By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Fairfield is mostly a town of single-family homes, but its rental buildings have their own character. There are two- and three-families on the streets around Route 1 and Black Rock Turnpike, small apartment buildings near the Fairfield Center and Southport train stations, beach cottages that have been converted into year-round rentals, and houses near Fairfield University and Sacred Heart University rented to students. Most owners here have one to four units. A smaller group owns five-plus buildings that need commercial habitational coverage.

This page is for owners of Fairfield apartment buildings, two- to four-families and five-plus buildings. If you own a single rental house or condo, our Fairfield landlord insurance page is the better fit.

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance is a family-owned independent agency founded in 2005. We’re licensed in 10 states, we compare 40+ carriers and our team has 200+ years of combined experience. We serve Fairfield owners from our office at 1885 Post Road in Fairfield and by phone at (203) 859-6858, email and online. We have 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials and an A+ BBB rating. On the business side we write habitational policies only, meaning apartment buildings and condo associations. We don’t charge additional fees.

Key facts for Fairfield apartment buildings

  • About 3,600 of Fairfield’s roughly 21,600 occupied homes are rented, about 17% (ACS 2020-2024, B25003).
  • About 2,050 units are in two- to four-unit buildings and about 1,430 in buildings of five or more (B25024).
  • The 1950s were the town’s biggest building decade, about 4,800 units, and about 4,300 units predate 1940 (B25034).
  • Storm surge through Ash Creek and Pine Creek and overtopping of the barrier beach cause street flooding and sewer backups in the beach area.
  • One to four units usually go on personal dwelling forms. Five or more units are commercial habitational, often on a habitational BOP.

Fairfield’s rental stock, by building size

The 2020-2024 American Community Survey counts about 22,500 housing units in Fairfield, and about 18,800 are detached single-family homes. About 1,200 units are in two-unit buildings and about 860 in three- and four-unit buildings. About 1,430 are in buildings of five or more units (B25024). The median owner-occupied home is worth about $780,000.

Much of the town was built in the postwar boom. The 1950s alone account for about 4,800 units, more than any other decade, and about 4,300 units were built in 1939 or earlier, mostly in Southport, Fairfield Center, Stratfield and the older beach neighborhoods (B25034). A 1920s two-family in Stratfield, a 1955 Cape split into two units and a converted beach cottage on a slab each raise different questions about wiring, heating, roofs and flood exposure.

Two- to four-family

Dwelling (DP-3) or owner-occupied homeowners form. Lost rent, liability and an umbrella.

Five units and up

Commercial habitational package or BOP: building, loss of rents and liability together.

Student rentals

Houses and units near Fairfield University and Sacred Heart.

Flood and backup

Beach-area surge, Ash Creek, Pine Creek and sewer backups.

Two- to four-family buildings in Fairfield

If you live in one of the units

An owner who lives in a Fairfield two-family can often insure the whole building on a homeowners form, covering the structure, belongings and liability, plus loss of rents on the rented unit. That’s common in Fairfield, where many two-families are owner-occupied.

If you don’t live there

A non-owner-occupied two- to four-family goes on a dwelling fire policy. We usually suggest the open-perils DP-3 form with replacement cost on the building, fair rental value for every unit and premises liability. For one- to four-unit Fairfield buildings we compare Vermont Mutual, Andover, Liberty Mutual, Hanover, Providence Mutual and Foremost. Vermont Mutual can also write multi-family rentals of one to four units on a BOP.

Student rentals near the universities

Fairfield University and Sacred Heart University both draw students into off-campus rentals, especially in the beach area and the neighborhoods near Fairfield Center and Jefferson Street. Off-campus student housing in the beach neighborhoods has been a long-running local issue, so check the town’s zoning and occupancy rules before you lease to a group.

Carriers handle student rentals differently. Some decline them on certain forms, and others accept them with questions about the number of tenants, lease terms and who signs the lease. What matters most:

  • Disclose it. Tell the carrier the building is rented to students. Finding out at claim time is the worst outcome.
  • Liability limits and an umbrella. Parties, decks and stairs raise liability exposure. We usually suggest higher liability limits and a landlord umbrella.
  • Renters insurance in the lease. Your policy doesn’t cover students’ belongings or their own liability. Require renters insurance and keep proof on file.
  • Summer vacancy. If units sit empty between May and August, check your policy’s vacancy terms.

Five or more units: commercial habitational coverage

Once a building reaches five units, most carriers treat it as a commercial habitational risk. For Connecticut apartment buildings of five or more units, we place coverage with Vermont Mutual, Andover and Providence Mutual. Our Connecticut apartment building insurance guide covers what those carriers look for.

A habitational package or BOP usually brings together:

  • Building coverage at replacement cost, with the limit set to the real rebuild cost, not the purchase price or the assessment.
  • Business income / loss of rents, sized to the full rent roll and a realistic rebuild and re-occupancy period.
  • General liability for common halls, stairs, lots, walks and any amenity space.
  • Equipment breakdown for boilers, elevators and electrical gear, where offered.
  • Building ordinance or law coverage for code upgrades after a loss.
  • Common-area contents such as laundry and maintenance equipment.

Underwriters ask about construction type, sprinklers and alarms, roof and boiler age, electrical and plumbing updates, ground-floor commercial space, garden-level units, flood zone, student occupancy and five years of losses.

In Fairfield, the water that does the most damage often comes up through the floor drain, not over the sea wall.

