Insurance basics · Claims
By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Updated: November 4, 2026

Key takeaways
  • Make everyone safe, prevent further damage and report the claim promptly.
  • The carrier’s adjuster investigates and estimates. You document, and you can push back with your own estimates.
  • Home claims often pay in stages, and your mortgage company may be on the check.
  • Your deductible comes off the payment, not out of your pocket up front to the carrier.
  • If you disagree, you have options: reinspection, appraisal, a public adjuster or your state insurance department.

Most people only file a handful of claims in their lives, so it’s normal not to know how it works. A pipe bursts in January, someone backs into you at Market Basket, a tree comes down on the garage. Here’s the process from first call to final payment, with the terms you’ll hear along the way. It’s the same broad shape for home and auto, with a few differences we’ll point out.

Step 1: Safety and preventing more damage

People first. Call 911 if anyone is hurt or there’s fire, gas or a downed wire. Then do what’s reasonable to stop the damage from getting worse: shut off the water main, tarp a hole in the roof, move belongings out of the wet room, get the car off the road. Policies expect you to protect the property from further damage, and the reasonable cost of doing it is usually part of a covered claim. Keep the receipts.

Step 2: Document everything

  • Photos and video of the damage before anything is cleaned up or thrown away
  • For auto: the other driver’s name, insurance, plate and the police report number
  • A list of damaged belongings, with ages and receipts where you have them
  • Receipts for emergency repairs, hotels, meals and rentals
  • A simple log of every call: date, who you spoke with and what they said

Hold on to damaged items until the adjuster has seen them or tells you they can go, unless they’re a health hazard. Take photos either way.

Step 3: Report the claim

Report it promptly. You can call the carrier’s claims line or use its app at any hour, or call us during business hours and we’ll help. Our billing and claims page lists how to reach your carrier. You’ll get a claim number. Put it on everything.

Not sure whether a small loss is worth filing? Call us first. We’ll talk through the deductible and how a claim may affect your record. See the pros and cons of filing a homeowners claim.

Step 4: The adjuster

The carrier assigns an adjuster. On auto claims, that may mean photos through an app or a visit to an approved shop. On home claims, an adjuster (sometimes an independent adjuster the carrier hires after a big storm) inspects the damage, asks questions and reviews your policy. Be there for the inspection if you can, point out everything, and give them your contractor’s estimate if you have one.

The adjuster works for the insurance company. You can hire a licensed public adjuster to represent you instead, usually for a share of the settlement. The Massachusetts Division of Insurance has a good overview of public adjusters and what to ask before hiring one.

Step 5: The estimate and coverage decision

The adjuster writes an estimate and the carrier decides what the policy covers. A few terms you’ll see:

  • Deductible. The part of a covered loss you absorb. It’s subtracted from the payment.
  • Actual cash value (ACV). Replacement cost minus depreciation.
  • Replacement cost. What it costs to repair or replace with like kind and quality. Many home policies pay ACV first and release the rest, often called recoverable depreciation or holdback, after repairs are done.
  • Policy limits and sublimits. The most the policy pays, and smaller caps on items like jewelry, mold or trees.
  • Proof of loss. A sworn statement of what you’re claiming. Some carriers require it, with a deadline.
  • Reservation of rights. A letter saying the carrier is still investigating whether coverage applies. It isn’t a denial.

Step 6: Payment

Auto claims are often paid to the repair shop or to you and your lienholder. Home dwelling payments usually list your mortgage company too, and the lender may hold the funds and release them as work is done. Contents and loss of use are typically paid to you. Massachusetts consumers can read the Division of Insurance guide to obtaining payment for a home insurance claim, which also explains asking for an advance in an emergency.

“The smoothest claims have three things: a prompt report, good photos, and a written list of what was damaged. If something doesn’t look right, call us, because helping you through a claim is part of what we do.”

— Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance

Step 7: If you disagree

Your options if the claim doesn’t look right
  1. Ask for the reason in writing, including the policy language the carrier is relying on.
  2. Send more information: your contractor’s estimate, photos and receipts.
  3. Request a reinspection or a different adjuster.
  4. Use the appraisal clause, if your property policy has one, for disputes about the amount owed.
  5. Consider a public adjuster or an attorney on large or complicated claims.
  6. Contact your state insurance department. New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Connecticut and the other states we serve all take consumer complaints.

For timing, see how long a home insurance claim takes. For the record a claim leaves, see how long claims stay on your record. After a crash, our New Hampshire auto accident guide has a checklist.

Have a claim or a question about one?
Call (603) 431-4020 in Portsmouth or (203) 859-6858 in Fairfield (Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM, Friday 8 AM–4 PM ET) and we’ll help you report it and explain what comes next. After hours, call your carrier’s claims line. Find it on our billing and claims page.

Frequently asked questions

Who do I call first, my agent or the insurance company?

Either works. Carriers take claims around the clock by phone or app, which is fastest after hours. You can also call us during business hours and we’ll help you report it and explain what to expect. Most important is reporting promptly.

What does an insurance adjuster do?

The adjuster works for the insurance company to investigate the loss, inspect the damage, review the policy and estimate what the carrier owes. On larger property claims, you may also see an independent adjuster the carrier hires. You can hire a licensed public adjuster to represent you, for a fee.

Why did I get two checks, or a check with my mortgage company on it?

On home claims, carriers often pay the actual cash value first and the rest once repairs are done, when your policy has replacement cost coverage. If you have a mortgage, the lender is usually named on dwelling payments so they can make sure the home is repaired.

What if I disagree with the adjuster’s estimate?

Ask for the estimate in writing, get your own contractor’s estimate, and send it with photos and an explanation. You can ask for a reinspection. Many property policies include an appraisal clause for disputes over the amount, and every state insurance department takes consumer complaints.

Will filing a claim raise my premium?

It can, depending on the type of claim, who was at fault, your claims history and the carrier. That’s why it helps to talk through smaller losses with your agent first. Never hold back a claim for a serious loss over premium worries.

How long does a claim take?

Simple auto glass or small property claims can wrap up quickly. Larger home claims with contractors, contents and loss of use can take months. Our guide to how long a home insurance claim takes goes into the timeline.

Sources

This article is general information, not an offer of coverage or a promise that any loss is covered. Your policy wording and each carrier’s underwriting decide coverage.

Jon Merwin
Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
Jon founded Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, a family-owned independent agency based in Portsmouth, NH, with a second office in Fairfield, CT, and licensed in 10 states. The agency is New Hampshire’s highest-rated agency on Google, with 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.

Related guides: How long a home insurance claim takes · Water damage from rain · Does insurance go up after a claim? · Billing and claims · Water damage insurance claims

Next step: Find your carrier’s claims contact or call (603) 431-4020.

Call Email Claims Payments