By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO

Stratford is mostly a town of homeowners. The Census Bureau estimates that fewer than one occupied home in five here is rented, against about one in three across Connecticut (B25003). That makes renting in Stratford a little different from renting in a city. A typical rental is a floor of a two-family house on a side street, a whole house, or a unit in one of the newer buildings near the Stratford Center train station, and the person renting it is about twice as likely to be 65 or older as under 35. The renters policy that fits depends on which of those describes your place, and on where in town it sits, because the South End and Lordship face flood risks that the rest of town mostly does not.

Our home base is Portsmouth, NH, where the agency started in 2005; it is still independent and family-owned. Stratford clients work with us through our nearby Fairfield office at 1885 Post Road, and by phone, email and online. Tenants in Stratford deal with us over the phone and by email for quotes, changes and claims alike. Because we can shop 40+ carriers, a top-floor apartment off Main Street and a rented cape near the beach can each get a policy built for it. Reach us at (203) 859-6858 or insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com.

Key takeaways

  • Two- to four-family houses hold about four in ten Stratford rentals. Shared basements, shared stairs and water moving between floors are the everyday insurance issues.
  • About a quarter of rented homes in Stratford are headed by someone 65 or older, a larger share than statewide.
  • Nearly half of Stratford’s rented homes were built before 1960, so older wiring, heating and plumbing come with the territory.
  • The South End is the town’s most flood-exposed area. Flood is never part of a renters policy; protecting belongings against it takes a separate flood policy.
  • Storm drain backups and flooded railroad underpasses are recurring problems; backup coverage and your auto policy are where those claims land.

Before you call, you can see what clients say about us: 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.

Who rents in Stratford, and where

The Census Bureau’s five-year survey covering 2020 through 2024 sketches the local rental market:

  • About 3,800 of 20,600 occupied homes are rented. Statewide the share is close to twice as high (B25003).
  • About 1,000 rentals are in two-family houses, the single largest group, and about 590 more are in three- and four-family buildings. About 720 are detached single-family houses, and about 770 are in buildings with 20 or more units (B25032).
  • About 1,770 rented homes were built before 1960, including about 870 from before 1940 (B25036).
  • About one renter in three moved in during 2020 or later, a little less turnover than the state as a whole (B25038).
  • About a quarter of rented homes are headed by someone 65 or older, while only about one in eight is headed by someone under 35 (B25007). Rented homes hold an average of about two people (B25010).
  • The median gross rent is about $1,710 a month (rent plus estimated utilities), above the Connecticut median of roughly $1,490 (B25064; state figure).

Census figures for a town this size carry wide margins of error, so treat them as proportions, not precise counts.

Five common Stratford rentals and what each needs

1. A floor of a two-family house

This is the classic Stratford rental, often with the owner living upstairs or downstairs. Your renters policy should carry replacement cost on your belongings, so a claim pays what it costs to buy new rather than what your used furniture would sell for. Liability matters more than people expect in a shared house: a bathtub that overflows into the unit below or a space heater that scorches the shared hallway is a claim against you. Ask the owner where tenants may store things and whether the basement has ever taken on water.

2. A whole house you rent

About one Stratford rental in five is a detached single-family house. Renting a house usually means more of the chores fall to you, such as shoveling, mowing and keeping the walk clear, so read the lease carefully: if you are responsible for the walk and someone slips on ice, your liability coverage is what responds. A house also tends to mean more belongings in the garage and basement, so set the personal property limit with those in mind. If you have a dog, tell us; carriers ask, as our dog breed guide explains.

3. An apartment near the train in Stratford Center

The regional hazard plan reports that 754 housing units were built in Stratford’s transit-oriented development zone around the train station over the past decade, with nearly 500 more within a quarter mile of the zone, and that the town expects the trend to continue (MetroCOG Natural Hazard Mitigation Plan, 2024 Update). Managed buildings like these commonly require renters insurance, set a liability minimum and ask to be listed as an interested party. Newer construction helps with fire safety, but a kitchen fire or an overflowing washer on an upper floor can still affect several units, and your liability coverage is what protects you if the damage is traced to your apartment.

