Insurance basics · Renewals
By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Updated: November 4, 2026
- Read the new declarations page, not just the premium. Coverage, deductibles and endorsements can change.
- Premiums change for reasons beyond your own record, including statewide rate changes and rebuilding costs.
- Update the policy for life changes: renovations, new drivers, a home business, a new dog.
- A non-renewal notice needs fast action. Call your agent the day it arrives.
- Renewal is a good time for a review, and an independent agent can compare carriers.
Once a year (or every six months for many auto policies) an envelope or email shows up with your renewal. Most people look at the price, sigh or shrug, and file it. That’s understandable, but the renewal is the one time each year the carrier tells you exactly what you’re buying for the next term. Here’s what to look at, and why the number changes.
What a renewal is
Insurance policies run for a set term, usually twelve months for home and six or twelve months for auto. Near the end of the term, the carrier decides whether to offer you a new one and on what terms. If it does, you get a renewal offer or new declarations page. If you keep paying, the new term starts on the renewal date with whatever is on that page.
Your renewal review checklist
- Named insureds and address. Is everyone who should be on the policy listed? Did you move or add a co-owner?
- Dwelling limit. Does it still reflect what it would cost to rebuild? Renovations and rising construction costs both matter. Try our replacement cost estimator.
- Deductibles. The all-perils deductible, plus any wind, named storm or separate water deductible.
- Endorsements. Water backup, scheduled jewelry, service line, equipment breakdown. Were any added, removed or changed?
- Liability limits. Do they still fit what you own and earn? Consider an umbrella.
- Drivers and vehicles. New teen driver, a car you sold, someone who moved out.
- Discounts. Bundling, alarms, a new roof, paid-in-full, good student. Make sure the ones you qualify for are on there.
- Mortgagee and lienholders. Correct after a refinance or a car payoff?
Why premiums change at renewal
Premiums move for reasons that are about you, and reasons that have nothing to do with you. Our page on what affects your insurance premium goes deeper. In short:
Things about your policy
- Claims, including small ones (see does homeowners insurance go up after a claim)
- Tickets, accidents and new or young drivers on an auto policy
- A change in your credit-based insurance score, where state law allows carriers to use it
- Renovations or additions that raise the dwelling limit
- Ending a discount, like a student who graduated or a policy you moved elsewhere
- Your home’s roof getting older, or new information from an inspection
Things about the market
- Statewide rate changes. Carriers file rates with each state’s insurance department, and approved changes apply to everyone at renewal.
- Rebuilding and repair costs. Lumber, labor, auto parts and vehicle technology all affect what a claim costs.
- Weather. Storms, ice and water losses across a region push rates for everyone in it.
- Inflation guard. Many home policies automatically raise the dwelling limit each year to keep up with construction costs, which raises the premium too.
- Carrier appetite. A carrier may tighten underwriting in an area, change its rules on roofs or older homes, or pull back from a line of business.
In New Hampshire, for example, rates for home and auto have climbed for several of these reasons at once. Our post on why rates keep rising in New Hampshire explains more.
“A higher renewal premium isn’t always a reason to switch, and the same premium isn’t always a reason to stay. Read what changed, then call us so we can go over your options together.”
— Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance
Life changes to report before renewal
- A renovation, finished basement, new roof or updated electrical
- A pool, trampoline, wood stove or new dog
- Running a business from home or renting out a room
- A new driver, a driver moving out or a new commute
- Buying jewelry, art or other valuables
- Marriage, divorce or a move
You can send most changes through our policy change request. Our post on keeping your home insurance up to date has more ideas.
If you get a non-renewal notice
A non-renewal means the carrier won’t offer another term. States require advance written notice, and the reason can be a claim history, the home’s condition or the carrier pulling back from an area. Call us right away so there’s time to find new coverage. Read our guides for non-renewed homes in New Hampshire and homeowners non-renewal in Connecticut.
Should you shop at renewal?
Not every year by reflex, but renewal is the natural moment to check. It makes sense when the premium jumped, coverage changed, your life changed or it’s been a few years. As an independent agency we work with 40+ carriers, don’t charge fees, and can compare your current policy against others side by side. If switching makes sense, we time it to your renewal date. See how to change homeowners insurance for the steps.
Send us your renewal and we’ll walk through what changed and whether another carrier fits better. Call (603) 431-4020 in Portsmouth or (203) 859-6858 in Fairfield (Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM, Friday 8 AM–4 PM ET), or request a policy review.
Frequently asked questions
When does my insurance renewal arrive?
Carriers usually send a renewal offer or declarations page a few weeks before the policy expires. The exact timing depends on the carrier and your state. If you haven’t seen it and your expiration date is close, call us.
Why did my premium go up when nothing changed?
Your own situation is only part of the price. Carriers also adjust rates for everyone in a state based on the cost of repairs, medical care and claims in your area. Rebuilding costs, weather losses and updated property values can all raise a renewal even with no claims.
Will my policy renew automatically?
Many home and auto policies renew automatically if you’re paid up and the carrier offers renewal. Automatic doesn’t mean nothing changed, so read the new declarations page for changes in coverage, deductibles and endorsements.
What is a non-renewal?
A non-renewal means the carrier has decided not to offer you another policy term. States require carriers to give advance written notice. If you get one, call us right away so there’s time to find coverage elsewhere.
Should I shop my insurance at every renewal?
Not necessarily every year, but a renewal is a natural time for a review, especially after a big premium change, a life change or a coverage change you didn’t expect. An independent agent can compare carriers for you.
Can I change my coverage at renewal?
Yes. Renewal is a good time to adjust deductibles, update your dwelling limit, add or remove drivers and vehicles, or add coverage like water backup or an umbrella. Tell us before the renewal date so changes take effect with the new term.
Sources
- Insurance Information Institute, Homeowners Insurance Handbook (PDF), checked November 4, 2026.
- New Hampshire Insurance Department, Consumer resources, checked November 4, 2026.
- Connecticut Insurance Department, Consumer resources, checked November 4, 2026.
- Massachusetts Division of Insurance, Filing an insurance complaint, checked November 4, 2026.
This article is general information, not an offer of coverage or a promise that any loss is covered. Your policy wording and each carrier’s underwriting decide coverage.
Related guides: What affects your insurance premium · How to change homeowners insurance · Request a policy review · Umbrella insurance
Next step: Request a policy review or call (603) 431-4020.

