Agencies · Reviews · Fairfield, Connecticut

By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor

Published November 2026 · Google data checked November 13, 2026

Which insurance agencies in Fairfield, CT have the most Google reviews? We checked every agency office in the town, independent and captive alike, and ranked the five listings with the most reviews. We’re Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, and our Fairfield office is at 1885 Post Road, so our listing is on this list. Here’s exactly how we counted.

Top 5 at a glance

RankAgency office (Google listing)TypeGoogle reviewsGoogle rating
1Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, 1885 Post Rd, Fl 2, FairfieldIndependent5194.9
2Farmers Insurance – Oluwatoyin Ogunbiyi, Linwood Ave, FairfieldCaptive (Farmers)1825.0
3Mark Otterson – State Farm Insurance Agent, Black Rock Tpke, FairfieldCaptive (State Farm)1665.0
4Colleen Tighe – State Farm Insurance Agent, Kings Hwy E, FairfieldCaptive (State Farm)1384.9
5Macman Insurance Associates, Villa Ave, FairfieldIndependent484.8

Google Maps review counts and ratings read November 13, 2026. Ranked by review count; a tie goes to the higher rating.

How we ranked them

Same-day counts. We read every review count and rating from each office’s public Google Maps listing on November 13, 2026, about 5:40 to 5:45 AM Eastern.

Every agency office in Fairfield (including Southport). We included both independent agencies, which represent several insurance companies, and captive agencies, which represent one company (such as State Farm, Allstate or Farmers agents). Each row is labeled. The listing’s street address had to be in Fairfield (including Southport); nearby offices in other towns were left out.

What we left out. Insurance company service centers, AAA offices, online-only agencies, and agencies that sell only health, Medicare or life insurance, the same rules we use in our New Hampshire and Connecticut top 10.

Sorted by review count. Ratings are shown for reference. A tie in review count goes to the higher rating. Each Google listing is ranked on its own.

Disclosure. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote this page and our own listing is on it. We did not contact or receive anything from the other agencies. Counts change daily, so the live Google listing is always the most current number. We plan to recheck every quarter.

Independent or captive: what the label means

An independent agency can quote policies from several insurance companies. A captive agency represents one company and offers that company’s policies. Both can serve clients well; the label simply tells you how many companies an agent can quote.

The top 5, in order

1. Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, 1885 Post Rd, Fl 2, Fairfield

Google reviews: 519 · Rating: 4.9 · Independent

This is our agency. Our Fairfield office is part of Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, a family-owned independent agency that compares 40+ carriers and is licensed in 10 states, including Connecticut. We write home, auto, umbrella and business insurance. Reach the Fairfield office at (203) 859-6858.

2. Farmers Insurance – Oluwatoyin Ogunbiyi, Linwood Ave, Fairfield

Google reviews: 182 · Rating: 5.0 · Captive (Farmers)

A Farmers Insurance agency on Linwood Avenue. As a captive agency, it offers Farmers policies.

3. Mark Otterson – State Farm Insurance Agent, Black Rock Tpke, Fairfield

Google reviews: 166 · Rating: 5.0 · Captive (State Farm)

A State Farm agency on Black Rock Turnpike. As a captive agency, it offers State Farm policies.

4. Colleen Tighe – State Farm Insurance Agent, Kings Hwy E, Fairfield

Google reviews: 138 · Rating: 4.9 · Captive (State Farm)

A State Farm agency on Kings Highway East. As a captive agency, it offers State Farm policies.

5. Macman Insurance Associates, Villa Ave, Fairfield

Google reviews: 48 · Rating: 4.8 · Independent

An independent agency on Villa Avenue. It ranks just ahead of the State Farm office at 765 Post Rd, which showed 47 reviews and a 4.7 rating on the same day.

For statewide rankings, see the Connecticut list in our top 10 insurance agencies in New Hampshire and Connecticut.

Call our Fairfield office at (203) 859-6858 or insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com. Office hours are Monday through Thursday, 9 AM to 5 PM, and Friday, 8 AM to 4 PM Eastern.

Frequently asked questions

Which insurance agency in Fairfield, CT has the most Google reviews?

As of November 13, 2026, Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance had the most Google reviews of the agency offices we counted in Fairfield, at 519 with a 4.9 rating. Counts change daily.

How was this list ranked?

By Google review count on each office’s public Google Maps listing, read on November 13, 2026. Ratings are shown for reference, and a tie goes to the higher rating.

Does the list include captive agents like State Farm and Farmers?

Yes. Every insurance agency office in Fairfield was considered, independent and captive. Each one is labeled.

What is the difference between an independent and a captive agency?

An independent agency can quote policies from several insurance companies. A captive agency represents one company and offers that company’s policies.

Who wrote this list?

Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance wrote it, and our own listing is included. We did not contact or receive anything from the other agencies.

Call Email Claims Payments