4. A rental in the South End or Lordship

These neighborhoods are where flood planning in Stratford is concentrated, and the next section explains why. Renters here should decide on flood coverage before hurricane season rather than after a storm is named, keep valuables off basement floors and check that their loss of use coverage would carry them through a long repair if the building were damaged.

5. Renting later in life

With a quarter of Stratford’s rented homes headed by someone 65 or older, many tenants are downsizing from a house they owned. Two points come up often: furniture, art and heirlooms brought from a larger home can add up to more than people expect, so take a fresh inventory before choosing a limit; and jewelry, silver and collections usually have low limits for theft unless they are scheduled separately. The hazard plan also lists emergency preparedness outreach for the Oronoque Village community and backup power for Stratford Housing Authority units among the town’s actions (MetroCOG NHMP 2024). Loss of use coverage, which covers the added cost of a hotel or temporary apartment while a damaged home is repaired, is worth checking for anyone who could not easily stay with family.

Flood: the South End, Lordship and the Housatonic

The 2024 regional plan says that a Category 1 hurricane would flood most of Stratford’s South End, including the residential neighborhoods bounded by Interstate 95, Lordship Boulevard, Access Road, Main Street and South Avenue, while Lordship itself sits higher and would largely be spared by a storm of that size. A Category 3 or 4 storm would push water north of I-95 and into Stratford Center. The plan also notes that a coastal storm in the fall of 2018 brought flooding in Stratford close to the limits reached during Tropical Storm Irene, and that cottages on the Long Beach barrier were removed in 2010 and the land made permanent open space (MetroCOG NHMP 2024).

Stratford has taken part in the NFIP since 1978, and its current flood maps took effect on July 8, 2013. The plan counts 1,148 flood policies in force in town and 74 repetitive loss properties as of 2024, 63 of them residential. After Irene, Sandy and Ida, FEMA approved about $50,000 in Individual Assistance for Stratford renters, a reminder that disaster aid is limited and is not a substitute for insurance (MetroCOG NHMP 2024).

  • Your renters policy will not pay for flood. That includes surge, tidal flooding and rainwater that comes in at ground level.
  • Contents flood coverage is available to tenants through the NFIP and private flood carriers. Expect a waiting period of about a month before NFIP coverage begins (FloodSmart). Selective is the company we use for new NFIP policies.
  • Check the map for your address on the FEMA flood map portal, and see our Stratford flood insurance page for how zones and options work in town.

The Connecticut Insurance Department publishes guidance on storm water versus flood claims, which is worth reading before a storm.

Backed-up drains and flooded underpasses

Not all of Stratford’s water problems come from the Sound. The regional plan describes inland flooding in town as occurring with moderate to frequent regularity, listing Main Street at Stratford Center, Broadbridge Avenue, Terrill Road, Hamilton Avenue, Reed Street, Bunnell Avenue and Parkwood Road among the spots most often reported, and storm drain backups on Albert and Albright avenues. In August 2008, water on parts of Terrill Road was close to two feet deep, and in July 2018 a vehicle was trapped in floodwater under the railroad overpass on West Broad Street (MetroCOG NHMP 2024).

  • Sewer and drain backup is excluded from most renters policies unless you add it. If your unit or storage space is below grade, it is one of the most useful add-ons available. Our guide to sewer backup coverage explains it.
  • Your car is covered for flood damage only under the comprehensive part of your auto policy. Never drive into water under an underpass.
  • Alerts help. The town runs a Citizens Electronic Notification System for emergency messages, and the hazard plan encourages residents to sign up.

