Island second homes · Trusts and LLCs · Named insureds · Umbrella · Rentals · By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency, independent since 2005 and licensed in Massachusetts. We don’t have a Massachusetts office. We work with Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard owners by phone, email and online, and we compare carriers from among the 40+ we work with. We don’t charge any fees, and we’ve earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.

Many island houses aren’t owned by a person. They’re held in a nominee trust, a family or revocable trust, or an LLC, often set up by an estate planner, and the owners’ primary home is usually in another state. That’s normal. The insurance just has to be set up to match. This page explains what changes when an island second home is owned by a trust or LLC, and what to send us.

Key takeaways
  • The named insured on the home policy should match whoever holds title on the deed: the trust, the trustees or the LLC.
  • The people who use the house may need to be listed too, so contents and liability respond the way you expect.
  • Your umbrella and your primary-home policy should line up with the same names and liability limits.
  • Rentals add rules: Massachusetts requires $1 million in short-term rental liability, and Nantucket limits which LLCs can register a rental.
  • We don’t give legal advice about which structure to use. We make the insurance fit the structure you chose.

Why the deed matters to the policy

Insurance follows ownership. A carrier pays a property claim to the people or entities with an insurable interest, usually the owner on the deed and the mortgage lender. If an island house moves into a trust or LLC and the policy still lists only the individuals who used to own it, the names no longer match. That can slow down a claim, create questions about who’s protected, and, most important, leave the new owner without liability coverage if a guest is hurt.

The fix is usually simple paperwork done at the right time. The hard part is remembering to call your agent when the estate plan changes.

Common ownership structures on Nantucket and the Vineyard

StructureWho usually goes on the policyWhat we check
Nominee realty trustThe trustees, with the beneficiaries who use the houseTrust name exactly as recorded, current trustees, schedule of beneficiaries
Family or revocable living trustThe trust and trustees, with the family members who live in or use the homeWho the trustees are, and whether the grantors still use the house
LLCThe LLC, with members who use the house listed where the carrier allowsLLC name, managers and members, and whether the house is ever rented
Individuals (no entity)The owners on the deedEvery person on the deed is on the policy

Carriers handle entity ownership differently. Some will write an island home owned by a trust or LLC on a homeowners form with the right endorsements. Others want a dwelling policy, especially if no one in the household lives there for part of the year or the house is rented. We tell you which approach each carrier uses before you choose.

A primary home in another state

Most island second-home owners have a primary home somewhere else. That’s where gaps tend to appear: one agent writes the primary home and the umbrella, another writes the island house, and nobody checks that the names and limits line up. Your umbrella usually requires certain liability limits on every home and car underneath it, and it may need to list the trust or LLC that owns the island house.

We’re licensed in 10 states, including Massachusetts, so we can often look at the island house, the primary home, the cars and the umbrella together. See about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance. If another agent keeps your primary home, we’ll still check that the island policy fits under your umbrella.

High-value island homes

Many trust- and LLC-owned island homes are also high-value homes. For Nantucket and Martha’s Vineyard property we can write Swyfft, Openly, Chubb and Cincinnati, and we can also access several other markets through surplus lines brokers. Chubb and Cincinnati can work with trusts and entities. Island appetite is still limited and changes often, and no carrier writes every value or every address, so we confirm who will write your house. On a high-value house we also look at rebuild cost on the island, wind and named-storm deductibles in dollars, and private or excess flood above the NFIP limit. See high-value home insurance on Nantucket, high-value home insurance on Martha’s Vineyard, coastal Massachusetts high-value home insurance and Massachusetts high-value home insurance.

Seasonal use and an empty house

Island second homes often sit empty from fall to spring. Carriers ask how many months someone is there, who checks the house, how it’s heated and whether the water is shut off or monitored. When an entity owns the house, they also want to know who actually uses it, and how often. Leak sensors, low-temperature alarms, an automatic water shutoff and a caretaker log help with underwriting. See second and seasonal home insurance.

