Nantucket high-value homes · Rebuild cost · Wind deductibles · Private flood · By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency, independent since 2005 and licensed in Massachusetts. We don’t have a Massachusetts office. We insure Nantucket homes by phone, email and online, which is how most island owners prefer to work anyway, since many spend much of the year somewhere else. We compare carriers from among the 40+ we work with, we don’t charge any fees, and we’ve earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.
This page is for owners of larger and higher-value Nantucket homes: shingled houses in town, Sconset cottages that have been expanded, and newer homes in places like Madaket, Surfside, Polpis and Monomoy. For general island basics, such as short-term rental certificates, erosion and flood maps, see our Nantucket home insurance page.
- Insure a Nantucket home for what it would cost to rebuild on the island, with materials and crews coming over by boat and design approved by the Historic District Commission.
- Island wind and named-storm deductibles are usually a percentage of the dwelling limit. On a high-value home that can mean a five- or six-figure out-of-pocket amount, so ask for it in dollars.
- Homeowners policies exclude flood. NFIP building coverage stops at $250,000, so larger homes usually need private or excess flood.
- For Nantucket property we can write Swyfft, Openly, Chubb and Cincinnati, and we can also access several other markets through surplus lines brokers. Appetite still varies by carrier, address and value, and it changes often, so we confirm who will write your house before quoting.
What makes a Nantucket home “high-value” to an insurer
Carriers look at the cost to rebuild, not the sale price. A Nantucket house can sell for far more than it would cost to rebuild, or, for an older or custom house, cost more to rebuild than buyers expect. Three things push island rebuild costs up:
- Getting everything to the island. Lumber, windows, equipment and most trades come over on Steamship Authority freight boats or by barge. That adds cost and time, and a big storm that damages many houses at once can stretch both.
- Historic District Commission review. The whole island is a local historic district. Exterior work, including rebuilding after a loss, needs a Certificate of Appropriateness, which can mean specific materials, windows, roofing and trim.
- Custom work inside. Millwork, built-ins, high-end kitchens and baths, and restored antique details cost more to replace than standard finishes.
High-value policies are built for these homes. They often settle claims at replacement cost without deducting depreciation, offer extended replacement cost above the dwelling limit, include higher limits for jewelry, art and collections, and give more room for additional living expense while a house is rebuilt. Forms and limits vary by carrier, so we compare them side by side.
Coverage we review on a high-value Nantucket home
| Coverage | Why it matters on Nantucket |
|---|---|
| Dwelling (Coverage A) and extended replacement cost | Island rebuild costs, boat freight and labor, and HDC-approved materials |
| Ordinance or law | Code upgrades when an older house is repaired or rebuilt |
| Additional living expense | Review and approval time before a builder can start, plus construction time |
| Other structures | Guest cottages, garages, studios, pools, fences and outdoor showers |
| Contents and scheduled valuables | Art, jewelry, antiques and collections, often at an agreed value |
| Water backup and leak protection | Houses that sit empty for months in winter |
| Flood (separate policy) | Storm surge and wave action, which homeowners policies exclude |
| Personal liability and umbrella | Guests, pools, boats, rentals and more than one home |
Wind and named-storm deductibles, in dollars
The Massachusetts Division of Insurance (DOI) says some Massachusetts policies carry a separate deductible for damage from a named storm or wind. It’s usually a percentage of the insured value, generally 1% to 5%, and may apply per event, per season or per year. In its report on the 2024 home insurance market, the DOI said the largest wind deductibles were in the coastal parts of Bristol, Plymouth, Barnstable, Dukes and Nantucket counties.
The FAIR Plan’s published rules set a minimum named-storm deductible for all of Nantucket County of 2% at lower dwelling limits and 5% at higher limits, wherever the house sits on the island. Private carriers set their own rules.
On a high-value house, percentages add up fast. On a home insured for $3 million, a 2% deductible is $60,000 and a 5% deductible is $150,000. We put each quote’s wind deductible in dollars next to the price so you can compare them the same way, and we’ll talk through whether a higher or lower deductible makes sense for you.
Flood above the NFIP limit
Standard homeowners policies don’t cover flood, including storm surge and wave action. Nantucket’s FEMA maps include Zone AE and coastal high-hazard Zone VE, and the town’s 2021 Coastal Resilience Plan estimates that, without mitigation, 2,373 structures are at risk from coastal flooding and erosion by 2070.
For a high-value home, the federal program usually isn’t enough by itself. NFIP building coverage is capped at $250,000 and contents at $100,000. FEMA settles building claims at replacement cost only for a principal residence insured to at least 80% of its replacement cost, so a second home is generally settled at actual cash value, and contents always are. NFIP coverage also generally starts 30 days after purchase.
We place new NFIP policies through Selective. For larger homes we also compare private flood carriers, including Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge, and excess flood that sits above an NFIP policy. Some private policies offer higher building limits, loss of use or replacement cost on contents. Which ones can write a particular house depends on the address, the flood zone and the elevation, so send any elevation certificate with your quote request. Our Massachusetts flood insurance page goes deeper.
Erosion is different. Homeowners policies generally exclude earth movement, and flood policies cover shoreline collapse only in narrow, storm-driven cases. Neither pays to move a house back from a bluff. If your home is near the Sconset bluff, Madaket or another eroding bank, tell us at the start.
