Independent Insurance Agencies in Fairfield County, CT: A Town-by-Town Guide (2026)

Published on: October 19, 2026

Agencies · Fairfield County, CT
By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Data checked October 19, 2026

Key takeaways
  • This guide profiles 10 local independent insurance agencies with offices in Fairfield, Westport, Greenwich, Darien, Norwalk, Stamford and Stratford, plus our own agency.
  • It is organized by town, not ranked. Google ratings and review counts are shown as of October 19, 2026, for reference only.
  • Founding years run from 1905 (Hatfield, Fairfield) to 2013 (Howard & Gay, Westport).
  • Several Gold Coast agencies focus on high-value homes; others focus on everyday home, auto and small-business coverage.
  • In Fairfield County, ask any agency about flood, wind and hurricane deductibles, rebuild cost and liability limits, not just price.

Looking for an independent insurance agency in Fairfield County, Connecticut? There are many good ones, and they aren’t all built for the same client. Some have insured the same Greenwich and Darien families for generations, some focus on large Gold Coast homes, and some are neighborhood offices that handle cars, condos and small businesses. This guide sorts them by town and explains what each one says it does best, so you can call the two or three that fit. We’re Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, and our Connecticut office is on the Post Road in Fairfield, so we’re on the list too. Here’s how we built it.

Large waterfront homes on Long Island Sound at Tod's Point in Greenwich, Connecticut
Shoreline homes in Greenwich. Flood, wind and rebuild cost shape insurance across lower Fairfield County.

How we chose these agencies

  • Towns. We looked for agency offices in Fairfield, Westport, Greenwich, Darien, New Canaan, Stamford, Norwalk and Stratford.
  • Local independents only. Each agency describes itself as independent or as comparing several carriers. We left out captive agents that represent one insurer (such as State Farm, Allstate, Farmers and GEICO agents), insurance companies, online-first agencies, health-only brokers and local branches of national brokerage firms.
  • Google data. We read each office’s Google rating and review count from its Google Maps listing on October 19, 2026. Where an agency has several offices, we show the listing for the office named. Counts change daily.
  • Founding years and specialties. These come from each agency’s own website. If we couldn’t verify a figure, we left it out rather than guess.
  • Not a ranking. Agencies are grouped by town. Review counts are shown for reference, and a small count doesn’t mean an agency is less capable; many long-established offices simply haven’t asked clients for reviews.

Disclosure: Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote and publishes this guide and is included in it. We did not contact, pay or receive anything from the other agencies listed.

Fairfield County independent agencies at a glance

AgencyTownFounded (per agency)Known for (per its website)Google rating (reviews)
Hatfield Insurance AgencyFairfield1905Family-owned brokerage for custom personal and commercial insurance5.0 (1)
Morrison Insurance AgencyFairfieldNot listedPersonal lines (auto, home, condo, boat, RV) and business insurance5.0 (14)
Double Eagle Insurance Agency of CTFairfield2006Family-owned agency serving Connecticut, Long Island and New York City4.6 (9)
Howard & Gay InsuranceWestport2013Home, auto, flood, valuable items and high-net-worth insurance5.0 (19)
Cross Private Client InsuranceWestport1954 (Cross Insurance)High-value, coastal and historic homes, collections, watercraft and collector cars4.9 (57)
Griffith E. Harris Insurance ServicesGreenwich1946Personal, business and high-net-worth insurance for the Greenwich community4.0 (4)
Abercrombie, Burns, McKiernan & Company InsuranceDarien1952Full-service independent agency: personal, business, life and health5.0 (16)
The Bayliss AgencyNorwalkNot listedPersonal and commercial auto, homeowners and renters; service in English and Spanish4.7 (22)
Malloy InsuranceStamford1945Family-owned agency for home, auto and business insurance4.8 (251)
A.J. Gambardella AssociatesStratford1977Home, auto, life and small-business insurance5.0 (498)
Portsmouth Atlantic InsuranceFairfield (1885 Post Road)2005Home, flood, auto and high-value homes; 40+ carriers1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials
Google ratings and review counts read from each office’s Google Maps listing on October 19, 2026. Founding years and specialties from each agency’s website. Listed by town, not ranked.

