Providence Mutual Insurance, Quoted by an Independent Agency
Providence Mutual was founded in 1800, which makes it one of the oldest mutual insurers in the United States. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency that quotes Providence Mutual for homes and rental properties in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, for apartment buildings and condo association master policies in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut, and for condo association master policies in Vermont and Rhode Island. We compare it with 40+ other carriers first. We don’t charge additional fees.
Where we quote Providence Mutual
- MEquoted
- NHquoted
- VTquoted
- MAquoted
- RIquoted
- CTquoted
- NYask us
- FLask us
- OHask us
- ILask us
Confirmed for this page: homes and rentals in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut; apartment buildings and condo associations in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut; and condo association master policies in Vermont and Rhode Island.
Who is Providence Mutual?
Providence Mutual was founded in 1800 in Providence, Rhode Island, originally chartered to insure homes within a ten-mile radius of the city. The company says it has protected policyholders through events like the Great Nantucket Fire, the Hurricane of 1938 and Superstorm Sandy. It is a mutual company, owned by its policyholders, and is based at 340 East Avenue in Warwick, Rhode Island.
Providence Mutual partners with independent agents across the Northeast to offer property and casualty insurance for individuals, families and businesses.
Why Portsmouth Atlantic quotes Providence Mutual
We use Providence Mutual as a property carrier for homes and rentals, and it is one of a short list of markets we use for apartment buildings and condo association master policies. In Connecticut that list is Vermont Mutual, Andover and Providence Mutual.
For the owner of a three-family in New Haven County or a 12-unit building in Fairfield County, that short list matters. We put Providence Mutual next to the other habitational markets and explain the differences in how each one looks at the building.
What we place with Providence Mutual
- Homeownerswe place
- Landlord / rental homeswe place
- Apartment buildings (5+ units)we place
- Condo associationswe place
- Condo and renterswe place
- Umbrellacarrier offers; ask
On the commercial side we use Providence Mutual for habitational risks only.
Providence Mutual through the years
- 1800Founded in Providence, RI, to insure homes within ten miles of the city.
- 1938Paid claims through the Hurricane of 1938.
- 2023Withdrew from AM Best’s rating process; rated by Demotech and KBRA.
- 2026Demotech affirms A′ (A Prime), September 14.
Sources: Providence Mutual, Who We Are and June 30, 2023 statement; Demotech.
Ratings and financial strength
Demotech A′ (A Prime)
Demotech lists a Financial Stability Rating of A′ (A Prime), Unsurpassed, for Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Company, affirmed September 14, 2026.
KBRA A-
Providence Mutual reports an A- (Excellent) rating from Kroll Bond Rating Agency. KBRA’s most recent public release we found, from April 2024, affirmed A- with a stable outlook.
About AM Best
Providence Mutual withdrew from AM Best’s rating process in June 2023 and explained its reasons in a public statement. We note it so you aren’t surprised if you look the company up there.
Coverages we place with Providence Mutual
We use Providence Mutual for property: homes, condos, renters, rentals and habitational commercial risks.
Homeowners
Dwelling fire and landlord
See Connecticut landlord insurance and Massachusetts landlord insurance.
Apartment buildings
See Connecticut apartment buildings, Massachusetts apartment buildings and Maine apartment buildings.
Condo associations
See Connecticut condo associations, Massachusetts condo associations and Maine condo associations.
Condo owners and renters
Every policy is subject to Providence Mutual underwriting. The right carrier depends on the property, the drivers, the location and your history. We will tell you when Providence Mutual is a strong match and when another company we represent fits better.
Where we can place Providence Mutual
We can place Providence Mutual in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts, Vermont, Rhode Island and Connecticut, as follows, subject to underwriting.
New Hampshire
Providence Mutual is one of the carriers we compare for New Hampshire homes, and it is a market for apartment buildings and condo association master policies. See New Hampshire homeowners insurance and our New Hampshire insurance page.
Maine
Providence Mutual is one of our Maine property carriers, and a market for apartment buildings and condo association master policies. See Maine homeowners and second-home insurance, Maine apartment building insurance, Maine condo association insurance, Maine insurance and southern Maine insurance. We have no Maine office; we serve the state as a service area.
Vermont
In Vermont, we use Providence Mutual for condo association master policies. See Vermont homeowners and second-home insurance. We have no Vermont office.
Massachusetts
In Massachusetts, we use Providence Mutual for apartment buildings and condo association master policies. See Massachusetts apartment building insurance and Massachusetts condo association insurance. We have no Massachusetts office.
Rhode Island
In Rhode Island, we use Providence Mutual for condo association master policies. See Rhode Island homeowners and second-home insurance. We have no Rhode Island office.
Connecticut
We write Providence Mutual homeowners, landlord, apartment-building and condo association policies in Connecticut. See Connecticut homeowners insurance, Connecticut landlord insurance, Connecticut apartment building insurance, Connecticut condo association insurance and our Connecticut insurance page.
