Agencies · Massachusetts coast · North Shore and South Shore
By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Published October 19, 2026 · Google data checked October 19, 2026
- We profiled 10 local independent insurance agencies: five on the North Shore (Newburyport to Marblehead) and five on the South Shore (Hingham to Scituate and Hanover).
- Richardson Insurance in Hanover (352 Google reviews) and Sterling Insurance Agency in Beverly (212) had the most reviews on each shore as of October 2026.
- Founding years on the agencies’ own sites run from 1854 (Farquhar & Black, Salem) to 1988 (Logue Insurance, Manchester-by-the-Sea).
- The Massachusetts Division of Insurance says the largest coastal wind deductibles are in counties that include Plymouth County, home to Hingham, Scituate, Marshfield and Duxbury.
- Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is licensed in Massachusetts and serves both shores from Portsmouth, NH. We have no Massachusetts office.
Looking for an independent insurance agency on the North Shore or South Shore of Massachusetts? The two shores look alike from a boat, but they insure differently. The North Shore runs from the Merrimack River at Newburyport down through Cape Ann, Manchester-by-the-Sea, Beverly Farms and Marblehead, with granite ledges, harbors and many older homes. The South Shore runs from Hingham and Cohasset through Scituate, Marshfield and Duxbury, with barrier beaches, marshes and some of the state’s more exposed coastline. This guide lists local independent agencies on each shore, with their Google ratings and review counts as of October 2026 and what each one says it does. We’re Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, an independent agency based in Portsmouth, NH and licensed in Massachusetts, so we’ve included ourselves at the end and explained exactly how we built the list.

How we chose these agencies
- Date checked. We read each Google rating and review count from the office’s public Google Maps listing on October 19, 2026, between about 8:30 and 8:50 AM Eastern.
- Where. North Shore: offices in or next to Newburyport, Ipswich, Gloucester, Manchester-by-the-Sea, Beverly, Salem and Marblehead. South Shore: offices in or next to Hingham, Cohasset, Scituate, Norwell, Hanover, Marshfield and Duxbury.
- Independent agencies only. Each agency says on its own website (or, for one, on an insurer’s independent-agent locator) that it can offer more than one insurance company. We left out captive agents (such as State Farm, Allstate and Farmers), AAA, insurance companies, health-and-Medicare-only agencies and public adjusters.
- Local agencies first. We left out the local offices of large national brokers, with one exception: the Marblehead office long known locally as Joe Greene and later Garrity Insurance, which now operates as Relation Insurance.
- Not a quality ranking. Within each shore, the table is sorted by Google review count. Ratings are shown for reference. A small office with a dozen reviews can be an excellent fit.
- Founding years. Taken from each agency’s own website. Where an agency doesn’t list one, we say so rather than guess.
- Our own agency. We have no Massachusetts office, so we are not in the tables. We describe our agency separately below.
Disclosure: Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote and publishes this page. We did not contact, pay or receive anything from the agencies listed. Counts change daily; the live Google listing is always the current number. For the statewide picture, see our New England agency review-count study.
Source: Google Maps listings, checked October 19, 2026. Each bar is a single office listing.
North Shore independent insurance agencies
| Agency (Google listing) | Town | Founded (per its website) | Google rating | Google reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sterling Insurance Agency | Beverly | 1929 | 4.9 | 212 |
| Farquhar & Black Insurance Agency | Salem | 1854 | 4.9 | 79 |
| Arthur S. Page Insurance | Newburyport | 100+ years | 4.9 | 70 |
| Relation Insurance – Marblehead (formerly Garrity Insurance) | Marblehead | Not listed | 4.5 | 22 |
| Logue Insurance Agency | Manchester-by-the-Sea | 1988 | 4.9 | 19 |
Sterling Insurance Agency, Beverly
Sterling says it has been an independent agency in Beverly since 1929, now at 186 Cabot Street. Its site covers home, condo, boat, umbrella and investment-property insurance, and says it has multiple markets for flood. It had the most Google reviews of any North Shore office we checked. (Not to be confused with Sterling Insurance Group, a separate agency on Martha’s Vineyard.)
