Andover Companies Home Insurance Review (2026): High-Value Homes, A Local Agent’s View

Published on: October 5, 2026

High-value homesNH · CT · MA · MEIndependent agent review

By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Reviewed by Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Key takeaways

  • The Andover Companies dates to 1828 in Andover, Massachusetts. Its insurers are Merrimack, Cambridge and Bay State, and the group moved to a mutual holding company structure on January 1, 2026.
  • AM Best rates the Andover Companies Pool A (Excellent) for financial strength, and Andover says it has been rated A or higher since 1940.
  • Andover’s Superior Home plan builds in replacement cost and open perils coverage on contents, plus ordinance or law coverage. Add-ons cover valuables, water backup, home systems and umbrella liability.
  • Through Portsmouth Atlantic, Andover can write homes up to $2M in Connecticut, up to $2.25M in Massachusetts and up to $1.5M in New Hampshire.
  • Above those amounts, we compare Chubb and Cincinnati, which write homes at any dwelling limit, plus Openly, National General and Hanover.

Is Andover a good choice for a high-value home? For many New England homeowners, it is one of the first carriers we check. The Andover Companies has insured property in the Northeast since 1828, AM Best rates the group A (Excellent), and its home plan builds in coverage that many homeowners would otherwise have to add. Andover sells only through independent agents, and Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance represents Andover from our office in Portsmouth, NH. This review covers what Andover does well for larger and older homes, how much home it can insure through us in each state, and when we look at other carriers instead.

Blue-gray Cape-style coastal New England home with a manicured lawn and a white picket fence
A coastal New England home (photographed in Maine). Photo: James Anthony / Pexels.

Who is The Andover Companies?

The Andover Companies was founded in 1828 by town leaders in Andover, Massachusetts, who wanted a way to rebuild after a catastrophic fire. They formed Merrimack Mutual Fire, a company owned by its policyholders. Merrimack added Cambridge Mutual Fire in 1913 and Bay State in 1955, and the three now make up The Andover Companies (Andover, our history). Andover calls itself one of the largest and longest-standing mutual insurance groups in the Northeast.

Andover reorganized into a mutual holding company structure effective January 1, 2026. Merrimack Mutual became Merrimack Insurance Company and Cambridge Mutual became Cambridge Insurance Company. Both are now owned through a new mutual holding company, The Andover Companies, Inc. (Andover press release, January 8, 2026). Andover says the change will improve efficiency and support its long-term position. It is still headquartered in Massachusetts (Andover, Massachusetts).

Andover’s personal and business insurance is sold only through independent insurance agencies in the Northeast and Illinois (Andover, contact us). That is why you will not find an Andover quote online. You get it through an agent like us.

What is Andover’s AM Best rating?

AM Best rates Merrimack, Cambridge and Bay State, the members of the Andover Companies Pool, A (Excellent) for financial strength. Each also carries an a+ long-term issuer credit rating with a stable outlook. The AM Best report Andover posts shows those ratings affirmed effective September 25, 2025, with balance sheet strength assessed as very strong (AM Best rating report).

Andover says the group has been rated A (Excellent) or higher by AM Best since 1940, and its financials page still shows the A rating as of this update (Andover financials). Ratings can change, so we confirm the current rating of the company named on your quote.

Founded in Andover, MA

Andover began as a policyholder-owned fire insurer and has insured Northeast property for nearly 200 years.

AM Best A (Excellent)

The Andover Companies Pool is rated A for financial strength with an a+ issuer credit rating.

Eight states

Andover writes in the Northeast and Illinois, only through independent agents.

Independent agents only

You get Andover through an agency like ours, not online or through a call center.

Where does Andover write home insurance?

Andover has state pages for Connecticut, Illinois, Maine, Massachusetts, New Hampshire, New Jersey, New York and Rhode Island (Andover, contact us). Portsmouth Atlantic writes Andover homes in New Hampshire, Connecticut, Massachusetts and Maine. We cannot write Andover in Vermont, so for Vermont homes we quote our other carriers.

