How Deductibles and Claims Affect Your Home Insurance (and What to Expect When You File)

Published on: November 5, 2026

By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Two choices shape your homeowners insurance more than most people realize: the deductible you pick and how you use your policy when something goes wrong. Here’s how both work, and what the claim process looks like from start to finish.

How your deductible affects your premium

Your deductible is the amount you pay toward a covered loss before the insurance pays the rest. In general, a higher deductible lowers your premium and a lower deductible raises it, because you’re taking on more or less of the small losses yourself.

When choosing, ask yourself what amount you could pay out of pocket tomorrow without strain. That’s a sensible ceiling.

Flat vs. percentage deductibles

Most policies have a flat all-perils deductible. Some, especially near the coast, also have a separate wind, hurricane or named-storm deductible figured as a percentage of your dwelling limit. Know which one applies to which loss. See hurricane deductibles in Connecticut.

How claims affect your premium

  • Claims history follows you. Carriers share claims data, and your history usually stays with you when you move or switch companies.
  • Frequency matters. Several small claims can count against you more than one larger claim.
  • Type matters. Water and liability claims are often viewed as more likely to repeat.
  • Some carriers offer no-claims credits that can be lost after a claim.

A claim can affect your renewal pricing or, in some cases, whether a carrier renews the policy. That’s not a reason to avoid a real claim. It’s what insurance is for. It’s a reason to think twice about very small ones. More on this in the pros and cons of filing a homeowners insurance claim.

Should you file? A quick gut check

  • Is the damage clearly more than your deductible?
  • Is it sudden and accidental, not wear and tear?
  • Is anyone hurt or is another person’s property involved? If so, report it.
  • Not sure? Call your agent first to talk it through.

The insurance claim process, step by step

  1. Stay safe and prevent more damage. Shut off water, tarp a roof, and keep receipts for emergency repairs.
  2. Document everything. Photos and video before cleanup, plus a list of damaged items.
  3. Report the claim. Call your carrier’s claim line or your agent as soon as you can.
  4. Meet the adjuster. They’ll inspect the damage and may ask for estimates or receipts.
  5. Review the estimate. Compare it with contractor estimates and ask questions if something is missing.
  6. Payment and repairs. Payments may come in stages, and your mortgage lender may be named on the check.
  7. Close out. If you have replacement cost coverage, you may receive held-back depreciation once repairs are done.

For typical timing, see how long a home insurance claim takes. For winter-specific claims, read our guide to homeowners insurance and ice storms.

Frequently asked questions

Does a higher deductible lower my home insurance premium?

Generally yes, because you take on more of each loss yourself. Pick a deductible you could comfortably pay.

Will one claim raise my homeowners insurance?

It can, depending on the carrier, the type of claim and your history. Some carriers also remove no-claims credits.

Should I file a claim for small damage?

If the damage is close to your deductible, it’s often worth talking to your agent first.

What is the first step in the insurance claim process?

Make sure everyone is safe, prevent further damage, document it with photos and report the claim promptly.

Do claims follow me if I switch carriers?

Yes. Claims history is shared among carriers and usually follows the person, not just the property.

Questions about your deductible?

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency, founded in 2005. We work with 40+ carriers, we have 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials, and we don’t charge any fees. We’ll help you compare deductible options across carriers.

Request a quote or call (603) 431-4020.

This article is general information, not a statement of coverage. Coverage varies by policy and carrier, and your policy documents control.

Call Email Claims Payments