Flood Insurance in Fairfield, CT

By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO

Flood · NFIP · Private Flood · Elevation Certificates · Fairfield, CT

Home › Connecticut › Fairfield › Flood Insurance

If you own a home in Fairfield, flood is usually the gap in your coverage that matters most and gets checked least. A homeowners policy pays for wind, a tree through the roof and a burst pipe. It does not pay when Long Island Sound comes up Fairfield Beach Road, when Pine Creek backs up behind the tide gates, or when the Mill River leaves its banks after a long rain. That takes a flood policy, written separately, and the time to buy it is before a storm shows up in the forecast. We look at flood alongside your homeowners insurance so the two policies fit together.

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency founded in 2005 and licensed in 10 states. We are the most-reviewed independent insurance agency in New Hampshire, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. We compare 40+ carriers and charge no fees of any kind on any line. We serve Connecticut by phone, email and online, with a Fairfield County office coming soon. Call (603) 431-4020.

Where does Fairfield flood?

The 2024 update of the MetroCOG Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan, which covers Fairfield, Bridgeport, Easton, Monroe, Stratford and Trumbull, describes Fairfield’s flood risk in detail. A few places come up again and again:

• Fairfield Beach and Pine Creek. The plan describes the Pine Creek tidal wetlands as heavily modified by drainage canals, tide gates and dikes, with bulkheads where the creek runs behind the barrier beach and dense homes. It singles out the neighborhoods near Fairfield Beach and Pine Creek as a public-safety concern in coastal floods.
• The shoreline south of Old Post Road. According to the plan, even a Category 1 hurricane would likely cause widespread flooding along the shoreline south of Old Post Road between Sasco Hill Road and Ash Creek.
• Southport Harbor and Southport village. The plan says parts of Southport would flood in a Category 2 or 3 storm. Southport’s historic district sits partly in the floodplain.
• Ash Creek. The tidal estuary on the Bridgeport line, next to Black Rock, floods with surge and with heavy rain from the Rooster River upstream.
• The Mill River. Flowing from the Easton Reservoir through the center of town to Southport Harbor, it is the system the plan calls most susceptible to inland flooding. The Rooster River, Great Brook and Sasco Brook, which runs along the Westport line near Greens Farms, are also named.
• The Town Center. The plan says the area along US Route 1 would flood in a Category 3 or 4 hurricane.

You do not need to live on the beach to have flood exposure. Homes on low streets near any of these creeks, and homes with finished basements anywhere in town, can take on water.

What did Irene and Sandy show about flood risk in Fairfield?

The plan highlights two recent storms. In Tropical Storm Irene on August 28, 2011, surge and fresh water flooded multiple sections of White Street with a few feet of water, and inundation reached about half a mile inland on Fairfield Beach Road past One Rod Highway. The surge damaged or destroyed more than 100 homes across East Haven, Milford, Westport, Fairfield and Stratford.

Superstorm Sandy on October 29, 2012 arrived at high tide with a surge of eight to nine feet along much of western Long Island Sound. The plan says inundation spread several blocks inland in many places and, in Fairfield, reached north of I-95 along Ash Creek and the Mill River.

Since Sandy, many Fairfield beach-area homes have been elevated. That helps with flood, but the plan cites a CIRCA study finding that elevated homes can be more vulnerable to wind. A raised house still needs a careful look at the roof, the wind coverage and the hurricane deductible on the homeowners policy.

How do FEMA flood zones work in Fairfield?

FEMA flood maps (Flood Insurance Rate Maps) mark Special Flood Hazard Areas, the zones with a one-in-100 annual chance of flooding. In Fairfield the zones you will see most are:

• VE zones, the coastal high hazard area right on the water, where waves are part of the risk and building rules are strictest.
• AE zones, with a mapped base flood elevation, along the shoreline, the tidal creeks and the rivers.
• Shaded and unshaded X zones, which are moderate or lower risk. Flood insurance is not federally required there, but homes still flood.

If your home is in an A or V zone and you have a federally backed mortgage, your lender will require flood insurance. The Town’s Plan and Zoning Department, which serves as Fairfield’s floodplain administrator, says the town has over 4,000 properties in FEMA flood zones. FEMA has also been running a restudy of the Saugatuck River Watershed that includes Fairfield, and the Town has posted preliminary maps for review. Preliminary maps cannot be used to rate a policy, so always check the current effective map for your address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center. If your zone is changing, call us before the new map takes effect. Timing can affect how your policy is rated.

What is Fairfield’s substantial damage rule?

This rule catches many Fairfield homeowners by surprise. The Town says that when a property in the flood zone has improvement work or damage repair that costs more than half the value of the structure, the house must be modified to be safe from future flooding. The Town is clear that damage of any kind counts toward that threshold, including fire and wind, not only flood. Owners in the flood zone proposing new work must submit a Substantial Damage Estimate form.

Two coverages matter here. On the homeowners side, ordinance or law coverage helps with the extra cost of rebuilding to current codes after a covered loss. On the flood side, NFIP policies include Increased Cost of Compliance coverage, which can help pay to elevate or otherwise bring a substantially damaged home into compliance after a flood. We check both when we review a shoreline home.