New Hampshire

Andover partners with independent agents across New Hampshire for home and business insurance (Andover, New Hampshire). Through our agency, Andover can write New Hampshire homes up to $1.5M. That covers many Seacoast homes, lake houses and older colonials. For larger New Hampshire homes, we compare Chubb, Cincinnati, Openly, National General and Hanover.

Connecticut

Andover writes Connecticut homes through the state’s independent agencies (Andover, Connecticut). Through Portsmouth Atlantic, Andover can write Connecticut homes up to $2M. We work with Connecticut homeowners by phone, email and online.

Massachusetts and Maine

Massachusetts is Andover’s home state (Andover, Massachusetts). Through our agency, Andover can write Massachusetts homes up to $2.25M. Andover is also one of our Maine property carriers (Andover, Maine), which helps families with a primary home in one state and a second home in another.

What Portsmouth Atlantic writes with Andover

StateAndover homes through Portsmouth Atlantic
ConnecticutUp to $2M
MassachusettsUp to $2.25M
New HampshireUp to $1.5M
MaineAvailable. Ask us about your home.
VermontNot available through us. We quote other carriers.
Portsmouth Atlantic placement guidelines as of October 2026. Every home is subject to Andover underwriting.

What is Andover’s Superior Home Insurance Protection Plan?

Andover’s main homeowners product is its Superior Home Insurance Protection Plan. Andover says the plan automatically includes coverages that many policies treat as add-ons (Andover homeowners insurance):

Ordinance or law

Helps pay for building code upgrades required when you repair or rebuild after a covered loss.

Replacement cost on contents

Belongings are covered at what it costs to replace them, not a depreciated value.

Open perils on contents

Personal property is covered against all risks except those the policy excludes.

Personal property protection

Broad contents protection is part of the base plan.

Open perils coverage on contents is the main difference Andover draws between an HO-3 and an HO-5 policy. An HO-3 covers belongings only for the named perils listed in the policy. An HO-5-style approach covers them unless a cause is excluded (Andover, HO-3 vs. HO-5). For a higher-value home with more valuable contents, that broader form matters.

What stands out for higher-value and older homes?

Valuables: Scheduled Personal Property

Andover’s Scheduled Personal Property endorsement lets you insure jewelry, antiques, fine art, sports memorabilia and stamp, card and coin collections. Andover says these items can typically be insured up to their professionally appraised value. The endorsement can also cover losses a standard policy may not, such as mistakenly losing an item or a loss while you wear or use it away from home (Andover, Scheduled Personal Property).

Higher sublimits: the Additional Coverage Endorsement

Andover’s Additional Coverage Endorsement raises limits on categories that standard policies cap, including silverware, business property, watercraft, money, and jewelry and furs. It also adds personal injury coverage, refrigerated items and lock replacement (Andover, Additional Coverage Endorsement).

Home systems and underground service lines

Older New England homes often have boilers, well pumps and long underground lines. Andover’s Home Systems Protection with Service Line Coverage Endorsement can help pay for a sudden mechanical or electrical breakdown of covered systems and for leaks, breaks or collapse of covered service lines. Andover lists boilers, furnaces and heat pumps, water heaters, well pumps and sump pumps, permanent generators and underground water, power and data lines (Andover, Home Systems Protection).

Water backup and sump overflow

A standard policy usually will not pay for water that backs up through a drain or sewer or overflows from a sump. Andover’s Water Backup and Sump Discharge or Overflow Coverage adds limited coverage for structural repairs, belongings, standing sewage cleanup and minor mold caused by the backup (Andover, water backup coverage). For a finished basement, this is one of the first add-ons we review.

Historic homes

Andover’s guide to historic home insurance recommends three coverages for homes at least 50 years old with architectural or historical significance. Extended Reconstruction Cost may add 25% to 50% more coverage to restore the home with materials of like kind and quality. An Ordinance or Law endorsement may raise that coverage up to 100% of your dwelling limit. Scheduled Personal Property covers antiques and period pieces (Andover, historic home insurance). Availability depends on your state and home, so we confirm what applies before we quote.