Renting a trust- or LLC-owned island home

Rental income is a common reason families put an island house in an LLC. Before you list it, check three things:

  • State rules. Massachusetts law requires short-term rental operators to carry at least $1 million in liability coverage for each rental, unless the hosting platform maintains equal or greater coverage, and to notify their homeowners insurer, which may exclude rental claims. Operators also register with the Department of Revenue.
  • Town rules. On Nantucket, each rental unit needs a certificate from the Board of Health, and an LLC can register only if all of its members are natural persons who meet the town’s ownership conditions. On Martha’s Vineyard, West Tisbury and Tisbury require town registration, and Oak Bluffs voters are considering a bylaw at a December 2026 special town meeting that would define the owner as a natural person.
  • The policy form. Occasional rental may fit a homeowners policy with an endorsement. Regular rental may call for a dwelling or landlord policy. See Massachusetts landlord insurance.

What to send us

  • The current deed, or the trust or LLC name exactly as recorded
  • Names of the trustees, or the LLC’s managers and members
  • Who uses the house, and for how many months a year
  • Any mortgage lender and loan number
  • Current declarations pages for the island house, your primary home, cars and umbrella
  • Rental plans, town certificates or registrations
  • Your attorney’s contact information, if you’d like us to coordinate wording

Disclosure: This page is general information, not legal or tax advice. Coverage, eligibility and price depend on each carrier’s underwriting and your details. Nothing on this page is a quote or a promise of coverage.

More for island owners

See high-value home insurance on Nantucket, high-value home insurance on Martha’s Vineyard, Nantucket home insurance, Edgartown home insurance, Massachusetts second-home and vacation home insurance, nominee trusts, family trusts and LLCs in Massachusetts, Massachusetts flood insurance and Cape Cod high-value home insurance.

Frequently asked questions

Who should be the named insured on an island home held in an LLC?

Usually the LLC, because it holds title. The people who use the house, such as the LLC’s members and their families, may also need to be listed so personal property and liability respond the way you expect. How that’s done depends on the carrier and the form, so send us the deed and the LLC’s name exactly as it appears.

Can a homeowners policy cover a house owned by a trust?

Often, yes. Many carriers can name a trust and its trustees, with the beneficiaries who live in or use the home listed as well. A Massachusetts nominee realty trust is common and carriers generally understand it, but the wording still has to match the deed. Our guide to nominee trusts, family trusts and LLCs goes deeper.

Do I need to tell my agent if I move the island house into a trust or LLC?

Yes. If the deed changes and the policy doesn’t, the named insured may no longer match the owner, which can complicate a claim and leave the new owner without liability protection. Tell us before or right after the transfer, and send a copy of the new deed.

Does my umbrella cover an island house owned by an LLC?

Not automatically. Many personal umbrellas are written to individuals, so the LLC or trust may need to be added, and the umbrella carrier will want the underlying home policy’s liability limit to meet its requirement. If you rent the house, the umbrella carrier also needs to know. See Massachusetts umbrella insurance.

Can an LLC rent out a Nantucket home short term?

Sometimes. Nantucket’s short-term rental regulations let an LLC register only if all of its members are natural persons who meet the town’s ownership conditions. Massachusetts law also requires at least $1 million in liability coverage for each short-term rental, unless the hosting platform maintains equal or greater coverage, and notice to the homeowners insurer. See our Nantucket home insurance page for the town rules.

Can you tell me whether to use a trust or an LLC?

No. That’s a legal and tax decision for your attorney or estate planner. Once you’ve chosen a structure, we make sure the insurance matches it, and we’re happy to talk with your attorney about how the names should read on the policy.

Start your island second-home quote

Send the deed or entity name, how the house is used, and your current declarations pages, and we’ll compare options from multiple carriers and explain the differences in plain English. Start your quote online, call (603) 431-4020 or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com.

Call Email Claims Payments