Should a Fairfield home have NFIP or private flood insurance?

There are two main paths, and many Fairfield homes end up using one or both.

NFIP flood through Selective

We write National Flood Insurance Program policies, placing new business through Selective as a Write Your Own carrier. Selective issues and services the policy, but FEMA sets the coverage terms. The NFIP covers a residential building up to 250,000 and contents up to 100,000. Coverage in basements is limited to certain items, which matters in Fairfield, where many older homes have finished lower levels. New policies generally carry a 30-day waiting period, with exceptions such as a policy bought in connection with a loan closing.

Private and excess flood

Many Fairfield shoreline homes cost far more to rebuild than the NFIP building limit. Private flood can offer higher building limits, contents coverage that better matches the furnishings, additional living expenses while you are out of the house and, with some carriers, a shorter waiting period. For higher-value homes, another option is to keep a primary flood policy and add excess flood above it. Private flood markets we compare include Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge.

For a county-wide view, see our Fairfield County, CT flood insurance guide. If you also own on the Westport or Greenwich shoreline, see our Greenwich and Westport shoreline flood insurance page.

Does an elevation certificate help with flood insurance in Fairfield?

Often, yes. An elevation certificate shows how high the lowest floor of the house sits compared with the base flood elevation. FloodSmart notes that most homeowners do not need one to buy flood insurance, but homes in A and V zones may, and it can help identify savings. If your house was raised after Sandy or built after the current map, there may already be one on file with the Town’s floodplain administrator, so ask Plan and Zoning before you hire a surveyor.

Carriers also ask about the foundation type, flood vents, where the furnace, water heater and electrical panel sit, and any prior flood claims.

How do flood, wind and hurricane deductibles fit together?

A coastal storm usually brings both wind and water, and they fall under different policies. Wind damage, such as shingles torn off or a tree on the roof, goes to your homeowners policy. Rising water goes to your flood policy, with its own deductible. Many Connecticut shoreline homeowners policies also carry a separate hurricane deductible. Under Connecticut law, it can apply only after the National Hurricane Center issues a hurricane warning for part of the state and the storm produces sustained winds of 74 mph or more somewhere in Connecticut. It ends 24 hours after the last warning is lifted or the storm is downgraded, whichever comes first. The amount must be on your declarations page. Read more in our article on hurricane deductibles in Connecticut and our guide to coastal home insurance, flood and wind in Connecticut.

What about condos and rentals near the water?

If you own a condo, the association may carry flood on the building. That policy does not cover your belongings or the improvements inside your unit, so a ground-floor or garden-level owner near the beach or the Mill River may need a separate flood policy too. If you rent a Fairfield house to tenants, the landlord policy will not cover flood either. Tenants need their own coverage for belongings. For landlords, see our landlord insurance page.

How do you get a flood quote for a Fairfield home?

• The property address, so we can check the effective FEMA zone
• Year built, foundation type, number of floors and whether there is a finished basement
• Any elevation certificate, survey or photos of raised mechanicals and flood vents
• Your current flood and homeowners declarations pages, if you have them
• Your lender’s flood requirement and closing date, if you are buying

Send what you have through the form below or call (603) 431-4020. We serve Connecticut by phone, email and online, with a Fairfield County office coming soon.

Get a quote

Tell us about your situation and we will compare carriers for you. Prefer to talk? Call (603) 431-4020.

Frequently asked questions

Does homeowners insurance cover flooding in Fairfield, CT?

No. Homeowners, condo and renters policies exclude flood, including storm surge from Long Island Sound and creeks or rivers overflowing. You need a separate NFIP or private flood policy.

Is flood insurance required in Fairfield?

It is required by your lender if the home is in a FEMA high-risk zone (A or V) and you have a federally backed mortgage. Elsewhere it is optional, but homes outside those zones still flood.

How long does it take for flood insurance to start?

New NFIP policies generally have a 30-day waiting period, with exceptions such as a purchase tied to a loan closing. Private flood waiting periods vary by carrier. Do not wait for a storm forecast.

What is the substantial damage rule in Fairfield?

If repairs or improvements to a home in the flood zone cost more than half the value of the structure, the Town requires it to be brought up to flood standards. Damage from any cause counts, including wind and fire.

My Fairfield home costs more to rebuild than the NFIP limit. What are my options?

A private flood policy with higher limits, or an excess flood policy above a primary flood policy. We compare both for your address.

Do you charge fees on flood insurance?

No. We do not charge fees of any kind on any policy we write.

Sources

• MetroCOG Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan, 2024 Update
• Town of Fairfield: Town Plan and Zoning Department (floodplain management)
• Town of Fairfield: Flood protection and preliminary FEMA maps
• FEMA Flood Map Service Center
• FloodSmart: Elevation certificates
• Connecticut Insurance Department: Homeowner Before the Storm
• Connecticut DEEP: National Flood Insurance Program

This page is general information about flood insurance in Fairfield, Connecticut. Flood is a separate policy from homeowners, and your policy wording controls coverage. Call (603) 431-4020 with questions about your situation.