Andover Companies Insurance, Quoted by a Local Independent Agency
The Andover Companies is a Massachusetts mutual insurance group that has insured New England property since 1828. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency. We quote Andover for home, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire, landlord and umbrella coverage, and for habitational commercial (apartment buildings and condo associations), in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut, and we compare it with 40+ other carriers so you can see the differences before you choose. We don’t charge additional fees.
Who is The Andover Companies?
The Andover Companies started in 1828, when town leaders in Andover, Massachusetts, formed Merrimack Mutual Fire so property owners could rebuild after a catastrophic fire. The company was owned by its policyholders. Merrimack later added Cambridge Mutual Fire Insurance Company in 1913 and Bay State in 1955. Those three insurers — now Merrimack Insurance, Cambridge Insurance and Bay State Insurance — still make up the group.
Andover describes itself as one of the largest and longest-standing mutual insurance groups in the Northeast. It sells personal and business property insurance only through independent agents, not through an Andover website quote or a call center. That is why a local agency like ours is how you get an Andover quote.
On January 1, 2026, Andover reorganized into a mutual holding company structure, The Andover Companies, Inc. Andover says the change keeps its mutual roots while giving the group more operating flexibility. It is still based in Massachusetts, at 95 Old River Rd. in Andover.
Why Portsmouth Atlantic quotes Andover
We work with 40+ carriers, and Andover is one we look at often for well-maintained homes and rental properties in the states where we write it. It is a New England company writing New England property. Its published personal lines are home, condo, renters, dwelling fire (landlord and investment property) and personal umbrella, plus habitational commercial coverage such as apartment buildings and condo association master policies.
Andover is on the list of companies we compare for high-value homes in Connecticut and elsewhere we are appointed, alongside other carriers we represent. If Andover is not the right fit for a particular house, we still have other markets to show you. You work with one agency either way, and we don’t charge additional fees.
For a longer agent’s-eye review of Andover’s home plan, see our Andover Companies home insurance review.
Ratings and financial strength
AM Best financial strength
Andover posts an AM Best financial strength rating of “A” (Excellent) for the Andover Companies Pool. The AM Best report on Andover’s site, effective September 25, 2025, affirms that A rating, an a+ long-term issuer credit rating, and a stable outlook for Merrimack Mutual Fire, Cambridge Mutual Fire and Bay State Insurance Company, the three members of the pool. Andover’s financials page says the group combined has been rated “A” (Excellent) or higher by AM Best since 1940. Ratings can change, so we confirm the current rating of the company named on your quote.
What Andover reports for 2025
On its financials page, Andover reports year-end 2025 figures of about $4.89 billion in assets, $3.08 billion in surplus, and $1.12 billion in premiums written. Those are Andover’s published numbers, not a guarantee of how any one claim will be paid. They are one reason we look at financial-strength ratings when we explain a carrier.
BBB accreditation
Andover’s website describes the group as a BBB accredited business with an A+ rating, and says it has held that accreditation for five years. We treat that as Andover’s statement and would confirm it at publish, because Bureau ratings can change.
A long record in the same rating band
Andover’s news page says AM Best’s monthly magazine honored its three subsidiaries for consistently maintaining an AM Best financial strength rating of A or higher for over 50, 75 and 100 years, respectively. That is Andover’s account of the recognition, and it lines up with the long A-or-higher record it publishes on its financials page.
Coverages Andover offers
These are the personal and habitational lines Andover publishes on its website. Availability and forms depend on the state, the property and underwriting. Andover’s personal-insurance pages do not list auto; when you need car insurance, we quote it from other carriers we represent and can still look at Andover for the property.
Homeowners
Andover’s main homeowners product is its Superior Home Insurance Protection Plan. Andover says the plan automatically includes ordinance or law coverage, personal property protection, replacement cost on contents, and open perils contents coverage (all risks except those the policy excludes). Optional add-ons it lists include scheduled personal property, water backup and sump overflow, home systems protection with service line coverage, identity recovery, home cyber protection, and a personal umbrella. Andover also lists credits an agent can check, such as protective devices, a new dwelling, customer loyalty, a hardwired generator and a non-smokers endorsement.
Condo (HO-6)
Andover writes condo unit owners coverage for a range of building types, including conversions and condexes. It says an HO-6 policy typically includes dwelling, personal property, loss of use, personal liability, medical payments to others, and loss assessment, and that the policy can be shaped around what the association’s master policy already covers. We can place Andover condo (HO-6) policies in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut. See our Portsmouth condo insurance and Connecticut condo insurance pages.
Renters
Andover offers renters insurance for personal property and liability. We can place Andover renters insurance in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut. If you rent in one of the states where we write Andover, we can compare it with other renters options we represent. Start at our renters insurance page.
