Cincinnati Insurance, Quoted by an Independent Agency
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies were started in 1950 by independent agents, and they still sell only through independent agents. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency that writes Cincinnati in every state where we are licensed. We look at Cincinnati for larger homes at any dwelling limit, for yachts and for collector cars, and we compare it with 40+ other carriers before you choose. We don’t charge additional fees.
Where we write Cincinnati
- MEquoted
- NHquoted
- VTquoted
- MAquoted
- RIquoted
- CTquoted
- NYquoted
- FLquoted
- OHquoted
- ILquoted
We write Cincinnati in every state where Portsmouth Atlantic is licensed.
Who is Cincinnati Insurance?
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies were founded in 1950 by four small business owners who also ran their own independent insurance agencies. That origin still shapes the company: Cincinnati sells only through independent agents. The parent company, Cincinnati Financial Corporation, trades on Nasdaq as CINF, and the insurance companies are based in Fairfield, Ohio.
For families, Cincinnati’s personal lines include its Executive Capstone program for larger homes, plus auto, umbrella, valuables, and boat and yacht coverage. It is the kind of carrier that can put a household’s home, cars and watercraft with one insurer when the pieces fit.
Why Portsmouth Atlantic quotes Cincinnati
We write Cincinnati in all 10 states where we are licensed. Cincinnati writes homes at any dwelling limit, and it usually wants a dwelling of at least about $150,000, so it is mainly a carrier for established and larger homes rather than a starter house.
Cincinnati is also one of the markets we use for yachts, through its Capstone Yacht program for 20 to 80 feet and Capstone Oceania for 80 feet and up, and for collector cars. We quote Cincinnati car insurance in New England too, which matters when you want the home and the cars on one account.
For a longer look at Cincinnati’s high-value home program, see our Cincinnati Insurance review.
What we place with Cincinnati
- High-value homeswe place
- Homes in Connecticutwe place
- Car insurance (New England)we place
- Yachts (Capstone)we place
- Collector carswe place
- Valuables, umbrellacarrier offers; ask
Teal bars are confirmed for this page. Gold means Cincinnati publishes the coverage; ask us how it fits.
Cincinnati in three dates
- 1950Four independent agents found The Cincinnati Insurance Company.
- 1955AM Best’s first rating on record for The Cincinnati Insurance Company.
- 2026AM Best affirms A+ (Superior) for the property casualty group, March 5.
Sources: Cincinnati history page; AM Best rating disclosure and March 5, 2026 release.
Ratings and financial strength
AM Best A+ (Superior)
AM Best rates The Cincinnati Insurance Company and its property casualty subsidiaries A+ (Superior), with long-term issuer credit ratings of aa (Superior). AM Best affirmed those ratings on March 5, 2026, with a stable outlook. Cincinnati’s own financial strength page notes that only about the top 12% of property casualty groups receive an A+ or A++ from AM Best. Ratings can change. You can confirm Cincinnati’s current rating at ambest.com, and we confirm it when we quote.
Other agencies’ views
Cincinnati’s financial strength page also lists ratings from Fitch, Moody’s and S&P for its standard market property casualty companies. We confirm the current ratings of the company named on your quote.
Coverages Cincinnati offers
These are personal coverages Cincinnati publishes. Forms and options vary by state, and larger homes go through underwriting and may need an inspection before a policy is issued.
Homes, including Executive Capstone
Cincinnati’s home and condo pages cover standard homes and its Capstone forms for higher-value homes. See high-value home insurance, New Hampshire high-value homes and Connecticut high-value homes.
Car insurance
We quote Cincinnati auto in New England, often alongside the home. See auto insurance, New Hampshire auto and Connecticut auto.
Yachts
Capstone Yacht is built for vessels from 20 to 80 feet, and Capstone Oceania for yachts of 80 feet and up, generally $1 million and over with a full-time captain or crew. See boat and watercraft insurance.
Collector cars
Cincinnati is one of the carriers we use for collector cars. See collector car insurance.
Valuables and umbrella
Cincinnati publishes valuables and personal excess liability coverage. We can compare its umbrella with other options. See umbrella insurance.