Providence Mutual for people who own property to rent
Providence Mutual is a Northeast company that knows coastal weather; it has been paying claims through New England storms for more than two centuries. For us, its strongest role is with people who own property to rent: multi-family houses, small apartment buildings and condo associations.
We also quote it for owner-occupied homes in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut, alongside our other property carriers.
Landlords
Associations
See Connecticut condo associations and small Massachusetts condo associations.
Where we work with you
Our New Hampshire office is at 601 Islington St, Unit 206, Portsmouth, NH 03801, (603) 431-4020. Our Connecticut office is at 1885 Post Rd, Fl 2, Fairfield, CT 06824, (203) 859-6858. We have no Maine office; we serve southern Maine as a service area. See all office locations.
How we quote Providence Mutual
- Tell us what you need covered. Request a quote or call us. Share the address, the drivers or vehicles if auto is part of it, and any current policies you want compared.
- We check Providence Mutual and other markets. If the property is in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts or Connecticut, we can look at Providence Mutual. We look at Providence Mutual alongside other carriers we represent for the same property.
- We explain the differences. You see how the forms, deductibles and eligibility compare, in plain language, before you choose. We don’t charge additional fees.
- You choose, and we stay with you. If you already have a Providence Mutual policy, you can pay a bill or start a claim through our carrier accounts page, or call us and we will help.
Reviews of Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Company
Reviews of Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Co on Google, 3.6★ from 127 reviews (as of Nov 12 2026)
★★★★★
“We have been Providence Mutual customers for almost 10 yrs. Everyone we’ve dealt with has been highly professional and helpful. Unfortunately in 2025 we had an accident, … couldn’t have been more helpful every step of the way! Our repair shop was impressed with the communication, response time and ease of dealing with Providence Mutual. Thank you!”
Cynthia H. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“Had to file a claim after a huge snowstorm for roof damage and missing shingles. Providence Mutual adjuster came within a day to assess the damage and made it easy to have the repairs made. Was very pleased with the outcome and ease of filing the claim.”
Nancy G. · Google review · 5 stars
★★★★★
“We recently had a claim for home damage that was handled promptly and professionally from beginning to end by our claims representative, … He was knowledgeable, professional and readily available, and helped us to hire a very competent contractor to make the necessary repairs in a timely manner. Very glad to have Providence Mutual …”
Robert B. · Google review · 5 stars
These are Google reviews of Providence Mutual Fire Insurance Company, the carrier, not of Portsmouth Atlantic.
What our clients say about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance
These five-star Google reviews are about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, our agency.
Reviews of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance on Google, 5.0★ from 596 reviews (as of Nov 12 2026)
★★★★★
“Brian and his team were responsive, flexible, and accommodating. They took the time to explain different aspects of coverage and made sure we understood and were comfortable with our decisions. They also found us excellent rates and significant savings with better coverage than our prior carrier!”
Annecca S. · Google review · 5 stars · 7 months ago
★★★★★
“Just switched my home and auto insurance coverage for the first time in years, and grateful to have had Jon and his team guide me through the process. Incredibly responsive, friendly and professional. They found me an excellent set of products and really did their best to facilitate a smooth and painless transition. Fully intend to remain a long-term client!”
Alexander G. · Google review · 5 stars · 8 months ago
★★★★★
“I have been a happy customer for over 10 years. I always refer friends, family and coworkers to PAI for the best rates, friendly, professional customer service and because they are a local, family owned and operated business. *update* It has been another wonderful experience working with Jon and the team at Portsmouth Atlantic. I appreciate how knowledgeable and responsive you all have been during this process.”
Evan M. · Google review · 5 stars · Edited 8 months ago
Frequently asked questions
How old is Providence Mutual?
Providence Mutual was founded in 1800 in Providence, Rhode Island. It is a mutual company owned by its policyholders and based in Warwick, Rhode Island.
Does Providence Mutual have an AM Best rating?
Providence Mutual withdrew from AM Best’s rating process in 2023. It reports a Demotech Financial Stability Rating of A′ (A Prime), affirmed September 14, 2026, and an A- rating from KBRA.
Does Providence Mutual insure apartment buildings and condo associations?
Yes. It is one of our markets for apartment buildings of five or more units and condo association master policies in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut, and for condo association master policies in Vermont and Rhode Island.
Where does Portsmouth Atlantic quote Providence Mutual?
We can place Providence Mutual for homes and rental properties in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, for apartment buildings and condo association master policies in New Hampshire, Maine, Massachusetts and Connecticut, and for condo association master policies in Vermont and Rhode Island.
How do I get a Providence Mutual quote, and do you charge fees?
Request a quote at our quote form, call our Portsmouth office at (603) 431-4020 or our Fairfield office at (203) 859-6858, or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com. We don’t charge additional fees. Hours at both offices are Monday through Thursday 9 AM to 5 PM and Friday 8 AM to 4 PM Eastern, closed weekends.
Tell us about your home, rental or building and we will see whether Providence Mutual is a fit, then compare it with other carriers we represent. We don’t charge additional fees. Request my quote or call (603) 431-4020 or (203) 859-6858.
Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM
Friday 8 AM–4 PM Eastern
Closed weekends