Landlord and dwelling fire
Andover’s dwelling fire program is written for owners of residential rental and investment property, including a single-family home, a condo, or a building of up to four units. Andover says the policy typically covers the building and detached structures, and lists covered events that include fire, smoke, lightning, wind or hail, internal explosion, and vandalism. Added options may include the owner’s personal property in the building, loss of rental income after a covered event, and liability. See landlord insurance.
Personal umbrella
Andover describes its personal umbrella as an extra layer of worldwide liability protection, for example after an at-fault car accident or an incident at your property. Andover says you may be able to extend personal liability coverage up to $5 million, subject to its eligibility rules. We can also compare umbrella quotes from other carriers we represent. See umbrella insurance.
Apartment buildings and condo associations
When the risk is habitational commercial — apartment buildings and condo association master policies — Andover is one of the markets we use in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut. Portsmouth Atlantic writes only habitational commercial with Andover; we do not write Andover’s other business classes.
Every policy is subject to Andover underwriting. The right carrier depends on the property, the location and your history. We will tell you when Andover is a strong match and when another company we represent fits better.
Andover in New Hampshire and New England
Where we can place Andover
We can place Andover in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut for homeowners, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire, personal umbrella, and habitational commercial coverage (apartment buildings and condo associations), subject to underwriting. We cannot write Andover in Vermont. With Andover, Portsmouth Atlantic writes only habitational commercial — no other business classes.
If you need Andover in another state, ask us and we will check.
New Hampshire
We place Andover homeowners, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire, personal umbrella, and habitational commercial coverage (apartment buildings and condo associations) in New Hampshire. See New Hampshire homeowners insurance and our New Hampshire insurance page.
Maine
Andover is one of our Maine property carriers for homeowners, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire and personal umbrella, and a market for apartment buildings and condo association master policies. See Maine homeowners and second-home insurance, Maine insurance and southern Maine insurance. We have no Maine office; we serve the state as a service area.
Massachusetts
We place Andover homeowners, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire, personal umbrella, and habitational commercial coverage (apartment buildings and condo associations) in Massachusetts. See Massachusetts homeowners insurance, Massachusetts apartment building insurance, Massachusetts condo association insurance and our Massachusetts insurance page. We have no Massachusetts office.
Connecticut
We write Andover homeowners, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire, personal umbrella, apartment-building and condo association policies in Connecticut. See Connecticut homeowners insurance, Connecticut condo insurance, Connecticut landlord insurance, Connecticut apartment building insurance, Connecticut condo association insurance and our Connecticut insurance page.
Vermont
We cannot write Andover in Vermont. For Vermont homes and rentals we look at other carriers we represent.
That footprint matters here because so much of the housing we see is older, coastal, or both. Seacoast colonials, southern Maine year-round and second homes, North Shore houses, and Connecticut homes from the Post Road towns inland all share some of the same questions: what it costs to rebuild after a nor’easter, whether an older roof, wiring or heating system will be accepted, and whether ordinance or law coverage will help if building codes have changed since the house was built. Andover is a property company that has been answering those New England questions for a long time.
Older homes and rebuild rules
Andover says ordinance or law coverage is built into its Superior Home plan, and it offers home systems and service line coverage for breakdowns of things like boilers, well pumps and underground lines. Those are the conversations we have on many houses well over 50 years old. For larger or custom homes, see our New Hampshire high-value home and Connecticut high-value home pages.
Coastal homes and nor’easters
A homeowners policy is not a flood policy. Homes near the ocean, a tidal river or a marsh still need a separate flood quote, which we place with Selective for new NFIP policies or with a private flood market when that is a better fit. For wind, hail and water that backs up through a drain or sump, we look at the Andover form and at the deductibles, and we compare them with other carriers. Ask us about water backup and sump overflow if you have a finished basement.
Where we work with you
Our New Hampshire office is at 601 Islington St, Unit 206, Portsmouth, NH 03801, (603) 431-4020. Our Connecticut office is at 1885 Post Rd, Fl 2, Fairfield, CT 06824, (203) 859-6858. We have no Maine office; we serve southern Maine as a service area. Learn more about our New Hampshire, Fairfield, CT, Connecticut and southern Maine work, or see all office locations.
How we quote Andover
- Tell us about the property. Request a quote or call us. Share the address, how you use the home, and any other properties or policies you want compared.
- We check Andover and other markets. If the home is in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts or Connecticut, we can look at Andover alongside other carriers we represent for the same risk.
- We explain the differences. You will see how the forms, deductibles and eligibility compare, in plain language, before you choose. We don’t charge additional fees.
- You choose, and we stay with you. If you already have an Andover policy, you can manage it, pay a bill or start a claim through our carrier accounts page, or call us and we will help.
Andover claims service and coverage options
The Andover Companies dates to 1828. The group is made up of Merrimack Mutual Fire, Cambridge Mutual Fire and Bay State, and it works only with independent agents. AM Best has rated Andover A (Excellent) or higher. Ratings can change, and we confirm the current rating of the company named on your quote.
When a claim is filed
Response time
Andover aims to respond within 24 hours after a claim is filed.