Every policy is subject to Cincinnati underwriting. The right carrier depends on the property, the drivers, the location and your history. We will tell you when Cincinnati is a strong match and when another company we represent fits better.
Where we can place Cincinnati
We can place Cincinnati in all 10 states where we are licensed, including all six New England states: Maine, New Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Rhode Island and Connecticut. Cincinnati writes homes at any dwelling limit, subject to underwriting.
New Hampshire
We write Cincinnati in New Hampshire, including larger homes. See New Hampshire homeowners insurance and our New Hampshire insurance page.
Maine
Cincinnati is one of our Maine property carriers. See Maine homeowners and second-home insurance, Maine insurance and southern Maine insurance. We have no Maine office; we serve the state as a service area.
Vermont
We can place Cincinnati in Vermont. See Vermont homeowners and second-home insurance and Vermont high-value home insurance. We have no Vermont office.
Massachusetts
We can place Cincinnati in Massachusetts. See Massachusetts homeowners insurance and Massachusetts high-value home insurance. We have no Massachusetts office.
Rhode Island
We can place Cincinnati in Rhode Island. See Rhode Island homeowners and second-home insurance. We have no Rhode Island office.
Connecticut
We write Cincinnati homeowners insurance in Connecticut. See Connecticut homeowners insurance and our Connecticut insurance page.
Cincinnati for New Hampshire and Connecticut households
A Cincinnati quote makes the most sense when there is more than one thing to insure. A Lake Winnipesaukee house with a boat at the dock, a Fairfield County home with a classic car in the garage, or a Seacoast family with a primary home, a second home and teenage drivers: those are the accounts where one carrier for the home, the cars and the watercraft can simplify things.
We still compare it. Cincinnati and Chubb are similar high-value carriers, and Openly, National General, Hanover and Andover each fit certain homes well. Our job is to show you the differences in plain language.
Lake and coastal boats
See Lake Winnipesaukee boat insurance and Connecticut boat insurance.
Collector cars by state
See collector car insurance in New Hampshire, Connecticut and Massachusetts.
Where we work with you
Our New Hampshire office is at 601 Islington St, Unit 206, Portsmouth, NH 03801, (603) 431-4020. Our Connecticut office is at 1885 Post Rd, Fl 2, Fairfield, CT 06824, (203) 859-6858. We have no Maine office; we serve southern Maine as a service area. See all office locations.
How we quote Cincinnati
- Tell us what you need covered. Request a quote or call us. Share the address, the drivers or vehicles if auto is part of it, and any current policies you want compared.
- We check Cincinnati and other markets. We can write Cincinnati in every state where we are licensed. We look at Cincinnati alongside other carriers we represent for the same household.
- We explain the differences. You see how the forms, deductibles and eligibility compare, in plain language, before you choose. We don’t charge additional fees.
- You choose, and we stay with you. If you already have a Cincinnati policy, you can pay a bill or start a claim through our carrier accounts page, or call us and we will help.
How Cincinnati handles claims
Cincinnati describes a local claims approach that sits alongside the independent-agent relationship. Details can vary by the type of claim and where it happens. This page is about personal lines only; we do not place Cincinnati life or commercial coverage.
Local field claims representatives
Cincinnati uses field claims representatives who work in the same areas as the agencies they support. For many types of claims, those representatives often have authority to issue a check on the spot.
A claims representative for each agency
Cincinnati assigns a field claims representative to each agency, including ours, so there is already a familiar claims contact when a claim is filed.
Storm teams after a disaster
After a disaster, Cincinnati can send storm teams to handle claims in the affected area, in addition to the local field representatives already there.
What Cincinnati reports about claims satisfaction
Cincinnati says more than 90% of the standard-lines auto and property policyholders who answered its claims-satisfaction surveys from January 2020 through December 2022 were highly satisfied with the overall claims process.