Carriers we compare for high-value Nantucket homes
For Nantucket property we can write Swyfft, Openly, Chubb and Cincinnati, and we quote the ones that will consider your address. We can also access several other markets through surplus lines brokers, and we compare options from among the 40+ carriers we work with. Island appetite is still limited and changes often. Many carriers don’t write on Nantucket at all, and those that do may ask for an inspection, protective devices or a higher wind deductible. No carrier writes every value or every address, so we confirm who will write your house before quoting.
If no regular carrier will write the home, the DOI says the market of last resort is the Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association, known as the FAIR Plan. It offers basic property coverage and doesn’t cover flood. Its published maximum dwelling limit on a homeowners form is $1,000,000 for a single interest, which is below the rebuild cost of many Nantucket homes. In that case the gap has to be filled another way, such as an excess policy, and we’ll tell you what’s realistic. For statewide context, see coastal Massachusetts high-value home insurance.
Winters, caretakers and an empty house
More than half of Nantucket’s homes are held for seasonal use, so many high-value houses sit empty for months. A supply line that fails in January can run for days before anyone notices. Carriers ask who checks the house and how often, how it’s heated, and whether the water is shut off or monitored. Low-temperature and leak sensors, an automatic water shutoff, a monitored alarm and a caretaker log help with underwriting and show reasonable care if there’s a claim. Our second and seasonal home insurance page covers the basics.
LLCs, trusts and a primary home somewhere else
Many Nantucket homes are held in a nominee trust, a family trust or an LLC, and the owners’ primary home is often in another state. The names on the policy should match the deed, and the people who use the house may need to be listed too. We line up the island house, the primary home, the cars and the umbrella so the liability limits and names match. We’re licensed in 10 states; see about Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance. For the details, read our guide to insuring a Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard home owned by a trust or LLC and our Massachusetts guide to nominee trusts, family trusts and LLCs.
Valuables, boats, cars and umbrella limits
Art, jewelry, wine and collections often need to be scheduled at agreed values rather than left under general contents limits. Homeowners policies give limited coverage for watercraft, so most boats need their own policy; see Massachusetts boat insurance. For older or special cars, see collector car insurance in Massachusetts.
An umbrella policy adds liability limits over your homes, cars and boat. It’s worth a close look if you host guests all summer, have a pool, own more than one home or rent the house. If you rent, Massachusetts law requires short-term rental operators to carry at least $1 million in liability coverage for each rental, unless the hosting platform maintains equal or greater coverage, and to notify their homeowners insurer. Our high net worth insurance page covers the wider picture.
Disclosure: Coverage, eligibility and price depend on each carrier’s underwriting and your details. Nothing on this page is a quote or a promise of coverage. This is general information, not legal or tax advice.
More for Nantucket and the islands
See our Nantucket home insurance page, Massachusetts second-home and vacation home insurance, Massachusetts high-value home insurance and coastal home insurance in Massachusetts. On Martha’s Vineyard, see Edgartown home insurance. On the Cape, see Cape Cod high-value home insurance.
Frequently asked questions
Can you insure my Nantucket home if you’re not on the island?
Yes. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance doesn’t have a Massachusetts office, but we’re licensed in Massachusetts and work with Nantucket owners by phone, email and online, which suits owners who are off-island much of the year. Call (603) 431-4020 or start a quote online.
When does a Nantucket home need a high-value policy?
When the cost to rebuild the house on the island, the contents, or the art and jewelry inside go beyond what a standard policy handles well. On Nantucket that point comes sooner than on the mainland, because rebuild estimates have to account for shipping materials and crews by boat and for Historic District Commission review. We start from a rebuild estimate, not the sale price.
How much is the named-storm deductible on a Nantucket house?
It depends on the carrier and the policy. The Massachusetts Division of Insurance says wind or named-storm deductibles generally run from 1% to 5% of the insured value. The FAIR Plan’s published minimum anywhere on Nantucket is 2% at lower dwelling limits and 5% at higher limits. On a house insured for $3 million, 2% is $60,000 and 5% is $150,000, so we show every option in dollars.
Is NFIP flood insurance enough for a high-value Nantucket home?
Usually not on its own. NFIP building coverage is capped at $250,000 and contents at $100,000, and FEMA settles a second home’s building claim at actual cash value. For larger homes we compare private flood carriers, including Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge, and excess flood above an NFIP policy. Which ones fit depends on the address, the flood zone and the elevation.
What if no regular carrier will write my Nantucket home?
The Massachusetts FAIR Plan is the market of last resort. Its published maximum dwelling limit on a homeowners form is $1,000,000 for a single interest, and it doesn’t cover flood. For a house that costs more to rebuild, the gap above the FAIR Plan has to be filled another way, such as an excess policy. We’ll tell you what is realistic for your home before you decide.
Our Nantucket house is owned by an LLC or a trust. Does that change the policy?
It can. The named insured should match whoever holds title, and the people who use the house, plus any trustees or LLC managers, may need to be listed too. Your umbrella should line up with the same names. Our guide to insuring a Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard home owned by a trust or LLC, and our Massachusetts guide to nominee trusts, family trusts and LLCs, explain what to send us.
Start your Nantucket high-value home quote
Have the address, year built and any renovation dates, square footage, construction and roof details, your flood zone and any elevation certificate, your current declarations pages, how the house is owned (individual, trust or LLC), how many months it’s occupied, and any rental plans. We’ll compare options from multiple carriers and explain the differences in plain English. Start your quote online, call (603) 431-4020 or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com.