Other Andover coverages

CoverageWhat Andover says it offers
Personal umbrellaWorldwide liability limits above your home and auto, with the option to extend personal liability coverage up to $5 million
Watercraft programCoverage added to your Andover home policy for private leisure boats: powered boats up to 32 feet and up to 50 mph, sailboats up to 40 feet, and non-powered boats on inland waters
SnowmobileLiability and physical damage protection for snowmobiles used for private leisure, added to your Andover home policy
Identity Recovery and Home CyberOptional endorsements for identity theft recovery and home cyber threats
Theft in or to a Dwelling Under ConstructionAn optional endorsement for homes being built or renovated
Home Day CareAn optional endorsement for in-home day care
Source: The Andover Companies product pages. Availability and terms vary by state and policy; read your policy for exact limits and exclusions.

Is your dwelling coverage keeping up?

For a high-value home, the most important number on the policy is the dwelling limit. Andover says your dwelling coverage should be based on what it would cost to rebuild your home, not what you paid for it or its market value. That cost depends on the size and style of the house, its special features and local construction costs, and it changes as those costs change (Andover, how much dwelling coverage do I need).

Other structures coverage is often set at 10% of the dwelling limit. Andover notes that may not be enough if you have a barn, a large shed or a detached garage with living space. We review both numbers at every renewal and whenever you renovate.

Jon Merwin, founder and CEO of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance

Expert tip

“With rising inflation, dwelling replacement costs have gone up, and the goalposts have shifted. The dwelling coverage a high-value home needs now is much higher than it was. The upside is that carriers are expanding their appetite for higher-value homes, so homeowners have more good choices.”

— Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance

Who is Andover best for?

  • Homeowners within Andover’s limits who want broad coverage built in. Replacement cost and open perils on contents come with the Superior Home plan.
  • Owners of older and historic New England homes. Andover’s historic home guidance, ordinance or law coverage and home systems endorsement fit older houses well.
  • Families with jewelry, art or collections. Scheduled Personal Property covers items up to their professionally appraised value.
  • Families with homes in more than one New England state. We write Andover in NH, CT, MA and Maine.
  • Homeowners who want a regional insurer. Andover has focused on Northeast property since 1828.

Compare Andover with our other high-value carriers

Tell us about your home, its age and what’s inside, and we’ll show you how Andover compares with Chubb, Cincinnati, Openly, National General and Hanover.

Start Your Quote Call (603) 431-4020

What are Andover’s pros and cons?

ProsThings to know
AM Best A (Excellent), and A or higher since 1940Through us, Andover’s home limits are up to $2M in CT, up to $2.25M in MA and up to $1.5M in NH
Replacement cost and open perils on contents built into the home planValuables, water backup and home systems coverage are add-ons you choose
Nearly 200 years insuring Northeast propertyWe cannot write Andover in Vermont
Historic home, valuables and umbrella optionsSold only through independent agents, so there is no direct online quote
Based on Andover’s public pages and Portsmouth Atlantic placement guidelines as of October 2026.

How do Andover claims work?

Andover gives you three ways to report a claim: online through your myAndover account, available 24/7; by phone at 800-225-0770; or through your agent. Andover’s claims office hours are 8:15 a.m. to 4:30 p.m. ET, Monday through Friday. Non-emergency claims reported by phone after hours are processed the next business day (Andover, report a claim).

After a loss, Andover says your first step is to make sure everyone is safe. If it is safe, you can take steps to prevent more damage, but do not make permanent repairs before an Andover representative has inspected the property. If you insure with Andover through us, call us at (603) 431-4020 and we will help you start the claim.

Why we place high-value clients with Andover

We place clients with Andover when the home fits its limits and the family wants broad property coverage from a regional insurer. Andover is a natural fit for older homes, coastal Capes and lake houses, where the built-in contents coverage and historic home options matter most.

