A Practical Guide to the Best Insurance Agencies in New Hampshire

Published on: November 11, 2026

By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Published November 11, 2026 · Google listings rechecked November 13, 2026

Most “best insurance agency” lists put every agency in one pile. That isn’t how people shop. A family insuring a home and two cars, a business owner who needs general liability and workers’ compensation, and someone comparing Medicare plans need very different agencies. So this guide gives three short lists for New Hampshire: the best agencies for personal lines (home, auto, umbrella), commercial lines (business insurance) and life and health (including Medicare).

We’re Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, a family-owned independent agency in Portsmouth, founded in 2005. We wrote this guide, and we rank ourselves on the personal lines list, so we explain exactly how we chose every agency below. We don’t write commercial insurance (other than businessowners policies for apartment and rental buildings) or life and health insurance, so we’re not on those lists. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance does not write life insurance or workers’ compensation. When clients need that coverage, we refer them to specialists.

Key facts

  • Three short lists of New Hampshire agencies: personal lines (5), commercial lines (4) and life and health (5).
  • Google ratings change daily, so this page does not publish a snapshot of those figures. Check each agency’s current Google listing if a rating matters to you.
  • Each agency is described by years in business, whether it is independent or captive, its New Hampshire offices, and its specialty.
  • Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote this guide and appears only on the personal lines list. We received nothing from any agency listed.
  • These are practical shortlists by focus, not a ranking.

How we chose

We wanted criteria anyone can check in a few minutes, so we used only public, verifiable facts:

Years in business

The founding year the agency states on its own website or public profile. If we couldn’t find one, we say so.

Independent, NH-based, specialized

Whether the agency represents several insurers, where its New Hampshire offices are, and which lines it focuses on.

The rules. Google ratings change daily, so this page does not publish a snapshot of those figures. Check each agency’s current Google listing if a rating matters to you. We rechecked each agency’s Google listing on November 13, 2026, and used one listing per agency (the office named in the table). We started with agencies that showed up in Google Maps searches for New Hampshire insurance agencies and in our own earlier review studies, then kept agencies with an office in New Hampshire and a rating of 4.5 or higher. Within each list, agencies are ordered by review count. For commercial lines, where review counts run lower, we gave extra weight to agencies with dedicated business insurance departments and long track records. We did not contact the agencies, and no one paid to be included. Agency descriptions come from each agency’s own website.

Disclosure. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote and publishes this guide, and we rank ourselves first on the personal lines list. Our review figure is our approved agency-wide number across our New Hampshire and Connecticut Google listings, so it isn’t directly comparable to the single-office counts of other agencies. For office-by-office counts, see our top 10 independent insurance agencies in NH and CT and our top 5 insurance agencies in Portsmouth, NH.

Best personal lines insurance agencies in New Hampshire

Personal lines means insurance for you and your household: homeowners, condo, renters, auto, umbrella, flood, boats and recreational vehicles. Look for an independent agency that can compare several carriers for your home and car together.

Agency (Google listing)Years in businessIndependent or captiveNH officesSpecialty
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, PortsmouthFounded 2005Independent (40+ carriers)PortsmouthHome, auto, umbrella, flood, high-value homes
Fortified Insurance Agency, ManchesterSince 2009 (per its website)IndependentManchesterAuto, home, life, business
Keslar Insurance Agency, NewmarketFounded 2009 (per its website)IndependentNewmarket, Rochester, AltonHome, auto, business
French Insurance Agency, HudsonSince 1928 (per its website)IndependentHudsonHome, auto, business, life
MAC Insurance Inc, LondonderryIncorporated 2019; owner licensed since 2006IndependentLondonderryAuto, home, recreational and classic vehicles

1. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, Portsmouth
This is our agency, so weigh this entry accordingly. We’re a family-owned independent agency founded in 2005, licensed in 10 states, with 40+ carriers and an A+ BBB rating. We’re New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials, and our team brings 200+ years of combined experience. We don’t charge additional fees. See our New Hampshire insurance agency page and our client reviews.

2. Fortified Insurance Agency, Manchester
An independent agency in Manchester with one of the highest review counts in the state for a single office. It writes auto, home, life and business insurance.

3. Keslar Insurance Agency, Newmarket
A Seacoast independent agency with offices in Newmarket, Rochester and Alton, serving New Hampshire, Maine and Massachusetts with home, auto and business coverage.

4. French Insurance Agency, Hudson
The longest track record on this list: its website says it has been local and independent since 1928. It offers personal, business and life insurance from several carriers.

5. MAC Insurance Inc, Londonderry
A newer independent agency with a near-perfect review record, known for auto and specialty vehicle coverage such as classic cars, RVs and off-road vehicles.

The best agency for your home and car may not be the best agency for your business or your Medicare plan. Pick the specialist for the job.

Best commercial lines insurance agencies in New Hampshire

Commercial lines covers businesses: general liability, commercial property, commercial auto, workers’ compensation, professional liability and bonds. Business owners usually benefit from an agency with a dedicated commercial team and access to carriers that write their industry. For business-focused offices we also weighed track record and commercial depth.

