Martha’s Vineyard high-value homes · Six towns · Wind deductibles · Flood · Up-Island fire protection · By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency, independent since 2005 and licensed in Massachusetts. We don’t have a Massachusetts office. We insure Martha’s Vineyard homes by phone, email and online, which fits owners who split the year between the island and somewhere else. We compare carriers from among the 40+ we work with, we don’t charge any fees, and we’ve earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.
This page covers larger and higher-value homes across the island: Edgartown and Chappaquiddick, Oak Bluffs, Tisbury and Vineyard Haven, West Tisbury, Chilmark and Menemsha, and Aquinnah. Each town looks a little different to an underwriter, so we start with the address.
- Fewer carriers write on the Vineyard than on the mainland, and appetite changes often. We check which carriers will consider your address before quoting.
- Insure for the cost to rebuild on the island, with materials and crews arriving by ferry or barge, not for the sale price.
- Wind and named-storm deductibles are usually a percentage of the dwelling limit. Ask for them in dollars.
- Homeowners policies exclude flood. Larger homes usually need private or excess flood above the NFIP limit.
- Up-Island houses far from hydrants get extra questions about fire protection, alarms and access.
A tighter market on the island
In December 2024 the Martha’s Vineyard Times reported that several insurers had stopped writing new policies on the island or pulled back entirely, according to local agents, and that nonrenewals had become more common. The causes cited were national storm losses, the island’s exposure to a direct hurricane hit, and up-Island fire protection. For high-value owners that means two things: start renewals early, and work with an agent who can compare more than one or two companies.
For Martha’s Vineyard property we can write Swyfft, Openly, Chubb and Cincinnati, and we can also access several other markets through surplus lines brokers. We quote the ones that will consider your address, and we compare options from among the 40+ carriers we work with. Island appetite is still limited and changes often, and many carriers ask for an inspection, protective devices or a higher wind deductible. No carrier writes every value or every address, so we confirm who will write your house before quoting.
The Vineyard, town by town
Edgartown and Chappaquiddick
Whaling-era captains’ houses in the village, larger homes around Katama and the harbor, and waterfront property on Chappaquiddick. Parts of Katama, the harbor front and Chappy are in FEMA Zones AE and VE, and the village historic district reviews exterior work. See our Edgartown home insurance page for details.
Oak Bluffs
Victorian houses, the gingerbread cottages of the Campground, homes around the harbor and on the East Chop bluff, and properties near Sengekontacket and Lagoon ponds. Older wood-frame houses close together raise questions about fire spread, wiring and heating. Some Campground cottage owners hold the cottage on land leased from the Martha’s Vineyard Camp Meeting Association, so the lease terms matter when we set up the policy.
Tisbury and Vineyard Haven
Vineyard Haven is the island’s year-round port, with homes on the harbor, around Lake Tashmoo and up on West Chop. Harbor-front and low-lying streets near Lagoon Pond can flood in storms, and older in-town houses may need ordinance or law coverage for code upgrades after a loss.
West Tisbury
Farmland, larger lots and long private roads, with many homes far from a hydrant. Barns, studios and guest houses need to be counted under other structures, and fire protection questions come up in underwriting.
Chilmark and Menemsha
Hillside and waterfront homes on large parcels, the fishing village at Menemsha, and south-shore properties facing the Atlantic. Expect questions about distance to the fire station and to water, driveway access for fire apparatus, and monitored alarms.
Aquinnah
The island’s most remote town, with homes near the cliffs and along Menemsha Pond. Remoteness, access and coastal erosion shape what carriers will offer.
Up-Island fire protection
Local agents quoted by the Martha’s Vineyard Times in 2024 said up-Island towns are seen as a higher fire risk from an insurance standpoint, largely because fire departments there are mostly volunteer and hydrants are scarce. That’s not a judgment on the firefighters. It’s how carriers rate response time and water supply. If your house is up-Island, tell us about central-station fire and low-temperature alarms, sprinklers, a pond or tank used for firefighting, and how wide and clear the driveway is. Those details help an underwriter say yes.
Rebuild cost on an island
Most building materials, equipment and many trades reach the Vineyard on Steamship Authority ferries from Woods Hole or by barge. After a big storm, demand for crews and boat space jumps at the same time. That’s why we set the dwelling limit from a rebuild estimate, look at extended replacement cost options, and check how long additional living expense coverage lasts. Historic district review in Edgartown and parts of other towns can add time and cost too. Our historic home insurance guide covers ordinance or law coverage.
Wind and named-storm deductibles
The Massachusetts Division of Insurance (DOI) says these deductibles are usually a percentage of the insured value, generally 1% to 5%, and may apply per event, per season or per year. In its report on the 2024 home insurance market, the DOI said the largest wind deductibles were in the coastal parts of Bristol, Plymouth, Barnstable, Dukes and Nantucket counties. The FAIR Plan’s published minimum for all of Dukes County is 2% at lower dwelling limits and 5% at higher limits. On a house insured for $2.5 million, that’s $50,000 to $125,000, so we show each quote’s deductible in dollars.
