Key takeaways
- A star average means little on its own. Read for volume, recency and specifics.
- Look for the same praise from many different people: quick answers, several carriers compared, clear explanations, help at closings and claims.
- Check how an agency replies when a review isn’t glowing.
- Portsmouth Atlantic is New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.
- Mid-November is a good time to book a year-end policy review, before nor’easter season gets going.
It’s mid-November. The first real nor’easter of the season is on the forecast, your renewal notice is sitting on the counter, and you’re wondering whether your insurance agency is the right one. You search, and every agency on the first page seems to have close to five stars. So how do you tell them apart?
Here’s the short answer. A top-rated insurance agency isn’t just one with a high average. It’s one whose reviews, read in bulk, keep describing the same things: people get a call back, someone compares more than one carrier for them, their questions get answered in plain English, and the agency is still there when a closing date or a claim gets stressful.
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials. That milestone is the reason for this new monthly series. This first post covers the basics: how to judge any agency by its reviews, and what our clients say matters most.
Why doesn’t the star rating alone tell you much?
Star averages bunch up near the top, so the number by itself rarely separates a great agency from an ordinary one. What separates them is underneath.
Volume and recency
A handful of five-star reviews can come from friends and family in a single month. Hundreds of reviews written over many years are much harder to manufacture, and they show how an agency behaves across lots of situations: first homes, teen drivers, storm claims, renewals that went up. Sort by “Newest,” too. An agency that was great five years ago and has gone quiet since isn’t telling you much about today.
Specifics beat superlatives
“Great service!” is nice. “They found us coverage for an old house two days before closing” is useful. Look for reviews that describe a situation, a problem that got solved, or the person who solved it. When the same kinds of details show up from different people, you’re looking at a pattern, not a fluke.
The less-than-perfect reviews
No agency gets every renewal or claim exactly right. Read the three- and four-star reviews. Did the owner reply? Is the reply defensive or helpful? Does it sound like the problem got fixed? That tells you more about what happens when something goes wrong than a page of perfect scores.
Is the review about the agency or the insurance company?
Plenty of insurance reviews are really about a carrier’s pricing or a claim decision. An agency review should tell you about the people: did they explain your options, follow up, and step in when you needed help?
What do our clients praise most?
We read our Google reviews and client survey comments closely, and a few themes come up far more than any others. Below are some of them, with comments clients shared on our client feedback page, quoted exactly as they appear there.
Quick, real answers
Speed comes up constantly, but not in the instant-online-quote sense. Clients mention that a real person called them back or handled a change without a runaround.
Jon is super helpful and amazingly communicative. He responds fast with well thought out answers making the process of getting insurance for my home and car super simple.
Andrew U., Dover, NH
More than one carrier, compared side by side
As an independent agency, we compare coverage from 40+ carriers instead of one company’s menu. Clients notice when someone does the shopping for them, especially when they’re moving several policies at once. It matters again at renewal: if a carrier changes what it wants to write or your premium jumps, we can look at other options instead of telling you there’s nothing to be done.
We weren’t the easiest client, since we had multiple policies to transfer from our previous carrier. Jon took the time to understand our needs, find the best options, and make the entire process smooth and straightforward.
Cindy P., Hudson, NH
Help with a new home on a deadline
Buying a house compresses everything. The lender wants proof of insurance, the closing date doesn’t move, and older or unusual homes can take more work to place. Many of our most detailed reviews come from that week before closing. If you’re in that spot now, our guide to proof of homeowners insurance for a New Hampshire closing explains what lenders usually ask for.
Exceptional service! I requested online quotes for homeowners’ insurance with six insurance agencies and not one response. Our closing date was approaching, so I tried again with Portsmouth Atlantic, and Brian contacted me within hours. He found us a robust package, more than I was expecting, given the unique aspects of the property. Within a day, we had coverage! Brian’s responsiveness and professionalism was outstanding; they are a family-owned business and are extremely knowledgeable. So glad to have found them!
Aaron D., Brookline, MA
Local advice for coastal and high-value homes
From Rye and New Castle to the Connecticut shoreline, coastal homes raise questions a generic quote won’t answer. How does a wind or hurricane deductible work? Do you need flood coverage? (Standard homeowners policies don’t include it.) Does your dwelling limit still match what it would cost to rebuild? Larger homes bring jewelry, art and umbrella coverage into it, which is where our high net worth insurance team spends its days. For the storm side, see which agencies understand coastal flood and wind risk in New England.
