Stillwater Insurance, Quoted by a Local Independent Agency

Stillwater Insurance Group is a national personal lines insurer based in Jacksonville, Florida. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency that quotes Stillwater for homes in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, and for landlord homes in Massachusetts. We compare it with 40+ other carriers so you can weigh the trade-offs. We don’t charge additional fees.

AM Best B++ (Good)Financial strength, affirmed June 17, 2026, stable outlook
Demotech A (Exceptional)Financial stability rating Stillwater reports
All 50 statesStillwater says it serves customers nationwide
1,000+ Google reviewsand over 2,000 testimonials for Portsmouth Atlantic

Financial strength at a glance

B++ (Good)AM Best rating for Stillwater Insurance Company and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company, affirmed June 17, 2026, stable outlook.
  • A++
  • A+
  • A
  • A-
  • B++
  • B+
AM Best’s highest gradelower grades continue

Sources: AM Best Credit Rating Center; Stillwater, About Us. We confirm the company on your quote.

Where we quote Stillwater

  • MEquoted
  • NHquoted
  • VTask us
  • MAquoted
  • RIask us
  • CTquoted
  • NYask us
  • FLask us
  • OHask us
  • ILask us
Confirmed for this pageAsk us (not confirmed here)

Confirmed for this page: Stillwater homes in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, and landlord homes in Massachusetts.

Who is Stillwater?

Stillwater began in 2000 as the property and casualty arm of Fidelity National Financial. In 2012, a group of investors led by its management bought the business, and it was rebranded as Stillwater Insurance Group. The group is made up of Stillwater Insurance Company, Stillwater Insurance Services, Inc. and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company.

Its home office is at 6800 Southpoint Parkway in Jacksonville, Florida, with offices in Jericho, New York and Omaha, Nebraska. Stillwater says it serves customers in all 50 states with personal insurance products, including home, auto, renters and condo, and a growing line of commercial products.

Why Portsmouth Atlantic quotes Stillwater

We include Stillwater in our home comparisons in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, and we place it for Massachusetts landlord homes. It is one more option to show you, so the decision is based on the actual forms and terms rather than on a single quote.

We are plain about ratings on every carrier page. Stillwater’s AM Best rating is B++ (Good), a different tier from the A-range carriers we also represent. We show you the rating of the company named on your quote and talk through what it means for you.

What we place with Stillwater

  • Homeownerswe place
  • Landlord homes in Massachusettswe place
  • Condo and renterswe place
  • Car insurancecarrier offers; ask
  • Umbrellacarrier offers; ask

Each line is subject to Stillwater underwriting and state availability.

Stillwater in brief

  • 2000Founded as Fidelity National Property and Casualty Insurance Group.
  • 2012Management-led investors buy the business; it is rebranded Stillwater Insurance Group.
  • 2026AM Best affirms B++ (Good), June 17.

Sources: Stillwater, About Us; AM Best.

Ratings and financial strength

AM Best B++ (Good)

AM Best rates Stillwater Insurance Company and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company B++ (Good) for financial strength, with a stable outlook, affirmed June 17, 2026. AM Best assigns B++ to insurers it considers to have a good ability to meet their ongoing insurance obligations.

Demotech and BBB

Stillwater reports an A (Exceptional) financial stability rating from Demotech, Inc. and an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau.

Coverages we place with Stillwater

Stillwater publishes home, auto, renters, condo, landlord and business coverage. We use it for homes in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, and for landlord homes in Massachusetts.

Landlord homes in Massachusetts

We can place Stillwater landlord homes in Massachusetts. See Massachusetts landlord insurance.

Every policy is subject to Stillwater underwriting. The right carrier depends on the property, the drivers, the location and your history. We will tell you when Stillwater is a strong match and when another company we represent fits better.

Where we can place Stillwater

We can place Stillwater in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut for homes, and in Massachusetts for landlord homes, subject to underwriting.

If you need Stillwater in another state, ask us and we will check.

New Hampshire

Stillwater is one of the carriers we compare for New Hampshire homes. See New Hampshire homeowners insurance and our New Hampshire insurance page.

Maine

Stillwater is one of our Maine property carriers, including homes, condos and renters. See Maine homeowners and second-home insurance, Maine insurance and southern Maine insurance. We have no Maine office; we serve the state as a service area.

Massachusetts

We can place Stillwater landlord homes in Massachusetts. See Massachusetts landlord insurance. We have no Massachusetts office.

