Billing and claims

If you need to file a claim or make a payment, use your insurance company’s phone number or website below. Those companies handle claims and billing directly.

If you want help finding the right number, or you have a question about your policy, call us at (603) 431-4020 or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com.

After hours. For a new claim, call the claims number for your carrier. The links and numbers below are the contacts published on our carriers page.

Find your carrier

Carrier Claims phone Service phone Online
American Modern1.800.375.20751.800.543.2644
Andover Companies1.800.225.07701.978.475.3300
Aon Edge1.844.640.25221.888.281.0684
CatCoverage1.801.316.42281.801.316.4228
Chubb1.800.252.46701.866.324.8222
Cincinnati Insurance1.877.242.25441.888.242.8811
Concord Group1.800.482.74431.800.852.3380
Foremost Insurance1.800.527.3907—
Hagerty1.800.747.53481.888.220.9565
Hanover1.800.628.02501.866.878.6609
Liberty Mutual1.800.225.2467 (1-800-2CLAIMS)1.800.290.8711
Roadside: 1.877.762.3101
MPIUA (Massachusetts FAIR Plan)1.800.851.89781.877.221.1782
National General1.888.325.11901.800.468.3466
Neptune Flood1.727.202.4815
You may be prompted to login directly to Neptune Flood’s online portal. If you don’t have a login, you can easily create one.
1.727.202.4815
Openly1.888.808.4842, Option 21.888.808.4842, Option 1
Patriot Insurance Company1.866.460.17761.866.460.1776
Plymouth Rock Assurance1.844.346.12251.835.511.7625
Progressive1.888.671.44051.888.671.4405
Providence Mutual1.877.763.18001.877.763.1800
Safety Insurance1.800.951.21001.877.951.4642
Ski Safe1.800.225.65601.800.225.6560
Steadily1.888.966.16111.888.966.1611
Stillwater Insurance1.800.220.13511.800.849.6140
Swyfft1.877.799.33891.855.479.9338
Universal Property & Casualty1.800.470.05991.800.425.9113
Vermont Mutual Insurance Group1.800.435.03971.800.451.5000
Carrier claim, billing and payment contacts from each company’s official site, compiled November 13, 2026. If your company is not listed, call us and we will point you to the right place.

What to expect when you file a claim

Have your policy number ready, and report the claim to the carrier as soon as you can. For a plain-language walkthrough, see how the insurance claim process works.

Need a policy change, an ID card or a certificate instead?

Go to the client portal

Call Email Claims Payments