Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency, founded in 2005 and licensed in Connecticut. From our office at 1885 Post Road in Fairfield, right next door to Trumbull, we help Trumbull homeowners compare homeowners insurance from carriers among the 40+ we work with. We don’t charge additional fees.

Trumbull is mostly a town of single-family homes: capes, colonials, raised ranches and split-levels on suburban lots across neighborhoods like Nichols, Long Hill, Daniels Farm and Tashua, with some newer, larger homes mixed in. It sits inland, so the questions carriers ask are different from a shoreline house in Fairfield or Milford. We work for you, not one insurance company, and we’ve earned 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.

What carriers look at on a Trumbull house

Age and updates

Much of Trumbull’s housing was built in the decades after World War II. Carriers want the roof age, the heating type, the electrical panel and the plumbing. Updates matter, so have the years handy. A newer roof or an upgraded panel can open up more carrier options.

Oil heat and tanks

Plenty of Trumbull homes still heat with oil. Carriers ask whether the tank is in the basement or buried, how old it is and whether an old tank was removed. Paperwork for a replacement or removal helps.

Finished basements and water

Finished lower levels are common in Trumbull’s raised ranches and split-levels. A sump pump failure or a drain backup in a heavy rain can ruin flooring, walls and everything stored down there, and a standard policy usually won’t pay for it unless you add water backup coverage.

Rivers, brooks and flood

Trumbull isn’t on the water, but the Pequonnock River and smaller brooks run through town, and low spots can take on water in a big storm. Flood from rising water is never covered by homeowners insurance. We check your address, and when it makes sense we quote a separate flood policy too.

Trees, wind and winter storms

Mature trees over older homes, nor’easters and ice storms cause roof and siding claims most winters. We review your wind deductible and whether your policy pays to remove a fallen tree. Our ice storm guide covers what’s typically covered.

Pools and liability

Backyard pools, trampolines and dogs all affect liability. If you have a pool or a teen driver in the house, it’s worth comparing higher liability limits and an umbrella policy.

Coverage we review with Trumbull homeowners

CoverageWhy it matters in Trumbull
Dwelling (rebuild cost)Rebuild cost, not market value, sets your limit, and older homes can cost more to rebuild with today’s codes
Ordinance or lawPays for required code upgrades during repairs on older homes
Water backupCovers sump pump and drain backups into finished basements, usually excluded unless added
Wind and hurricane deductibleConnecticut policies often carry a separate, higher deductible for named storms
Liability and umbrellaHigher limits for pools, dogs and teen drivers
Flood (separate policy)NFIP (new NFIP policies go through Selective) or private flood, depending on the house

Carriers we compare for Trumbull homes

For Connecticut homeowners, the carriers we compare include Vermont Mutual, Andover, Providence Mutual, Liberty Mutual, Foremost, Openly, Stillwater, Cincinnati, Chubb, National General and Hanover. Which ones fit depends on the house, its age and location, and each carrier’s underwriting, and we’ll tell you which options are realistic. Larger homes may also fit our Fairfield County high-value home options or our Trumbull high-value home insurance page.

Disclosure: Coverage, eligibility and price depend on each carrier’s underwriting and your details. Nothing on this page is a quote or a promise of coverage.

More for Trumbull and Fairfield County

See our Trumbull insurance agency page, Connecticut homeowners insurance, independent insurance agency in Fairfield County, Connecticut condo insurance, Connecticut landlord insurance and first-time home buyer insurance. Nearby: Fairfield homeowners insurance, Stratford homeowners insurance and Shelton car insurance.

Frequently asked questions

Do you have an office near Trumbull?

Yes. Our Connecticut office is at 1885 Post Road, 2nd floor, in Fairfield, the town just south of Trumbull. Most Trumbull homeowners work with us by phone, email and online, and you can start your quote online any time.

Does homeowners insurance cover flooding from the Pequonnock River or a local brook?

No. Homeowners policies exclude flood from rising water, whether it comes from the Pequonnock River, a smaller brook or runoff after a heavy storm. Flood is a separate policy, and you can buy it even if your lender doesn’t require it. See Fairfield County flood insurance.

Is water backing up into my finished basement covered?

Not automatically. Water that backs up through a floor drain or overflows a sump pump is usually excluded unless you add water backup coverage. Many Trumbull homes have finished lower levels, so it’s one of the first add-ons we check.

My house has an oil tank. Will that limit my options?

It can. Carriers ask where the tank is (basement or buried), how old it is and whether it has been replaced or removed. A newer tank, or proof an old buried tank was removed, can open up more carriers. Have whatever paperwork you have ready.

I’m buying a house in Trumbull. When should I call you?

As soon as your offer is accepted. Your lender needs proof of homeowners insurance before closing, and the roof age, heating system, electrical panel and flood zone all affect which carriers will write the house. Send us the listing or the inspection report and we’ll start comparing options.

Can I bundle my Trumbull home and car insurance?

Yes. We compare single-carrier bundles and split options side by side, so you can see which actually works better for your household. See car insurance in Trumbull and our Connecticut home and auto bundle page.

Start your Trumbull homeowners quote

Have your current declarations page (or the listing if you’re buying), the year the roof was replaced and your heating type handy. We’ll compare options from multiple carriers and explain the differences in plain English. Start your quote online, call (203) 859-6858 or email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com.

Call Email Claims Payments