Agency profiles, town by town

Fairfield

Fairfield has beach neighborhoods along Long Island Sound, Southport’s historic homes and inland areas like Greenfield Hill, so local agencies see a wide mix of homes.

Hatfield Insurance Agency · Founded 1905 · Google: 5.0 stars, 1 review (Fairfield office, Post Road, as of October 19, 2026)

Hatfield Insurance Agency says it has been family owned and managed since 1905, and it is run today by grandsons of the founder. It describes itself as a full-service brokerage that places custom personal and commercial coverage, and its site says it is licensed in Connecticut, New York, Florida, Massachusetts and Vermont. That multi-state reach can help families with a second home outside Connecticut. Its Google listing had one review when we checked, and its website shares letters from long-time clients.

Morrison Insurance Agency · Google: 5.0 stars, 14 reviews (Tunxis Hill Road, Fairfield, as of October 19, 2026)

Morrison Insurance Agency is a local independent agency on Tunxis Hill Road in Fairfield. Its site says it represents several preferred insurance companies and quotes personal coverage for cars, homes, boats and RVs, plus business insurance, for clients throughout Connecticut. Its Google reviews mention long client relationships and quick help with day-to-day requests. We could not find a founding year on its site, so we have left that out.

Double Eagle Insurance Agency of CT · Founded 2006 · Google: 4.6 stars, 9 reviews (Kings Highway East, Fairfield, as of October 19, 2026)

Double Eagle Insurance Agency says it has served clients since 2006 and calls itself a family-owned independent agency with three generations of insurance experience. Its Connecticut office is on Kings Highway East in Fairfield, and it also has a New York office. Its site lists home, condo, renters, flood, auto and business coverage, and mentions local concerns like coastal flood zones and commuting on I-95 and the Merritt Parkway. That makes it worth a look for households with ties to both Fairfield County and New York.

Westport

Westport and nearby New Canaan are home to several private-client offices that focus on larger homes and collections.

Howard & Gay Insurance · Founded 2013 · Google: 5.0 stars, 19 reviews (Post Road East, Westport, as of October 19, 2026)

Howard & Gay Insurance has offices in Westport, Greenwich and New Canaan, plus Scarsdale, NY. Its site says it has served clients since 2013 and specializes in home, auto, flood, valuable items and high-net-worth coverage. It is a natural call for larger Gold Coast homes with jewelry, art or other collections. Each of its offices has its own Google listing; the Greenwich office showed 4.8 stars from 19 reviews on the same day.

Cross Private Client Insurance · Founded 1954 (Cross Insurance) · Google: 4.9 stars, 57 reviews (Turkey Hill Road South, Westport, as of October 19, 2026)

Cross Private Client is a brand of Cross Insurance Agency, which its site says was founded in 1954. Cross expanded into Connecticut in 2016 by partnering with local boutique agencies, and its New Canaan office was previously branded as Brown Thayer Shedd. It lists high-value homes, coastal and historic homes, collections, watercraft and collector cars among its specialties, along with in-house claims staff. Its Westport listing had 57 Google reviews when we checked.

Greenwich

Greenwich has some of the highest home values in Connecticut and a long shoreline, from Old Greenwich to Byram.

Griffith E. Harris Insurance Services · Founded 1946 · Google: 4.0 stars, 4 reviews (East Putnam Avenue, Greenwich, as of October 19, 2026)

Griffith E. Harris Insurance Services says it is family owned and operated and was founded in Greenwich in 1946 by Griffith E. Harris, Sr. Its site lists personal, business, high-net-worth, and life and health insurance, plus risk management. For Greenwich households that value an agency with deep roots in town, it is one of the longest-running local names. Its Google listing had four reviews when we checked.

Darien

Darien’s waterfront and its many older, larger homes make rebuild cost and flood questions common.

Abercrombie, Burns, McKiernan & Company Insurance · Founded 1952 · Google: 5.0 stars, 16 reviews (Post Road, Darien, as of October 19, 2026)

Abercrombie, Burns, McKiernan & Company, often shortened to ABMcK, says it was founded in 1952 and is a full-service independent insurance and risk management agency based in Darien. Its site covers personal, business, and life and health insurance and stresses a concierge style of service. Recent Google reviews mention help with policy changes and claims.