Portsmouth Atlantic gives me a high-end, one-stop shop for my insurance coverage across home, flood, liability and auto. The team is highly knowledgeable and very responsive, too. I’m a fan.
PAI client, Exeter, NH
A review every year, not just at the start
This one means the most to me. A good agency doesn’t disappear after the first policy is signed.
Portsmouth Atlantic does a remarkable job reviewing our coverage each year, including a changing cast of college-age drivers The insurance market is in considerable turmoil, and having your expertise in the negotiations is incredibly helpful and reassuring.
Charles F., Boston, MA
Call our team at (603) 431-4020, or request a quote below and we’ll compare options from our 40+ carriers.
A quick checklist for reading any agency’s reviews
Use this on any agency you’re considering, including us.
| What to check | A good sign | A reason to pause |
|---|---|---|
| Number of reviews | Hundreds, built up over years | A few reviews, or a burst all at once |
| Recency | Steady new reviews this year | Nothing recent |
| Detail | Real situations: closings, claims, renewals | Only one-line praise |
| People | Different staff named by different clients | No one is ever named |
| Replies | Calm, helpful responses to criticism | Defensive replies or silence |
| Choice | Clients mention comparing options | Reviews only mention one company’s price |
You can read every one of our reviews, good or bad, on Google. If something in one of them gives you pause, ask us about it. We’d rather talk it through.
Why is November a good time to do this?
There’s a practical reason to look now. Winter is when New England homes get tested: ice dams on Seacoast capes, a burst pipe in a summer house that’s been closed up, a limb through the roof in a nor’easter. Our guide to how insurance companies handle snow and ice damage in the Northeast covers what usually happens with those claims.
It’s also the end of the year, a natural time for a policy review. A few questions worth asking before the holidays:
- Does your dwelling limit still reflect what it would cost to rebuild today, especially after a renovation?
- Did anything change this year, like a new driver, a new roof, a second home or a valuable purchase?
- Do you know your wind or hurricane deductible, and whether you have flood coverage at all?
- Do your liability limits still fit what you own? An umbrella policy is worth a look if your assets have grown.
- Will a house sit empty this winter? Tell your agent, because vacancy can affect coverage.
If you’d like us to take a look, our policy review request takes a few minutes. We don’t charge additional fees for reviews, quotes or service.
Who’s behind the reviews?
I started Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance in 2005, and we’re still family-owned. Today our team of 15 works from our office in Portsmouth, NH and our office in Fairfield, CT. We’re licensed in 10 states and compare coverage from 40+ carriers. Each review is a client who took a minute to tell their neighbors how it went, and I’m proud of every one. For more, read why we’re New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google and how we work as an independent insurance agency in Portsmouth, NH.
What’s next in this series
Around the middle of each month, we’ll share one thing from client feedback: a review milestone, standout feedback from a town we serve, or a seasonal tip drawn from the questions clients ask us most. Have a question you’d like answered? Mention it on the form below.
Frequently asked questions
What makes an insurance agency top-rated?
A high average across a large number of reviews collected over years, with reviews that describe specific situations and keep praising the same things, such as responsiveness, clear explanations and a choice of carriers. What the reviews say matters more than the number of stars.
Are Google reviews a reliable way to choose an insurance agency?
They’re one of the better tools if you read them in bulk. Look at volume, recency, detail and how the agency responds to criticism, then talk with the agency yourself before you decide.
How many Google reviews does Portsmouth Atlantic have?
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.
What is the difference between an independent agency and a captive agent?
A captive agent represents one insurance company. An independent agency can compare policies from several companies. We compare coverage from 40+ carriers.
Does Portsmouth Atlantic charge fees for quotes or policy reviews?
No. We don’t charge additional fees.
When should I review my homeowners policy?
At least once a year, ideally a couple of months before renewal, and after any big change such as a renovation, a new driver or a new property. In New England, late fall works well because it comes before winter storm season.
Request a quote or a year-end review
Tell us a little about your home, car or other property and we’ll compare options from our 40+ carriers. Prefer to talk? Call (603) 431-4020.
Coverage depends on your policy, the carrier and its underwriting. Read your policy wording for the terms that apply to you. This article is general information.