Connecticut

We write Stillwater homeowners policies in Connecticut. See Connecticut homeowners insurance and our Connecticut insurance page.

Stillwater in our home comparisons

Stillwater tends to come up for everyday homes: a ranch in Rochester, a cape in Sanford, a colonial in a Connecticut suburb. We put it alongside our regional and national carriers and show you how the deductibles, roof terms and endorsements compare.

For homes on the water or in a flood zone, we quote flood separately, because a homeowners policy doesn’t cover flood.

Flood is separate

See flood insurance and Seacoast NH flood insurance.

Where we work with you

Our New Hampshire office is at 601 Islington St, Unit 206, Portsmouth, NH 03801, (603) 431-4020. Our Connecticut office is at 1885 Post Rd, Fl 2, Fairfield, CT 06824, (203) 859-6858. We have no Maine office; we serve southern Maine as a service area. See all office locations.

How we quote Stillwater

  1. Tell us what you need covered. Request a quote or call us. Share the address, the drivers or vehicles if auto is part of it, and any current policies you want compared.
  2. We check Stillwater and other markets. If the home is in New Hampshire, Maine or Connecticut, or it is a Massachusetts rental, we can look at Stillwater. We look at Stillwater alongside other carriers we represent for the same home.
  3. We explain the differences. You see how the forms, deductibles and eligibility compare, in plain language, before you choose. We don’t charge additional fees.
  4. You choose, and we stay with you. If you already have a Stillwater policy, you can pay a bill or start a claim through our carrier accounts page, or call us and we will help.

Reviews of Stillwater Insurance Group

[Insert verified 5-star Google reviews]

Placeholder for verbatim five-star Google reviews of Stillwater Insurance Group, the carrier (not Portsmouth Atlantic). Collect them from the carrier’s Google listing, then run insert_reviews.py. Do not publish this page with the placeholder showing.

This section is for Google reviews of Stillwater Insurance Group, the carrier, not of Portsmouth Atlantic.

What our clients say about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance

These five-star Google reviews are about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, our agency.

Reviews of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance on Google, 5.0★ from 596 reviews (as of Nov 12 2026)

★★★★★

“Rebecca is a standout service provider on an all-star team! … Rebecca recently took time to help us fix and error on the part of the carrier. After we resolved that issue, she took time to look critically at the amount of coverage we were carrying. She helped us to align our coverage with our risk tolerance and we saved a great deal on premiums without being exposed to unreasonable risk!”

Philip L. · Google review · 5 stars · 2 years ago

★★★★★

“I can’t say enough about Mike, he solves every problem that I present with quickly and accurately. I would recommend him highly and Atlantic as well!”

Suzanne D. · Google review · 5 stars · Edited 2 months ago

★★★★★

“Rebecca and the whole team are amazing! I have been a customer for a long time and will continue with them!”

Holly S. · Google review · 5 stars · 3 months ago

Frequently asked questions

Where is Stillwater Insurance based?

Stillwater Insurance Group’s home office is at 6800 Southpoint Parkway in Jacksonville, Florida.

What is Stillwater’s AM Best rating?

AM Best rates Stillwater Insurance Company and Stillwater Property and Casualty Insurance Company B++ (Good), with a stable outlook, affirmed June 17, 2026. Stillwater also reports a Demotech A (Exceptional) rating.

What does Portsmouth Atlantic write with Stillwater?

We can place Stillwater homes in New Hampshire, Maine and Connecticut, and Stillwater landlord homes in Massachusetts.

How do I get a Stillwater quote, and do you charge fees?

Request a quote at our quote form, call our Portsmouth office at (603) 431-4020 or our Fairfield office at (203) 859-6858, or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com. We don’t charge additional fees. Hours at both offices are Monday through Thursday 9 AM to 5 PM and Friday 8 AM to 4 PM Eastern, closed weekends.

Tell us about your home and we will see whether Stillwater is a fit, then compare it with other carriers we represent. We don’t charge additional fees. Request my quote or call (603) 431-4020 or (203) 859-6858.

Portsmouth, NH office
601 Islington St, Unit 206
Portsmouth, NH 03801
(603) 431-4020
Fairfield, CT office
1885 Post Rd, Fl 2
Fairfield, CT 06824
(203) 859-6858
Hours (both offices)
Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM
Friday 8 AM–4 PM Eastern
Closed weekends
Call Email Claims Payments