Home buying · Homeowners insurance
By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Updated: November 4, 2026
- Start shopping for homeowners insurance when your offer is accepted, not the week of closing.
- Your lender needs proof of insurance before closing, with the lender listed on the policy.
- Insure the house for what it would cost to rebuild, which isn’t the same as the purchase price.
- Inspection findings like the roof, wiring, heating and oil tanks can change which carriers will write the home.
- Check the flood map early, even if the lender doesn’t require flood insurance.
You’ve finally got an accepted offer on a Cape in Dover, a colonial in Andover or a condo in Norwalk. Now your lender, your attorney and your real estate agent all want things from you at once, and somewhere on the list is “homeowners insurance.” For first-time buyers it’s easy to leave until the end. Here’s why you shouldn’t, and what to have lined up before closing.
When to start shopping
Start as soon as your offer is accepted, and ideally during your inspection period. Insurance isn’t just a box to check. If something about the house limits your options, like a 25-year-old roof, a buried oil tank or old knob-and-tube wiring, you want to know while you can still negotiate a repair, ask for a credit or walk away. Finding out a week before closing leaves you with fewer choices.
What your lender will ask for
If you’re financing, your lender will require proof of homeowners insurance before closing, with the lender listed as mortgagee. Many buyers pay the first year at or before closing, and some lenders then collect the premium monthly through an escrow account. Our post on homeowners insurance at closing explains how that works, and mortgage insurance vs. homeowners insurance clears up two terms people mix up.
Once the policy is set up, we send the evidence of insurance to your lender or closing attorney. Give us the lender’s mortgagee clause and the closing date as soon as you have them, and tell us if the date moves.
How much coverage: rebuild cost, not purchase price
Your dwelling coverage should reflect what it would cost to rebuild the house at today’s labor and material costs, not what you paid. In much of New England, especially on the Seacoast and in Fairfield County, a big part of the price is the land. In older towns, a house with plaster walls, custom trim and slate can cost more to rebuild than its sale price suggests. Our home replacement cost estimator gives you a starting point, and carriers run their own estimate too.
The rest of the policy is built around that number: other structures like a detached garage or shed, personal property for your belongings, loss of use if you have to move out during repairs, and personal liability. First-time buyers often carry too little liability. If you have savings to protect, ask about higher limits or an umbrella.
Inspection findings that can affect your insurance
Your home inspection isn’t just about repairs. The same things an inspector flags are what underwriters ask about. The Insurance Information Institute specifically suggests finding out whether there’s an underground oil tank, since many insurers won’t write homes that have one. Things that commonly matter in New England:
- Roof age and condition. An older roof can mean fewer carrier options or a roof paid at actual cash value. See will insurance cover a 20-year-old roof.
- Electrical. Knob-and-tube wiring, fuse boxes and some older panels can limit options until they’re updated.
- Heating. Oil tanks (especially buried ones), wood stoves and pellet stoves. Expect questions about tank age and location and how a stove was installed.
- Plumbing. Older galvanized or polybutylene pipes and the age of the water heater.
- Wells and septic systems, which are common outside town centers.
- Prior water damage, including stains, musty basements and fresh paint on a ceiling.
Read more in our guide to home insurance inspections. If the home is older, our page on older and historic home insurance covers what carriers look for.
Ask about the home’s claims history
Insurers can see a property’s recent claims through an industry database. A past water claim isn’t a deal breaker, but you’ll want to know where the water came from and whether it was properly fixed. A storm claim that paid for a new roof can actually make the house more attractive to insure. Ask the seller, through your agent, about claims in the last several years.
Flood: check before you’re committed
If the home is in a high-risk flood zone and you have a federally backed mortgage, your lender will require flood insurance. Even outside those zones, homes near rivers, marshes, lakes and the coast flood regularly. Check the address on FEMA’s Flood Map Service Center or our flood zone check early. National Flood Insurance Program policies usually have a 30-day waiting period, with an exception when a lender requires flood coverage for a new loan, and private flood policies set their own rules. Either way, getting the quote early keeps it off your closing-week list. Connecticut buyers should also read about the state’s flood disclosure rules.
“The smoothest closings happen when buyers call us the day their offer is accepted. That gives us time to flag a roof, oil tank, or flood zone issue while there’s still room to do something about it.”
— Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance
Buying a condo instead?
Condo buyers usually need an HO-6 policy. The association’s master policy covers the building, and your policy covers interior finishes (depending on the master deed), your belongings, loss of use, liability and loss assessment if the association passes a shared cost to owners. Read the master policy and condo documents before choosing limits. See condo insurance in New Hampshire.
Your pre-closing insurance checklist
- Call your agent when the offer is accepted.
- Share the inspection report and anything about the roof, heat, wiring or plumbing.
- Check the flood zone and ask for a flood quote if the home is anywhere near water.
- Ask the seller about past claims and completed repairs.
- Decide on dwelling, liability and deductible with your agent.
- Send us the lender’s mortgagee clause, loan number and closing date.
- Set up auto and umbrella at the same time if bundling makes sense.
- Confirm the lender or attorney received proof of insurance before closing.
Looking for the bigger picture? Our 13 tips for first-time home buyers covers the financial side, and home insurance basics for new buyers explains the parts of a policy.
We compare 40+ carriers, don’t charge fees, and work with your lender and attorney to have proof of insurance ready for closing. Call (603) 431-4020 in Portsmouth or (203) 859-6858 in Fairfield (Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM, Friday 8 AM–4 PM ET), or request a homeowners quote.
Frequently asked questions
When should a first-time buyer start shopping for homeowners insurance?
As soon as your offer is accepted, and ideally during your inspection period. That gives you time to find out whether anything about the house, like an old roof, an oil tank or older wiring, limits your options while you can still negotiate or walk away.
Do I need homeowners insurance before closing?
If you have a mortgage, yes. Lenders require proof of homeowners insurance before closing, usually with the lender listed as mortgagee. Your agent sends that proof to the lender or closing attorney once the policy is set up.
Should my dwelling coverage match the purchase price?
Not necessarily. Dwelling coverage should reflect what it would cost to rebuild the house, which can be higher or lower than what you paid. The purchase price includes the land, and land doesn’t burn down.
Do I need flood insurance as a first-time buyer?
If the home is in a high-risk flood zone and you have a federally backed mortgage, your lender will require it. Even outside those zones, homes near rivers, marshes or the coast can flood. Check the flood map early. Most NFIP policies have a 30-day waiting period, though there is an exception when the flood policy is required for a new loan.
Can the seller’s past claims affect my insurance?
They can. Carriers can see a home’s recent claims history through industry databases. Ask the seller about past claims, especially water or roof claims, and whether repairs were completed.
Is condo insurance different for first-time buyers?
Yes. A condo owner usually needs an HO-6 policy that covers interior finishes, belongings and liability, while the association’s master policy covers the building. Read the master policy and the condo documents before you choose your limits.
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute, Homeowners Insurance Handbook (PDF), checked November 4, 2026.
- FEMA, Flood Map Service Center, checked November 4, 2026.
- FEMA, FloodSmart, checked November 4, 2026.
This article is general information, not an offer of coverage or a promise that any loss is covered. Your policy wording and each carrier’s underwriting decide coverage.
Related guides: 13 tips for first-time home buyers · Homeowners insurance at closing · Home insurance inspections · Bundling home and auto in New Hampshire
Next step: Request a homeowners insurance quote or call (603) 431-4020.

