By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Short answer: Both add liability coverage on top of your home, auto and other policies. An excess liability policy generally follows the policy underneath it: it pays more, for the same kinds of claims. An umbrella usually goes a step further and can cover some claims the underlying policies don’t, after you pay a retained limit. Most families buy a personal umbrella; excess policies are more common for businesses, associations and some high-value households.

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency that compares 40+ carriers. For personal umbrellas, carriers we work with include Safety Insurance (MA, NH and ME), Andover Companies (NH, MA, CT and ME), Plymouth Rock (NH, MA, CT and NY) and Vermont Mutual (MA).

Fenced in-ground backyard pool with lounge chairs behind a shingled New England home

Umbrella vs. excess liability at a glance

UmbrellaExcess liability
Where it sitsAbove your home, auto, watercraft and other liability policiesAbove one or more specific underlying policies
What it coversClaims covered underneath, plus some claims the underlying policies don’t coverGenerally only what the underlying policy covers (it follows form)
Claims not covered underneathMay respond after you pay a retained limit (self-insured retention)Usually no coverage
Underlying limitsRequired; minimums set by the carrierRequired; minimums set by the carrier
Legal defense costsOften paid in addition to the limit; check the formDepends on the form; check whether defense reduces the limit
Who typically buys itHouseholds: homeowners, condo owners, renters, landlordsBusinesses, condo associations and apartment buildings, some high-value households
Typical limitsSold in $1 million layersSold in layers; can stack above an umbrella

These are general patterns. Policy forms differ, and a product’s name doesn’t always match how it works, so we compare the actual wording.

Why the difference matters

Most of the time, an umbrella and an excess policy behave the same way: your auto or homeowners policy pays up to its limit, and the extra layer pays the rest of a covered claim. The difference shows up at the edges, when a claim isn’t covered by the policy underneath. An umbrella may step in for certain claims, such as some personal injury claims like libel or slander, depending on the form. An excess policy that follows form won’t.

A New England example

A guest slips on an icy back step at your Seacoast home and is badly hurt. Your homeowners liability pays to its limit, and the umbrella or excess layer pays the rest of the covered judgment. Both work the same here. Now picture a dispute over something you posted online. If your homeowners form doesn’t cover that kind of claim, an umbrella with personal injury coverage might, while a follow-form excess policy wouldn’t.

What raises your liability exposure

  • Teen or newly licensed drivers in the household
  • A pool, trampoline, dock or dog
  • Boats, jet skis, snowmobiles or ATVs
  • Rental properties, including a condo you rent out
  • Serving on a volunteer or nonprofit board
  • Hosting often, or a home that draws visitors

For condo associations and apartment buildings, the liability layer sits above the association’s or owner’s habitational package. See small condo association insurance and apartment building insurance in New Hampshire.

State guides

New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut, Maine and Vermont. Product overview: umbrella insurance.

Back to all comparisons: Compare insurance options.

Frequently asked questions

Is a personal umbrella the same as excess liability?

Not exactly, though people use the terms loosely. Both add liability limits above your home, auto and other policies. An excess policy generally follows the underlying policy, so it covers only what that policy covers. An umbrella can also cover some claims the underlying policies don’t, usually after you pay a retained limit. Read the policy form: some products labeled one way behave like the other.

How much umbrella or excess coverage should I carry?

There’s no single right number. Many people start by looking at what they own and what they earn, since a large judgment can reach both. Teen drivers, pools, docks, boats, rental properties and a public-facing job can all raise your exposure. Try our umbrella insurance calculator, then let’s talk it through.

Do I have to carry certain limits on my home and auto first?

Yes. Every umbrella and excess carrier requires minimum liability limits on the underlying policies, and the minimums vary by carrier. If an underlying limit is too low, you may have to pay the gap yourself. We line the policies up so the layers meet.

Will my umbrella cover a rental property I own?

Often it can, if the rental property’s liability policy is listed as underlying coverage and the carrier allows it. Some carriers limit the number or type of rentals. Tell us about every property you own so none fall through the gap.

Does a personal umbrella cover my boat or snowmobile?

It can, when the boat or recreational vehicle has its own liability policy that meets the umbrella carrier’s minimums and is listed as underlying coverage. Some watercraft, by size or horsepower, need a carrier’s approval. Ask us before the season starts.

Get an umbrella quote

Send your current home and auto declarations pages and we’ll show you how the layers fit. We don’t charge any fees. Call (603) 431-4020, email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com or start your quote online.

Call Email Claims Payments