Farquhar & Black Insurance Agency, Salem
Farquhar & Black describes itself as a family-owned Trusted Choice independent agency serving Massachusetts since 1854, which makes it the oldest agency on this list by founding year. Its site lists personal and business insurance and the North Shore’s history of fires, storms and floods that it has worked through with clients.
Arthur S. Page Insurance, Newburyport
Arthur S. Page says it has insured greater Newburyport for more than 100 years from its State Street office. Its site lists home, auto, umbrella, watercraft, RV and business coverage, with evening and weekend appointments available. See our Newburyport home insurance page for the city’s historic-home and flood questions.
Relation Insurance, Marblehead (formerly Garrity Insurance)
The 122 Washington Street office in Marblehead is the one Garrity Insurance called its Joe Greene office. Relation Insurance acquired Garrity in 2022, and the office now offers Relation’s personal lines, including home, auto, boat and yacht, umbrella and high-net-worth coverage, alongside business insurance. Our Marblehead home insurance page covers the town’s ledge-top and harbor homes.
Logue Insurance Agency, Manchester-by-the-Sea
Logue calls itself a coastal independent agency, family owned and operated since 1988, on Central Street downtown. Its site highlights homeowners, flood (with access to several flood insurers), auto, watercraft and business insurance. Our Manchester-by-the-Sea and Beverly and Beverly Farms pages go deeper on homes in this stretch.
South Shore independent insurance agencies
| Agency (Google listing) | Town | Founded (per its website) | Google rating | Google reviews |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Richardson Insurance | Hanover | 1930 | 5.0 | 352 |
| AW Family Insurance | Hingham | Not listed | 5.0 | 197 |
| Lallis & Higgins Insurance | Rockland (also Weymouth) | Not listed | 4.8 | 196 |
| Austin Insurance Agency | Norwell | Not listed | 4.9 | 58 |
| Murphy Carty Insurance | Scituate Harbor | 1947 | 4.7 | 16 |
Richardson Insurance, Hanover
Richardson says it started in 1930 and has served the South Shore ever since from Hanover Street. It describes itself as 100% independent and says it represents insurers writing in Massachusetts, New Hampshire, Maine, Vermont and Rhode Island. It had the most Google reviews of any office on either shore.
AW Family Insurance, Hingham
AW Family Insurance is a local independent agency on Derby Street in Hingham. Its site lists auto, home, life and business insurance, and it is listed on an insurer’s independent-agent locator. It had the second-highest review count on the South Shore. Our Hingham home insurance page covers the harbor, historic and wooded parts of town.
Lallis & Higgins Insurance, Rockland
Lallis & Higgins works from Rockland and Weymouth. Its site has dedicated pages for coastal home, vacation and second-home, flood, condo and boat insurance, which fits owners with a house near the water and another inland.
Austin Insurance Agency, Norwell
Austin Insurance is on Washington Street in Norwell, between Hingham, Scituate and Hanover. Its site lists home, condo, boat, flood and umbrella coverage and the insurance companies it represents, and notes its membership in ISNE, a network of independent agencies.
Murphy Carty Insurance, Scituate Harbor
Murphy Carty says it has served Scituate and nearby towns since 1947 from Front Street in Scituate Harbor. Its site lists home, flood, boat, umbrella and surplus and excess lines for harder-to-place properties. Our Scituate home insurance page covers oceanfront, harbor and Humarock homes.
Other local offices we found on the same searches, without full profiles: Leslie S. Ray Insurance (Beverly), Prince Insurance (Gloucester), Duffy Insurance and the Charles A. Slee agency (Marblehead), McGunnigle Insurance and John J. Lawless Insurance (Hingham), O’Donoghue Insurance (Cohasset) and Hannon-Murphy Insurance (Plymouth). Large regional agencies such as Cross Insurance also have offices on both shores.
