By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Short answer: NFIP flood insurance is the federal program run by FEMA, with set coverage limits and rules that are the same everywhere. Private flood insurance comes from private insurers, with limits, waiting periods and extras that vary by carrier. For many New England homes, the right answer is to quote both and compare them line by line.

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance places new NFIP policies through Selective and quotes private flood with carriers including Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge. Our flood carriers write in every state we’re licensed in.

Gray-shingled coastal cottages beside a flooded tidal marsh

NFIP vs. private flood at a glance

NFIP (federal)Private flood
Who backs itThe National Flood Insurance Program, run by FEMAPrivate insurers, each with its own policy form
Building coverageUp to $250,000 for a homeVaries by carrier; some offer higher limits
Contents coverageUp to $100,000Varies by carrier
Temporary housing (loss of use)Not coveredSome policies include it or offer it
BasementsLimited: some building items, not most belongingsVaries by policy
Waiting periodGenerally 30 days, with exceptions such as a loan closingVaries; often shorter
How it’s pricedFEMA’s rating for each buildingEach carrier’s own rating and underwriting
Lender acceptanceAccepted by lendersFederally regulated lenders must accept policies that meet the federal definition
Above the limitsExcess flood policies can sit on topHigher limits may remove the need for excess

NFIP limits and exclusions are from FloodSmart (FEMA). Private flood terms depend on the carrier and the policy form, so we compare actual quotes rather than generalize.

When NFIP tends to fit

  • The home’s NFIP rating works well, or the seller has an NFIP policy you can take over.
  • The building is a type private carriers are cautious about, such as some older homes right on the water.
  • You want a policy whose terms don’t change from carrier to carrier.

When private flood tends to fit

  • The home’s rebuild cost is well above $250,000, which is common for coastal homes from Rye to Greenwich.
  • You want coverage for temporary housing while the home is repaired.
  • You need coverage to start sooner than the NFIP’s standard waiting period allows.
  • The private quote compares well on the same limits and deductible.

New England flood risk isn’t only on the beach

On the coast, nor’easters and storm surge are the main threat for places like Hampton, Seabrook, the Connecticut shoreline and Cape Cod. Inland, rivers and snowmelt do the damage: the Piscataqua watershed, the Merrimack, and the Housatonic in Connecticut. Heavy rain can flood basements anywhere, and a standard homeowners policy excludes flood in all of these cases.

Local guides: Seacoast NH, Portsmouth, Hampton, Rye, Connecticut, Massachusetts and Maine.

How we compare flood quotes

  1. Check the flood zone and, if there is one, the elevation certificate.
  2. Price NFIP building and contents coverage at the limits you need.
  3. Quote private flood at the same limits and deductible, plus higher limits if the rebuild cost calls for it.
  4. Compare exclusions, basement coverage, temporary housing, waiting period and what your lender will accept.

Back to all comparisons: Compare insurance options. Related: flood insurance, check your flood zone and HO-3 vs. HO-6.

Frequently asked questions

Will my mortgage lender accept a private flood policy?

Usually, if the policy meets the federal definition of private flood insurance. Under the 2019 federal private flood insurance rule, federally regulated lenders must accept private policies that meet that definition, and they may accept others that meet their own standards. Ask your lender early in the purchase, and we’ll send the policy details they need.

How long is the waiting period for flood insurance?

A new NFIP policy generally takes 30 days to go into effect. There are exceptions, such as when the coverage is required in connection with making, increasing or renewing a loan. Private flood waiting periods vary by carrier and are often shorter. Either way, don’t wait for a storm forecast to buy.

Can I switch from NFIP to private flood, or back?

Yes, you can move between them, but talk to us first. Leaving the NFIP can affect rating benefits that depend on keeping a policy continuously in force, and a private carrier can choose not to renew. We’ll compare both before you change anything.

Do I need flood insurance if I’m not in a high-risk flood zone?

A lender only requires it in a mapped high-risk zone, but flooding happens outside those zones too, from heavy rain, snowmelt and storm surge. A standard homeowners policy doesn’t cover flood. Check your address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center or our flood zone check, then decide.

Does a condo association need its own flood policy?

If the building is in a flood zone, the association often carries a master flood policy on the building, either through the NFIP’s Residential Condominium Building Association Policy (RCBAP) or a private carrier. Unit owners can add their own flood policy for belongings and the parts of the unit they’re responsible for.

Can a buyer take over the seller’s NFIP policy?

An NFIP policy can be assigned to the buyer when a home is sold, which can help if the existing policy has favorable rating. Private policies follow each carrier’s rules. Ask the seller for the current flood declarations page early.

Get NFIP and private flood quotes side by side

Send the property address and any elevation certificate. We don’t charge any fees. Call (603) 431-4020, email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com or start a quote.

Sources

Call Email Claims Payments