Flood and sewer backup in the beach area

Fairfield’s coastline runs from Southport Harbor past Sasco Beach, Penfield Beach and Jennings Beach to Ash Creek at the town’s eastern edge. Behind the barrier beach, the low-lying neighborhoods along Fairfield Beach Road, Old Dam Road and the Pine Creek marsh flood from storm surge that pushes up through Ash Creek and Pine Creek and from waves overtopping the beach. That same water floods streets and overwhelms the sanitary sewer system, so sewage can back up into basements and first floors.

The town has been working on it. Town flood and resilience projects include upgrading the Fairfield Beach, Center Street and Pine Creek pump stations, detention work on the Rooster River and East Trunk Line sewer improvements (Town of Fairfield). These help, but they don’t remove the risk for an individual building.

For apartment owners, that means:

  • Flood insurance. Landlord and apartment policies exclude flood. In mapped high-risk zones near the beach and creeks, a lender will usually require it. Outside them, it’s still worth a look.
  • Water and sewer backup coverage. Backup through drains is excluded unless you add it by endorsement, and a flood policy may not cover backup that isn’t caused by a flood. Ask about both.
  • Backflow valves and sump pumps. A backflow preventer on the sewer line and a working sump pump with a battery backup help prevent the loss and can help with underwriting.
  • Rooster River and inland flooding. Buildings near the Rooster River on the town’s east side and along the Mill River can flood in heavy rain, far from the beach.

NFIP and private flood for Fairfield buildings

Landlord, homeowners and habitational policies exclude flood. New NFIP policies go through Selective, and a new NFIP policy usually takes effect after a 30-day waiting period, with some exceptions such as coverage a lender requires at closing. NFIP building limits are capped at $250,000 for a one- to four-family residential building and $500,000 for a residential building of five or more units, and the NFIP doesn’t pay loss of rents (FloodSmart).

Private flood can fill some of those gaps. We compare private flood carriers including Flow Flood, Neptune Flood, Beyond Floods, The Flood Insurance Agency, CatCoverage and Aon Edge. Some offer higher building limits, shorter waiting periods or loss of rents as an option. Look up the address on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center or our flood zone check, and see Fairfield flood insurance and Fairfield County flood insurance.

Building ordinance or law in Fairfield

When an older building is badly damaged, the rebuild has to meet today’s building, fire and electrical codes. A standard policy pays to repair what was there and may not pay for the upgrades. Ordinance or law coverage usually has three parts: the value of an undamaged portion that has to be torn down, the cost of demolishing it and the extra cost to build to current code.

It matters in Fairfield because many beach-area buildings, if substantially damaged, have to be elevated to meet floodplain rules, and because most of the town’s housing predates modern codes. NFIP flood policies include Increased Cost of Compliance coverage of up to $30,000 for some floodplain compliance work after a flood (FEMA). On a multi-unit building, that rarely covers the whole cost.

Liability, umbrella and tenants

Apartment buildings carry more liability exposure than houses: shared stairs, laundry rooms, parking, snow and ice on walks and more people coming and going. On a one- to four-family owned personally, a personal umbrella is the usual way to raise limits. On a commercial package, we’ll review the package’s liability limit and how an umbrella or excess policy would sit above it. If the building is in an LLC, the LLC should be the named insured on every policy.

Your policy doesn’t cover tenants’ belongings. Requiring renters insurance in the lease protects them, and their liability coverage can respond when a tenant causes a fire or leak.

More pages for Fairfield owners

For a single rental, see Fairfield landlord insurance. For condo associations and unit owners, see Connecticut condo association insurance and Fairfield condo insurance. For your tenants, see Fairfield renters insurance. For flood across the county, see Fairfield County flood insurance. Statewide, see Connecticut apartment building insurance.

Get a quote for your Fairfield building

Tell us about the building, the units and the tenants, and we’ll compare carriers for the right fit. Call (203) 859-6858, email insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com or use the form below. There’s no obligation to buy, and we don’t charge additional fees. About 90% of our quotes go out within 24 hours.

Start Your Quote

Fairfield apartment building insurance FAQs

When does a Fairfield apartment building need a commercial policy?

Usually at five units. Two- to four-families generally go on personal dwelling or homeowners forms; five or more units is a commercial habitational risk, often on a habitational BOP. In Connecticut we place five-plus-unit buildings with Vermont Mutual, Andover and Providence Mutual.

Does my landlord policy cover sewer backup?

Not unless you add it. Water and sewer backup is excluded on most landlord and apartment policies and is added by endorsement. In Fairfield’s beach area, where storm surge can overwhelm the sewer system, it’s worth having.

Can I insure a building rented to college students?

Usually, yes, if you disclose it. Some carriers decline student rentals on certain forms, and others accept them. Higher liability limits, an umbrella and required renters insurance are smart additions.

Do I need flood insurance in Fairfield?

If your building is near the beach, Ash Creek, Pine Creek or the Rooster River, take a close look. Landlord and apartment policies exclude flood. Compare NFIP and private flood.

Will an NFIP flood policy pay my lost rent?

No. NFIP policies don’t pay loss of rents. Some private flood policies offer it as an option.

How do I start a quote for a Fairfield building?

Call (203) 859-6858 or use the form on this page. Have the address, unit count, year built, update years, rent roll, current declarations pages and five years of losses ready. We don’t charge additional fees.

Sources

General information for owners of apartment buildings in Fairfield. It is not a quote or legal advice. What a policy covers depends on its own wording and endorsements and on each carrier’s underwriting, and the public figures cited here may be revised.

Call Email Claims Payments