Norwalk

Norwalk mixes waterfront neighborhoods such as Rowayton with busy commercial corridors.

The Bayliss Agency · Google: 4.7 stars, 22 reviews (East Avenue, Norwalk, as of October 19, 2026)

The Bayliss Agency is an independent agency on East Avenue in Norwalk. Its site lists personal and commercial auto, homeowners, renters, umbrella and contractor coverage, along with DMV registration and notary services, and it offers service in both English and Spanish. It suits drivers and small business owners who want a neighborhood office that handles the paperwork too. We could not find a founding year on its site.

Stamford

Stamford, one of the county’s largest cities, has condos, single-family homes and shoreline neighborhoods like Shippan.

Malloy Insurance · Founded 1945 · Google: 4.8 stars, 251 reviews (Glenbrook Road, Stamford, as of October 19, 2026)

Malloy Insurance says it has been a family-owned, independent agency in Stamford since 1945, with third- and fourth-generation family members now in the business. Its site covers home, auto and business insurance across Fairfield County and New York, and it has been at its Glenbrook Road office since 1976. Its Google listing had 251 reviews when we checked.

Stratford

Stratford sits at the mouth of the Housatonic River on the county’s eastern edge.

A.J. Gambardella Associates · Founded 1977 · Google: 5.0 stars, 498 reviews (Main Street, Stratford, as of October 19, 2026)

A.J. Gambardella Associates says it has served individuals, families and businesses since 1977, with clients in Connecticut and several other states. Its site lists homeowners, auto, umbrella and life insurance, plus a long list of small-business coverages, and it serves Stratford, Fairfield, Shelton, Milford and nearby towns. Its Google listing had 498 reviews when we checked.

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance (Fairfield, 1885 Post Road)

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance · Founded 2005 · 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials

We’re Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, a family-owned independent agency founded in 2005. We’re based in Portsmouth, NH, and our Fairfield office at 1885 Post Road works with homeowners and drivers across Fairfield County. We compare 40+ carriers, are licensed in 10 states, and have earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. We don’t charge additional fees. For larger homes we work with high-value carriers, including Chubb and Cincinnati, which write homes at any dwelling limit. For flood, new NFIP policies go through Selective, and we can also quote private flood carriers such as Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods and Aon Edge. See our Fairfield, CT insurance agency page and our Fairfield County home, flood and auto insurance guide.

Want a second opinion on your Fairfield County coverage?
We can review your home, flood, auto and umbrella policies and compare 40+ carriers. We don’t charge additional fees.
Talk to our team: (203) 859-6858 · Request a policy review

What to look for in a Fairfield County insurance agency

Any of the agencies above can quote a policy. These are the Fairfield County questions that separate a good fit from a quick quote.

Coastal flood and storm surge

Much of the shoreline from Greenwich to Stratford sits in FEMA flood zones, and flooding also reaches inland along rivers and low streets. Flood is usually excluded from homeowners policies, so ask whether the agency quotes both NFIP and private flood, and whether it will check your flood zone and elevation certificate. Our Fairfield County flood insurance guide and our Greenwich and Westport shoreline flood page go deeper, and we have town pages for Fairfield, Stamford, Norwalk and Darien.

High-value homes on the Gold Coast

In Greenwich, Darien, New Canaan and Westport, the biggest risk is often an outdated dwelling limit. Ask how the agency estimates rebuild cost, whether the policy includes extended replacement cost, and how it schedules jewelry, art and wine. Ask, too, about personal umbrella limits that match your assets. See our pages on high-value homes in Greenwich, Darien, New Canaan and Southport, and our guide to luxury home insurance in Greenwich, Darien and Westport.

Nor’easters, wind and hurricane deductibles

Nor’easters bring wind-driven rain, fallen trees, ice dams and long power outages, and late-summer storms can bring hurricane-force wind. Many Connecticut shoreline policies carry a separate hurricane or wind deductible that is much larger than the standard one. Ask the agency to show you where yours sits on the declarations page, and whether water backup coverage is included. Our guide to hurricane deductibles in Connecticut explains when they apply.