We’re licensed in Massachusetts and compare 40+ carriers from our Portsmouth, NH office. We don’t charge additional fees.
Talk to our team: (603) 431-4020 · Request a coverage review
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance: serving both shores from Portsmouth, NH
We’re an independent, family-owned agency founded in 2005 in Portsmouth, NH, and licensed in Massachusetts among 10 states. We don’t have a Massachusetts office. We work with North Shore and South Shore homeowners from Portsmouth by phone and email or in person at our office, and many of our Massachusetts clients also own a home or have family in New Hampshire or Maine.
- Carriers. We compare 40+ carriers. For larger coastal homes that includes Chubb and Cincinnati, which write homes at any dwelling limit, and Openly, which we’re appointed with in Massachusetts. Our how we choose carriers page explains how we match them.
- Flood. We place new NFIP flood policies through Selective and quote private flood through Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge where they write the property.
- Reviews. We’re New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. Our Portsmouth listing is rated 5.0 as of October 2026. Read our client feedback.
- No fees. We don’t charge additional fees.
Town guides for the coast: Newburyport, Ipswich, Gloucester, Rockport, Manchester-by-the-Sea, Beverly, Salem, Marblehead, Swampscott, Hull, Hingham, Cohasset, Scituate, Marshfield, Duxbury and Plymouth.
What to look for in a coastal Massachusetts insurance agency
Any agency on this list can quote a price. On the coast, the questions below separate a policy that pays the way you expect from one that surprises you after a nor’easter. Our coastal Massachusetts high-value home insurance guide covers each one in more depth.
Wind and named-storm deductibles, in dollars
Most Massachusetts home insurers use a separate wind or named-storm deductible near the coast. The Division of Insurance says it usually runs from 1% to 5% of the home’s insured value, can sometimes be a flat amount, and may apply per storm, per season or per year. In its report on the 2024 home insurance market, the Division found that all but four of the top 25 home insurers reported mandatory wind deductibles, with the largest in the coastal parts of Bristol, Plymouth, Barnstable, Dukes and Nantucket counties. On a $2 million dwelling limit, a 2% deductible is $40,000, so ask any agency to show the deductible in dollars and compare it across quotes.
| Where the home is (outside Cape Cod and the Islands) | Massachusetts FAIR Plan minimum named-storm deductible, higher dwelling limits |
|---|---|
| Within half a mile of the coast | 2% of the dwelling limit |
| More than half a mile from the coast | A flat-dollar minimum instead of a percentage |
The FAIR Plan is the state’s insurer of last resort for homes that can’t find coverage in the regular market. Its rules are a useful benchmark because they’re published; private carriers set their own, and two quotes on the same Scituate or Marblehead house can treat a named storm very differently.
Flood is a separate policy
Homeowners policies exclude flood, and storm surge is flood. NFIP building coverage for a home tops out at $250,000 and contents at $100,000, which is often well below the rebuild cost of a waterfront house in Duxbury, Cohasset or Manchester-by-the-Sea. Ask whether the agency can quote private flood or excess flood over an NFIP policy, and whether it will use your elevation certificate. NFIP coverage usually starts 30 days after purchase, so line it up before a closing or storm season. See our flood insurance page and our guide to coastal flood and wind risk in New England.
Rebuild cost on high-value and historic homes
Carriers insure what it would cost to rebuild, not the sale price. A First Period house in Ipswich, a Federal-style captain’s house in Newburyport or a shingle-style home on a Marblehead ledge can cost far more to rebuild than its square footage suggests. Ask whether the agency will arrange an on-site appraisal, how extended replacement cost works on each quote, and how ordinance or law coverage handles rebuilding to current flood and building codes.
Seasonal homes, condos and boats
- Second homes. If the house sits empty part of the year or is rented in summer, the policy has to say so. Our Massachusetts second-home and vacation home insurance guide explains occupancy and rental questions.
- Two-unit condos. Some older North Shore and South Shore houses have been converted into two- or three-unit condos. Our Massachusetts condex insurance guide explains how the master policy and each unit owner’s HO-6 fit together.
