same Census survey, and the Maine Bureau of Insurance notes premiums are often higher for older homes, with many insurers offering credits when the roof, heating, plumbing and wiring have been updated. Converted multi-unit buildings and cottage associations need the master policy and each unit owner’s policy to fit together; our Maine condex insurance guide explains how.

Before you choose a southern Maine agency, check these
  • It is independent and can quote several carriers for a seasonal or waterfront home.
  • It is licensed in Maine and in any other state where you own a home.
  • It asks how the house is used in winter and whether you rent it.
  • It shows any windstorm or hurricane deductible in dollars.
  • It can quote flood, including private flood, before your closing.

Frequently asked questions

Which independent insurance agencies are in York, Maine?

The York offices we found were Chalmers Insurance Group on York Street (42 Google reviews, rated 4.8, as of October 2026), Tapley Insurance Agency (31 reviews, rated 4.7), Batchelder Bros. and Ellis Insurance Agencies (4 reviews, rated 4.8) and Schmid Insurance Agency on Route 1 (4 reviews, rated 5.0). Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is licensed in Maine and insures York homes from its Portsmouth, NH office, a short drive down Route 1.

Which independent insurance agencies serve Kittery and Eliot?

Cole Harrison Insurance Agency has an office on Walker Street in Kittery, William E. Dennett Agency has offices in Kittery and Eliot, and Ford Insurance Agency is on Dow Highway in Eliot. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is minutes away across the Piscataqua River in Portsmouth, NH, and is licensed in Maine.

Which independent insurance agencies serve Wells, Kennebunk and Kennebunkport?

Sevigney-Lyons Insurance Agency was founded in Wells in 1984, is now on Post Road and also operates the Lyons Agency for Insurance in Kennebunk. Cole Harrison Insurance Agency and Seaside Insurance Agency also have Kennebunk offices. Seaside had the most Google reviews of these, with 90 as of October 2026.

When does a hurricane deductible apply in Maine?

Under Maine Bureau of Insurance rules, an insurer that uses a hurricane deductible can apply it only from the time the National Weather Service issues a hurricane warning for a forecast zone that includes part of your town until 24 hours after the last warning for that zone ends. Outside that window, wind losses fall under your regular deductible or, on some coastal policies, a separate windstorm deductible.

Can I insure a summer cottage in southern Maine that sits empty in winter?

Yes. Many carriers write seasonal homes, but expect questions about winterization, heat monitoring and who checks the house while you are away. Frozen-pipe damage is usually covered only if you kept the heat on or shut off and drained the water, and many policies limit coverage for regular rentals, so tell your agent exactly how the home is used.

Does Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance have an office in Maine?

No. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance has no Maine office. We are licensed in Maine and insure homes in Kittery, York, Ogunquit, Wells, the Kennebunks and elsewhere in the state from our office in Portsmouth, NH, which is minutes from Kittery and York.

Sources

  • Google Maps business listings for each agency named, ratings and review counts read October 19, 2026, about 8:30 to 8:50 AM Eastern. Counts change daily; check the live listing.
  • Each agency’s own website, read October 19, 2026, for founding years and coverage descriptions. Insurance Journal, “AI-Focused COVU Acquires Maine’s 100-Year Old Ford Agency,” June 24, 2025.
  • U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2019-2023 5-year estimates, tables B25004, B25001 and B25034.
  • Maine Revised Statutes, Title 24-A, §3061, and Maine Bureau of Insurance Rule 02-031 C.M.R. ch. 960, §4 (hurricane deductibles); Maine Bureau of Insurance consumer guidance on premium factors.
  • FEMA disaster declaration for the January 9 to 13, 2024 severe storms and flooding in Maine; FEMA Flood Map Service Center; FloodSmart (NFIP).

This page is general information, not a policy or a recommendation of any agency. Coverage, forms and availability vary by carrier and property, and every policy is subject to underwriting. Your policy documents control.

Insuring a home on the southern Maine coast?
Founded in 2005 and family-owned, we compare 40+ carriers for Maine homeowners from our Portsmouth, NH office.
Talk to our team: (603) 431-4020 · Get a quote
Jon Merwin, founder and CEO of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance
Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, Portsmouth, NH
Portsmouth Atlantic has been an independent, family-owned agency since 2005, is licensed in 10 states, works with 40+ carriers and has earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. Meet our team.
Call Email Claims Payments