Insurance Carriers We Represent
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is an independent, family-owned agency. We opened in 2005. We compare 40+ carriers and work for you, not for an insurance company. We don’t charge additional fees.
The carriers we have pages for
These 17 companies are the ones with dedicated pages on our site. Each card summarizes the lines we place and the states we have confirmed, in New England plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois where we have appointments. Availability is still subject to underwriting. For a fuller picture of a company, open its page.
Filter the list by line or by state, or jump straight to a company. If you already have a policy, see Find your carrier’s billing and claims contacts.
We are licensed in all six New England states plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois. Filter by state to see the companies we have confirmed there.

Andover Companies
We place Andover homeowners, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire, personal umbrella, and habitational commercial coverage (apartment buildings and condo associations) in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut.
- ME
- NH
- MA
- CT

Bristol West
We place Bristol West non-standard car insurance in New Hampshire, Maine, Rhode Island and Connecticut.
- ME
- NH
- RI
- CT

Chubb
We place Chubb in every state we are licensed in: all six New England states plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois. In New England that includes high-value homes, Connecticut homes, high-value boats and yachts, and Massachusetts landlord homes.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA
- RI
- CT
- NY
- FL
- OH
- IL

Cincinnati
We place Cincinnati in every state we are licensed in: all six New England states plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois. In New England that includes high-value homes, Connecticut homes, car insurance, Capstone yachts and collector cars.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA
- RI
- CT
- NY
- FL
- OH
- IL

Concord Group
We place Concord Group home, auto, landlord, condo and renters coverage in New Hampshire, Maine and Vermont, and apartment buildings and condo associations in New Hampshire, Maine and Massachusetts.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA

Foremost
We place Foremost homeowners, auto, landlord and rental homes, mobile and manufactured homes, boats, and RVs and powersports in New Hampshire, Maine, Vermont, Rhode Island and Connecticut.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- RI
- CT

Hanover
We place Hanover personal lines, including homeowners and high-value homes, auto, condo, renters, landlord and rental homes, and boats, in every state we are licensed in: all six New England states plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA
- RI
- CT
- NY
- FL
- OH
- IL

Liberty Mutual
We place Liberty Mutual homeowners, auto, landlord and rental homes, boats, RVs and powersports, and collector cars in all six New England states.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA
- RI
- CT

National General
We place National General in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut, including homes (up to about $5 million), auto, RVs and powersports, Connecticut rental dwellings, Massachusetts landlord homes, and condo coverage.
- ME
- NH
- MA
- CT

Openly
We place Openly single-family and higher-value homes (up to about $5 million) in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Ohio and Illinois, including rentals in Maine and landlord homes in Massachusetts. We do not place condo or renters policies with Openly.
- ME
- NH
- MA
- CT
- OH
- IL

Patriot
We place Patriot homeowners, with capacity up to $3 million, in New Hampshire, Maine and Vermont, plus condo and renters coverage. Patriot auto is a New Hampshire market for us.
- ME
- NH
- VT

Plymouth Rock
We place Plymouth Rock home, auto, umbrella, renters and condo coverage in New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut and New York, and landlord homes in Massachusetts. We don’t quote Plymouth Rock in Maine.
- NH
- MA
- CT
- NY

Progressive
We place Progressive car insurance and renters coverage in all six New England states plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois, and we also look at Progressive for motorcycles, RVs, powersports and boats. We don’t write Progressive condo (HO-6) policies.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA
- RI
- CT
- NY
- FL
- OH
- IL

Providence Mutual
We place Providence Mutual homeowners, landlord and rental homes, condo and renters, apartment buildings and condo associations. Massachusetts is confirmed for apartment buildings and condo associations; Vermont and Rhode Island are confirmed for condo association master policies.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA
- RI
- CT

Safety
We place Safety auto, homeowners, condo, renters, dwelling fire, personal umbrella and habitational commercial coverage in Massachusetts, New Hampshire and Maine. In Massachusetts, Safety can write homes up to $3.5 million.
- ME
- NH
- MA

Stillwater
We place Stillwater homeowners, condo and renters coverage in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, and landlord homes in Massachusetts.
- ME
- NH
- MA
- CT

Vermont Mutual
We place Vermont Mutual homeowners and rental homes, condo unit owners, habitational commercial, and auto in Maine, Massachusetts and Vermont. It is our lead home and rental carrier in Vermont. Vermont Mutual also writes in New York.
- ME
- NH
- VT
- MA
- RI
- CT
- NY
Flood insurance is placed separately, including through the National Flood Insurance Program. Our flood markets write in every state we are licensed in, including New England plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois. None of the 17 company pages above list flood as a line we place with that carrier. See our flood insurance page, or request a quote.
No carriers in this list are tagged for that line. Try another filter, or request a quote and we will check the markets that fit.
Coverage we can help you place
Explore our main coverage pages, then come back here if you want to see which of these companies we use for a given line:
- Homeowners insurance
- Auto insurance
- Condo insurance in Connecticut and high-value home insurance in New Hampshire
- Renters insurance and landlord insurance
- Umbrella insurance and flood insurance
- Habitational commercial: Connecticut apartment buildings, Connecticut condo associations, Massachusetts apartment buildings and Massachusetts condo associations
You can also see how we choose carriers and browse all insurance products.
Our New Hampshire and Connecticut offices
We serve New England from two offices. Visit our New Hampshire insurance agency page or our Connecticut insurance agency page, including the Fairfield, CT office.
Ready to compare? Request a quote, or call us. We don’t charge additional fees.
Frequently asked questions
Which insurance companies does Portsmouth Atlantic represent?
We compare 40+ carriers. This page links the 17 companies we have dedicated pages for, from Andover to Vermont Mutual. The right carrier depends on the risk, the state and underwriting. Request a quote and we will compare the markets that fit.
Do you charge extra fees to place coverage with these carriers?
We don’t charge additional fees. Portsmouth Atlantic is a family-owned independent agency. We work for you, not for an insurance company.
I already have a policy with one of these companies. Can you help with billing or a claim?
Yes. If we placed the policy, start with our billing and claims contacts page, or call our New Hampshire office at (603) 431-4020 or our Connecticut office at (203) 859-6858 and we will help.
Can you write every carrier in every state you are licensed in?
No. Appointments and underwriting vary by company and state. We are licensed in all six New England states plus New York, Florida, Ohio and Illinois. Each card lists the states we have confirmed for that carrier. If you need a carrier in a state that isn’t listed, ask us and we will check. Some lines are limited even in a listed state — for example, we don’t write Progressive condo (HO-6) policies, and Openly is not a condo or renters market for us.
How do I get a quote?
Request a quote online, or call our New Hampshire office at (603) 431-4020 or our Connecticut office at (203) 859-6858. We have offices in Portsmouth, New Hampshire and Fairfield, Connecticut.