Agency (Google listing)Years in businessIndependent or captiveNH officesSpecialty
Bernier Insurance Agency, RochesterFounded 1981IndependentRochester, AltonPersonal and commercial; P&C focused
Gallant Insurance, BowSince 1989 (family-owned)IndependentBow (Concord area)Business, contractors, commercial auto, apartment buildings
Davis & Towle Insurance Group, ConcordTowle family-owned since 1954IndependentConcord, plus affiliated NH officesCommercial, bonds, employee benefits, personal
Cross Insurance, PortsmouthFounded 1954 (Bangor, ME)IndependentPortsmouth, Manchester, LaconiaCommercial by industry, benefits, bonds, personal

1. Bernier Insurance Agency, Rochester
A second-generation independent agency founded in 1981 that handles personal and commercial lines, with offices in Rochester and Alton.

2. Gallant Insurance, Bow
A family-owned independent agency serving New Hampshire since 1989, with business insurance pages for contractors, commercial auto, employment practices liability and apartment buildings.

3. Davis & Towle Insurance Group, Concord
One of New Hampshire’s largest family-owned insurance organizations, owned by the Towle family since 1954. It lists a full commercial menu, from general liability and workers’ compensation to directors and officers coverage and bonds.

4. Cross Insurance, Portsmouth
A large family-owned independent agency founded in 1954, with more than 40 offices across the Northeast and three in New Hampshire. Its commercial team works across industries such as construction, real estate, hospitality and manufacturing.

Own an apartment building or a rental property? That’s the one commercial area we do write, through businessowners policies. See apartment building insurance.

Best life and health insurance agencies in New Hampshire

Life and health agencies help with individual and family health plans, Medicare, life insurance and supplemental coverage. This list is about finding an agency, not about which plan or policy is right for you; a licensed life or health agent should help with that.

Agency (Google listing)Years in businessIndependent or captiveNH officesSpecialty
Dublin Health & Benefit Group, DublinEstablished 2005 (per its website)Broker (multiple carriers, per its website)DublinMedicare, individual and group health
The Integrity Agency, DoverFoundation laid in 2018 (per its website)Not stated on its websiteDoverHealth, Medicare, life, long-term care
The Cronin Agency, PortsmouthNot stated on its websiteNot stated on its websitePortsmouthMedicare and retirement planning
Karen Archer Insurance, WindhamOwner: 20+ years in insurance (agency year not stated)Represents many companies (per its website)WindhamMedicare, health, life, dental and vision
Core Benefits Group, HampsteadFounded 2010Independent brokerHampstead, Exeter (affiliate)Health, Medicare, group plans, plus P&C

1. Dublin Health & Benefit Group, Dublin
Established in 2005, this broker focuses on Medicare options and individual, family and group health coverage, and has the most Google reviews of any life and health agency we found in New Hampshire.

2. The Integrity Agency, Dover
A Seacoast agency covering health, Medicare, life, long-term care and supplemental dental and vision coverage.

3. The Cronin Agency, Portsmouth
A Portsmouth agency focused on Medicare and retirement planning.

4. Karen Archer Insurance, Windham
A Windham agency offering Medicare, health, life, and dental and vision coverage, and says it represents many different companies.

5. Core Benefits Group, Hampstead
Founded in 2010, Core works with local, regional and national carriers on health, Medicare and group plans, and also writes personal and business insurance.

How to choose an insurance agency in New Hampshire

Match the specialty

Choose an agency that does a lot of the kind of insurance you need.

Read recent reviews

Look past the star rating to recent reviews about claims and service.

Ask how many carriers

An independent agency can compare several insurers. Learn more in independent vs captive agents.

Check the license

Confirm any agent with the New Hampshire Insurance Department.

For more on picking a local agency, read choosing an independent insurance agency in Portsmouth, NH and why Portsmouth Atlantic is New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google. Homeowners can start with Portsmouth, NH homeowners insurance or New Hampshire high-value home insurance.

Talk to us about your home and auto insurance

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is family-owned, founded in 2005 and licensed in 10 states. We compare 40+ carriers, our team brings 200+ years of combined experience, and we have 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. We don’t charge additional fees. Call (603) 431-4020 or start your quote online. If you need business, life or health coverage, ask us for a referral.

Start Your Quote

Frequently asked questions

What is the best insurance agency in New Hampshire?

It depends on what you need insured. For home and auto, our personal lines list starts with Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, Fortified, Keslar, French and MAC. For a business, see the commercial list, and for Medicare or health coverage, see the life and health list. We wrote this guide and rank ourselves in personal lines.

How did you choose these agencies?

We used four public criteria: years in business, whether the agency is independent or captive, its New Hampshire offices, and its specialty. Google ratings change daily, so they are not published as a snapshot here.

Why isn’t Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance on the commercial or life and health lists?

We focus on personal lines. Other than businessowners policies for apartment and rental buildings, we don’t write commercial insurance, and we don’t write life or health insurance. When clients need those, we refer them to specialists.

What is the difference between an independent and a captive agency?

An independent agency can quote policies from several insurance companies. A captive agency represents one company. Both can serve clients well; the difference is how many companies the agent can compare.

How often will this guide be updated?

We rechecked the listings on November 13, 2026, and plan to recheck the ratings and review counts regularly. Counts change daily, so the live Google listing is always the most current number.

Call Email Claims Payments