On-site inspection
A qualified professional is assigned to inspect the loss on site.
Claims experience
Andover says its claims staff have an average of 23 years of experience.
Homeowner and rental options
Andover lists the following among coverages and options that may be available. What you can actually get depends on the policy, the property and the state.
For homeowners
Options Andover lists for homeowners include uncapped reconstruction cost, 100% ordinance or law, open-perils contents, home systems protection with service line, identity recovery, home cyber, scheduled personal property, condo unit owner coverage, personal umbrella and water backup.
For rental properties
For residential rental and investment properties, Andover lists extended replacement cost and fair rental value among the options that may be available, again depending on the policy and the state.
Reviews of The Andover Companies
Reviews of The Andover Companies on Google, 4.4★ from 294 reviews (as of Nov 12 2026)
★★★★★
“I’ve had an excellent experience working with Andover Companies. Their customer service is top-notch—always quick to respond and eager to help with any questions or concerns. The claims process is seamless and straightforward. … I highly recommend Andover to anyone seeking reliable and dependable insurance services!”
Courtney F. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“I had a very professional and friendly experience with the Andover Companies. All of the correspondence with my claims associate … were prompt and professional. She took the time to listen and show compassion and understanding. She also took the time to follow up with me and to answer all my question. Would highly recommend The Andover Companies!”
Jonathan L. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“The Andover Companies are fantastic! Their customer service is outstanding—always friendly, helpful, and quick to respond. … If you’re looking for an insurance company you can trust, The Andover Companies are an excellent choice. Highly recommend!”
Chris S. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“I’ve had a great experience with Andover Companies. Their professionalism and dedication to taking care of their insureds truly stand out. … I feel confident doing business with Andover and highly recommend them for anyone looking for a reliable, reasonably priced, and customer-focused insurance provider.”
David L. · Google review · 5 stars
These are Google reviews of The Andover Companies, the carrier, not of Portsmouth Atlantic.
What our clients say about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance
These five-star Google reviews are about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, our agency.
Reviews of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance on Google, 5.0★ from 596 reviews (as of Nov 12 2026)
★★★★★
“Always timely with communication and each step of the process was clearly explained.”
Jacob K. · Google review · 5 stars · 7 years ago
★★★★★
“What a great experience!”
Nina B. · Google review · 5 stars · Edited 3 years ago
★★★★★
“Dyan Martinez was so responsive and helpful!”
Kimberly M. · Google review · 5 stars · 8 months ago
Frequently asked questions
Who are The Andover Companies?
The Andover Companies is a Massachusetts mutual insurance group founded in 1828 in Andover, Massachusetts, as Merrimack Mutual Fire. It is made up of Merrimack Insurance, Cambridge Insurance and Bay State Insurance. Andover writes property and liability insurance through independent agents in Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, New York, New Jersey and Illinois.
What kinds of insurance does Andover write?
Andover’s published personal lines include homeowners, condo unit owners (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire for rental and investment property, and personal umbrella. It also writes habitational commercial coverage such as apartment buildings and condo association master policies. Its personal-insurance pages do not list auto. Portsmouth Atlantic can still quote auto from other carriers we represent. Through Portsmouth Atlantic, we can place those Andover lines in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut. The only commercial coverage we write with Andover is habitational; we do not write Andover’s other business classes.
Where can Portsmouth Atlantic quote Andover?
We quote Andover in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut for homeowners, condo (HO-6), renters, dwelling fire, personal umbrella, and habitational commercial coverage (apartment buildings and condo associations). We cannot write Andover in Vermont. Andover also lists Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey and Illinois on its own site; do not assume we are appointed there unless we confirm it for your property. If Andover is not available, we will quote other carriers we represent.
What is Andover’s AM Best rating?
Andover posts an AM Best financial strength rating of A (Excellent) for the Andover Companies Pool. The report on Andover’s site, effective September 25, 2025, affirms A, an a+ issuer credit rating, and a stable outlook for the three pool companies. Andover says the group has been rated A (Excellent) or higher by AM Best since 1940. We confirm the current rating when we quote.
Does Andover write auto insurance?
Andover’s published personal-insurance lineup is home, condo, renters, dwelling fire and personal umbrella. It does not list auto on those pages. If you need car insurance, we will quote it from other carriers we represent, and we can still look at Andover for your home, condo or rental.
How do I get an Andover quote, and do you charge fees?
Request a quote at our quote form, call our Portsmouth office at (603) 431-4020 or our Fairfield office at (203) 859-6858, or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com. We don’t charge additional fees. Hours at both offices are Monday through Thursday 9 AM to 5 PM and Friday 8 AM to 4 PM Eastern, closed weekends.
Tell us about your home, condo or rental and we will see whether Andover is a fit, then compare it with other carriers we represent. We don’t charge additional fees. Request my quote or call (603) 431-4020 or (203) 859-6858.
Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM
Friday 8 AM–4 PM Eastern
Closed weekends