Second homes and other states

Many Fairfield County families also own a home in New England, New York or Florida. An agency licensed in each of those states can keep the policies coordinated, which matters for umbrella coverage. Ask which states the agency is licensed in. We’re licensed in 10, and our guide to one agent for New Hampshire and Connecticut homes explains how that works.

Questions to ask any Fairfield County agency
  • Which carriers can you quote for my home, and which write high-value homes?
  • Will you quote both NFIP and private flood, and check my flood zone?
  • What is my hurricane or wind deductible, and where is it on my declarations page?
  • How did you estimate my rebuild cost?
  • Are you licensed in every state where I own a home?
  • Who will be my day-to-day contact, and who helps if I have a claim?

Frequently asked questions

Which independent insurance agencies serve Fairfield County, CT?

This guide covers Hatfield Insurance Agency, Morrison Insurance Agency and Double Eagle Insurance Agency in Fairfield; Howard & Gay Insurance and Cross Private Client Insurance in Westport; Griffith E. Harris Insurance Services in Greenwich; Abercrombie, Burns, McKiernan & Company in Darien; The Bayliss Agency in Norwalk; Malloy Insurance in Stamford; A.J. Gambardella Associates in Stratford; and Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, which has an office in Fairfield. It is a starting list, not a complete one.

Which Fairfield County agencies focus on high-value homes?

Among the agencies in this guide, Howard & Gay Insurance and Cross Private Client Insurance describe high-net-worth and high-value homes as a specialty on their own websites, and Griffith E. Harris Insurance Services lists high-net-worth insurance as a service. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance places high-value homes with carriers including Chubb and Cincinnati, which write homes at any dwelling limit.

Does homeowners insurance cover flooding in Fairfield County?

Standard homeowners policies generally exclude flood from rising water, such as storm surge on Long Island Sound or an overflowing river. Flood coverage is bought separately, through the National Flood Insurance Program or a private flood carrier, and NFIP policies usually have a 30-day waiting period before they take effect. Ask your agent to quote both and compare the coverage, not just the premium.

What is the difference between an independent agency and a captive agent?

An independent agency can quote policies from several insurance companies and compare them for you. A captive agent represents one insurance company. Every agency in this guide describes itself as independent or as comparing several carriers.

How did you choose the agencies in this guide?

We looked for local independent agency offices with a Google listing in Fairfield, Westport, Greenwich, Darien, New Canaan, Stamford, Norwalk or Stratford. We left out captive agents, insurance companies, online-first agencies and branches of national brokers. Google ratings and review counts were read from each office’s listing on October 19, 2026, and founding years and specialties come from each agency’s own website. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote this guide and is included in it.

Does Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance serve Fairfield County?

Yes. Our Connecticut office is at 1885 Post Road in Fairfield, and we work with homeowners and drivers in Fairfield, Westport, Greenwich, Darien, New Canaan, Stamford, Norwalk and nearby towns. Call (203) 859-6858 to talk with our team.

Sources

Google Maps business listings for each office named, ratings and review counts read on October 19, 2026. Founding years, services and history from each agency’s own website: Hatfield Insurance Agency, Morrison Insurance Agency, Double Eagle Insurance Agency of CT, Howard & Gay Insurance, Cross Private Client Insurance, Griffith E. Harris Insurance Services, Abercrombie, Burns, McKiernan & Company Insurance, The Bayliss Agency, Malloy Insurance, A.J. Gambardella Associates; Cross Insurance New Canaan office page (Brown Thayer Shedd history). Counts and details change; check each agency’s live listing and website for current information.

This page is general information, not a policy. Coverage, forms and availability vary by carrier and property, and every policy is subject to underwriting. Your policy documents control.

Insuring a home in Fairfield County?
Founded in 2005 and family-owned, we compare 40+ carriers, and our Fairfield office knows the county.
Talk to our team: (203) 859-6858 · Get a quote
Jon Merwin, founder and CEO of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance
Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, Portsmouth, NH
Portsmouth Atlantic has been an independent agency since 2005, is licensed in 10 states, works with 40+ carriers and has earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. Meet our team.
Call Email Claims Payments