Jon Merwin, founder and CEO of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance

Expert tip

“One of the many reasons we trust our clients with Andover Companies is because they’re a regional company. Their claims and customer service reps all live in New Hampshire, Maine and Massachusetts, and we have a great relationship with them. They’re a strategic partner of ours.”

— Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance

Andover covers a lot of New England homes well. Our job is to know where its limits are, and which carrier fits best when your home goes past them.

Where Andover fits among our high-value carriers

Portsmouth Atlantic works with 40+ carriers, so Andover is one of several high-value options we compare for every home.

CarrierWhere it fits through Portsmouth Atlantic
AndoverHomes up to $2M in CT, up to $2.25M in MA and up to $1.5M in NH
ChubbHomes at any dwelling limit, written in all 10 states where we are licensed
CincinnatiHomes at any dwelling limit, written in all 10 states where we are licensed
OpenlyHomes up to about $5M in NH, ME, MA, CT, OH and IL
National GeneralHomes up to about $5M
HanoverAnother high-value option we compare
Portsmouth Atlantic placement guidelines as of October 2026. Every home is subject to underwriting.

See our high-net-worth insurance page for how we insure larger homes and collections.

Frequently asked questions

Is Andover a good insurance company for a high-value home?

For many New England homes up to its limits, yes. AM Best rates the Andover Companies Pool A (Excellent), and Andover says it has been rated A or higher since 1940. Its Superior Home plan builds in replacement cost and open perils coverage on contents, and it offers valuables, home systems, water backup and umbrella add-ons. Through Portsmouth Atlantic, Andover can write homes up to $2M in Connecticut, up to $2.25M in Massachusetts and up to $1.5M in New Hampshire.

How much home can Andover insure through Portsmouth Atlantic?

Through our agency, Andover can write homes up to $2M in Connecticut, up to $2.25M in Massachusetts and up to $1.5M in New Hampshire. Every home is still underwritten on its own. For homes above those amounts, we compare Chubb and Cincinnati, which write homes at any dwelling limit, along with Openly and National General.

What is Andover’s AM Best rating?

AM Best rates Merrimack, Cambridge and Bay State, the members of the Andover Companies Pool, A (Excellent) for financial strength with an a+ issuer credit rating and a stable outlook. The rating report Andover posts is effective September 25, 2025, and Andover’s financials page still shows the A rating.

Is Andover still a mutual insurance company?

Andover reorganized into a mutual holding company structure effective January 1, 2026. Merrimack and Cambridge became stock insurance companies owned through a new mutual holding company, The Andover Companies, Inc. Andover still describes itself as one of the Northeast’s leading mutual insurers.

Does Andover cover jewelry, art and collections?

Yes, through its Scheduled Personal Property endorsement. Andover says you can typically insure jewelry, antiques, fine art, sports memorabilia and stamp, card and coin collections up to their professionally appraised value, including losses such as mistakenly losing an item or a loss while you are wearing or using it away from home.

How do I file an Andover claim?

Andover says you can report a claim online through your myAndover account, available 24/7, call Andover at 800-225-0770, or contact your agent. If you insure with Andover through Portsmouth Atlantic, call us at (603) 431-4020 and we can help you start it.

Related reading

Sources

This review is general information, not a policy. Coverage, forms and availability vary by state and policy, and every policy is subject to underwriting. Your policy documents control.

Related carrier reviews: Cincinnati Insurance Review (2026) · Chubb Insurance Review (2026) · Openly Review (2026) · High-net-worth insurance

Get an Andover quote for your NH, CT, MA or Maine home

We’ll check whether your home fits Andover and compare it side by side with our other high-value carriers.

Start Your Quote Call (603) 431-4020

Jon Merwin, founder and CEO of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance

Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Jon founded Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance in 2005 in Portsmouth, NH. Our family-owned independent agency is licensed in 10 states and works with 40+ carriers, and we have earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. We don’t charge additional fees. Meet our team.

Call Email Claims Payments