- Boats and liability. Harbor towns from Newburyport to Duxbury mean moorings, docks and guests. Ask about boat insurance and an umbrella policy that sits over the home, cars and boat.
- Is the agency independent, and which carriers can it quote for a home this close to the water?
- What is the wind or named-storm deductible on each quote, in dollars?
- Can it quote private or excess flood, not just NFIP?
- How did it set the dwelling limit, and will it arrange a rebuild-cost appraisal?
- Is it licensed in every state where you own a home or a boat?
Frequently asked questions
Which independent insurance agencies serve the North Shore of Massachusetts?
Among the local independent agency offices we checked on October 19, 2026, Sterling Insurance Agency in Beverly had the most Google reviews (212, rated 4.9), followed by Farquhar & Black in Salem (79, rated 4.9) and Arthur S. Page Insurance in Newburyport (70, rated 4.9). Relation Insurance in Marblehead, formerly Garrity Insurance, and Logue Insurance in Manchester-by-the-Sea also serve the coastal North Shore. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is licensed in Massachusetts and serves North Shore homeowners from its Portsmouth, NH office.
Which independent insurance agencies serve the South Shore of Massachusetts?
Richardson Insurance in Hanover had the most Google reviews of the South Shore offices we checked on October 19, 2026 (352, rated 5.0). AW Family Insurance in Hingham (197, rated 5.0) and Lallis & Higgins Insurance in Rockland (196, rated 4.8) were close behind, followed by Austin Insurance Agency in Norwell and Murphy Carty Insurance in Scituate Harbor. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance also insures South Shore homes from Portsmouth, NH.
Do South Shore homes have bigger wind deductibles than North Shore homes?
They can. The Massachusetts Division of Insurance found that the largest mandatory wind deductibles in its review of the 2024 home insurance market were in the coastal parts of Bristol, Plymouth, Barnstable, Dukes and Nantucket counties. Hingham, Hull, Scituate, Marshfield and Duxbury are in Plymouth County. North Shore homes in Essex County can still carry a wind or named-storm deductible, so ask any agency to show yours in dollars.
Does homeowners insurance cover storm surge on the Massachusetts coast?
No. Storm surge and coastal flooding are flood, and flood is excluded from standard homeowners policies. You need a separate flood policy from the National Flood Insurance Program or a private flood insurer. NFIP coverage usually starts 30 days after purchase, with some exceptions, such as a policy bought with a new mortgage.
Can an insurance agency in New Hampshire insure my Massachusetts home?
Yes, if the agency holds a Massachusetts license. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is licensed in Massachusetts and nine other states. We don’t have a Massachusetts office; we insure North Shore and South Shore homes from our Portsmouth, NH office, by phone and email or in person at our office.
Why isn’t Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance in the tables?
The tables list Google listings for offices on the North Shore and South Shore. Our only Massachusetts presence is our license, and our office is in Portsmouth, NH, so we describe our agency separately and apply the same rule we used in our New England review-count study.
Sources
- Google Maps business listings for each agency named, ratings and review counts read on October 19, 2026, about 8:30 to 8:50 AM Eastern. Counts change daily; check the live listing.
- Each agency’s own website, read October 19, 2026, for founding years and the coverage it describes. Relation Insurance press release, “Relation Insurance Services Acquires Garrity Insurance,” November 15, 2022.
- Massachusetts Division of Insurance, consumer guidance on wind and hurricane deductibles and its report on the 2024 Massachusetts homeowners insurance market.
- Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association (MPIUA), Named Storm Quick Reference, as of October 2026.
- FEMA and FloodSmart (NFIP): coverage limits and the 30-day waiting period.
This page is general information, not a policy or a recommendation of any agency. Coverage, forms and availability vary by carrier and property, and every policy is subject to underwriting. Your policy documents control.
Founded in 2005 and family-owned, we compare 40+ carriers for Massachusetts homeowners from our Portsmouth, NH office.
Talk to our team: (603) 431-4020 · Get a quote