Flood, surge and erosion
Homeowners policies don’t cover flood, including storm surge. NFIP building coverage is capped at $250,000 and contents at $100,000, and FEMA generally settles a second home’s building claim at actual cash value. For larger homes we compare private flood carriers, including Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge, and excess flood above an NFIP policy. We place new NFIP policies through Selective. Erosion along the south shore, the cliffs and coastal banks is generally not covered by homeowners or flood policies. See Massachusetts flood insurance.
When regular carriers say no
The DOI says the Massachusetts Property Insurance Underwriting Association, known as the FAIR Plan, is the market of last resort. It offers basic property coverage and doesn’t cover flood, and its published maximum dwelling limit on a homeowners form is $1,000,000 for a single interest. Many Vineyard homes cost more than that to rebuild, so the FAIR Plan alone may leave a gap. We start with regular-market and high-value carriers and tell you plainly what’s realistic for your house. For more, see coastal home insurance in Massachusetts.
Empty winters, rentals and ownership
Many Vineyard houses are closed from fall to spring. Carriers ask who checks the house, how it’s heated and whether the water is shut off or monitored. Leak sensors, an automatic water shutoff and a caretaker log help. See second and seasonal home insurance.
If you rent, Massachusetts law requires short-term rental operators to carry at least $1 million in liability coverage, unless the hosting platform maintains equal or greater coverage, and to notify their homeowners insurer. Town rules differ: West Tisbury and Tisbury require town registration, and Oak Bluffs voters are considering a short-term rental bylaw at a December 2026 special town meeting. Check your town’s current rules before the season.
If the house is held in a trust or LLC, the names on the policy and your umbrella should match the deed. See our guide to insuring a Nantucket or Martha’s Vineyard home owned by a trust or LLC and our Massachusetts guide to nominee trusts, family trusts and LLCs. For liability across your homes, cars and boat, see Massachusetts umbrella insurance and Massachusetts boat insurance.
Disclosure: Coverage, eligibility and price depend on each carrier’s underwriting and your details. Nothing on this page is a quote or a promise of coverage. Local rules change; check current town rules before you build or rent.
More for the islands and the Cape
See Nantucket home insurance, Massachusetts second-home and vacation home insurance, coastal Massachusetts high-value home insurance, Massachusetts high-value home insurance, Cape Cod high-value home insurance and Falmouth home insurance.
Frequently asked questions
Can you insure my Martha’s Vineyard home if you’re not on the island?
Yes. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance doesn’t have a Massachusetts office, but we’re licensed in Massachusetts and work with Vineyard owners by phone, email and online. Most of our island clients live elsewhere part of the year. Call (603) 431-4020 or start a quote online.
Why is home insurance on Martha’s Vineyard harder to find than on the mainland?
The island faces the open Atlantic, many homes sit empty in winter, rebuilding depends on the ferries, and up-Island towns rely largely on volunteer fire departments with fewer hydrants. In 2024 the Martha’s Vineyard Times reported that several insurers had pulled back from writing on the island. Appetite changes from carrier to carrier and year to year, which is why comparing many carriers helps.
Does it matter which Vineyard town my house is in?
Yes. Carriers look at distance to the water, flood zone, fire protection and access. A harbor-front house in Edgartown or Vineyard Haven, a cottage in Oak Bluffs and a house on a long dirt road in Chilmark or Aquinnah can get very different answers. Town rental rules also differ.
How large is a wind deductible on a Vineyard house?
The Massachusetts Division of Insurance says wind or named-storm deductibles generally run from 1% to 5% of the insured value, and the FAIR Plan’s published minimum for all of Dukes County is 2% at lower dwelling limits and 5% at higher limits. On a house insured for $2.5 million, that’s $50,000 to $125,000. We show every quote’s wind deductible in dollars.
My Vineyard home costs more than $1 million to rebuild. Is the FAIR Plan an option?
The FAIR Plan’s published maximum dwelling limit on a homeowners form is $1,000,000 for a single interest, and it doesn’t cover flood. For a house that costs more to rebuild, the gap above the FAIR Plan has to be filled another way, such as an excess policy. We start with regular-market and high-value carriers and tell you what’s realistic.
Can I rent my Vineyard house and keep my homeowners policy?
Only if your insurer agrees. Massachusetts law requires short-term rental operators to carry at least $1 million in liability coverage, unless the hosting platform maintains equal or greater coverage, and to notify their homeowners insurer. Several Vineyard towns also have their own rules. Light rental may fit a homeowners policy with an endorsement; heavier rental may call for a dwelling policy. See Massachusetts landlord insurance.
Start your Martha’s Vineyard home quote
Have the address and town, year built and renovation dates, construction and roof details, distance to a hydrant or fire station if you know it, alarms and water shutoffs, your flood zone and any elevation certificate, your current declarations pages, how the house is owned, months occupied and any rental plans. We’ll compare options from multiple carriers and explain the differences in plain English. Start your quote online, call (603) 431-4020 or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com.