Reviews of The Cincinnati Insurance Companies
Read more reviews of The Cincinnati Insurance Companies on Google
★★★★★
“… Dealing with another person’s insurance is usually a headache, but working with claims adjuster … completely changed my perspective. … Prompt & Consistent Communication: He kept me in the loop every step of the way. I never had to chase him down for updates or wonder what was happening with my claim. … If this is how Cincinnati Insurance treats people who aren’t even their paying customers, I can only imagine how well they treat their own clients. … Highly recommended!”
Alinda M. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“I had an outstanding experience working with … The Cincinnati Insurance Company. From start to finish, … provided truly exceptional service and made what could have been a stressful situation incredibly smooth and easy. … What impressed me the most was how quickly everything was handled. He coordinated directly with the repair shop, made the claims process seamless, and even helped me successfully process a diminished value claim without any hassle. … Highly, highly recommended!”
Azza H. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“… was my insurance adjuster after a house fire. She was professional and kept me updated on the progress of my claim during cleanup. She was very patient and explained insurance issues to me well. I would highly recommend her to anyone. If I could give her six stars I would!”
Jamie N. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“Great company to be insured by! They made recovering from a natural disaster better than expected. They were fair and kind throughout the process. I highly recommend them and will continue to use them for the foreseeable future.”
Chris F. · Google review · 5 stars
These are Google reviews of The Cincinnati Insurance Companies, the carrier, not of Portsmouth Atlantic.
What our clients say about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance
These five-star Google reviews are about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, our agency.
Reviews of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance on Google, 5.0★ from 596 reviews (as of Nov 12 2026)
★★★★★
“I had an excellent experience working with Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, especially with Natalie. … Natalie took the time to listen to my needs, understand what coverage I was looking for, and provided great advice and recommendations instead of just trying to sell a policy. … I highly recommend Natalie and the Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance team to anyone looking for honest guidance and excellent service!”
Fahim K. · Google review · 5 stars · 5 months ago
★★★★★
“Was great in the past, and still great today. When buying a home, they saw how stressed I was and took over most of the work for me to make it a smooth buying experience. Years later they pickup their phone on the first ring and always update my insurance within hours. Michael Chung did a good job today for me doing exactly that!”
Kevin B. · Google review · 5 stars · Edited 5 months ago
★★★★★
“We bought a new car and needed to cancel insurance on the old one and get insurance for the new car quickly. Rebecca Schweisthal couldn’t have been more helpful, thorough and professional to work with through this process! Thanks Rebecca!”
Wendy K. · Google review · 5 stars · Edited 5 months ago
Frequently asked questions
Who owns Cincinnati Insurance?
The Cincinnati Insurance Companies are owned by Cincinnati Financial Corporation, which trades on Nasdaq as CINF. The companies were founded in 1950 by independent agents and are based in Fairfield, Ohio.
Can I buy Cincinnati Insurance directly?
No. Cincinnati sells only through independent agents. Portsmouth Atlantic is an independent agency that writes Cincinnati in all 10 states where we are licensed.
What size home does Cincinnati write?
Cincinnati writes homes at any dwelling limit. It usually wants a dwelling of at least about $150,000, so it is most often a fit for established and larger homes.
What is Cincinnati’s AM Best rating?
AM Best rates Cincinnati’s property casualty group A+ (Superior), affirmed March 5, 2026, with a stable outlook. Ratings can change; you can confirm the current rating at ambest.com, and we confirm it when we quote.
Does Cincinnati insure yachts and collector cars?
Yes. We place yachts with Cincinnati through Capstone Yacht (20 to 80 feet) and Capstone Oceania (80 feet and up), and Cincinnati is one of our collector car carriers.
How do I get a Cincinnati quote, and do you charge fees?
Request a quote at our quote form, call our Portsmouth office at (603) 431-4020 or our Fairfield office at (203) 859-6858, or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com. We don’t charge additional fees. Hours at both offices are Monday through Thursday 9 AM to 5 PM and Friday 8 AM to 4 PM Eastern, closed weekends.
Tell us about your home, cars and watercraft and we will see whether Cincinnati is a fit, then compare it with other carriers we represent. We don’t charge additional fees. Request my quote or call (603) 431-4020 or (203) 859-6858.
Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM
Friday 8 AM–4 PM Eastern
Closed weekends