Wind and falling trees

The plan’s storm history includes a June 2010 thunderstorm that took down hundreds of trees in Stratford, with Lordship and Paradise Green hit hardest; falling trees damaged homes and cars and injured a driver. It also records trees and wires down on Barnum Avenue in 2016 and 2018. The building code treats parts of town south of I-95 as a wind-borne debris region (MetroCOG NHMP 2024). For a renter:

  • A tree through the roof is the landlord’s building claim. Your policy covers your damaged belongings, minus your deductible.
  • If the apartment is unlivable while repairs are made, loss of use coverage pays the extra cost of living elsewhere, within the policy limit.
  • Power outages on their own seldom trigger much coverage. Spoiled food coverage, where offered, is usually modest.

A move-in checklist for Stratford renters

  • Read the lease’s insurance clause: required liability amount, interested party wording and any deadline for proof.
  • Photograph each room, closets and storage areas on move-in day, and keep receipts for larger purchases in a cloud folder.
  • Ask whether the building is in a mapped flood zone and whether the basement or ground floor has flooded before.
  • Find out who clears snow and ice from the walks, steps and driveway, and who handles leaves and gutters.
  • Test smoke and carbon monoxide detectors and learn where the water shutoff and electrical panel are.
  • Sign up for town emergency alerts and keep your landlord’s after-hours contact.

More for Stratford renters

Every line we offer locally is on our Fairfield, CT office page, and the renters insurance overview walks through each part of a renters policy. To see where a landlord’s policy stops and yours starts, read our homeowners versus renters explainer. If you own a condo you rent out or are thinking of buying, see condo insurance in Stratford and landlord insurance in Stratford. Drivers can read about car insurance in Stratford and our auto and renters bundling guide. Renters just across the river can see renters insurance in Milford, and for other towns, start at our Connecticut hub page.

Get a Stratford renters insurance quote

Send the address, the kind of building and the insurance section of your lease. For Stratford tenants we shop 40+ carriers; we don’t charge additional fees for it, and we lay out the differences between policies plainly. After a loss, we help file the claim and stay with it until the carrier settles it. Request a quote. There’s no obligation to buy. Start with the form below, visit our quotes page or phone (203) 859-6858. Office hours: Monday–Thursday 9 AM–5 PM and Friday 8 AM–4 PM, Eastern time; closed Saturday and Sunday. Comments from 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials are collected on our client feedback page.

Frequently asked questions

Is renters insurance required in Stratford, CT?

Connecticut law does not require tenants to carry it, but many leases do, especially in managed apartment buildings. Even where it is optional, it is the only policy that pays to replace your own belongings after a fire or burst pipe, covers your liability if a guest is hurt or you damage the building, and pays for somewhere to stay while the unit is repaired. The landlord’s insurance covers the building and the landlord, not you.

I rent the first floor of a two-family house. Whose policy covers what?

The owner’s policy covers the house itself: roof, walls, wiring, heating system and anything the owner supplies. Your renters policy covers your furniture, clothes and electronics, including what you keep in a shared basement or garage, plus your personal liability. If water from your unit damages the floor below or the apartment upstairs leaks into yours, the carriers sort out who pays for the building; your policy replaces your own things, minus your deductible.

Does renters insurance cover flooding in the South End or Lordship?

No. Renters policies exclude flood, including storm surge from Long Island Sound and the Housatonic and rainwater that rises from the street. Tenants can buy contents-only flood coverage through the National Flood Insurance Program, which normally takes effect 30 days after purchase (FloodSmart), or through a private flood carrier. When we place a new NFIP policy, it is written through Selective. Belongings kept in a basement get only limited flood coverage either way.

Water came up through the floor drain during a rainstorm. Is that covered?

Only if your policy includes sewer and drain backup coverage, which is usually an add-on rather than part of the standard renters form. Stratford’s hazard plan describes neighborhoods where storm drains back up during heavy rain, so if you live on a lower floor or keep belongings in a basement, ask for the endorsement when you buy the policy. Water that flows in from outside at ground level is generally treated as flood instead.

My landlord wants to be listed on my policy. What does that mean?

Most leases ask you to list the landlord or management company as an interested party, sometimes called an additional interest. The carrier then notifies the landlord if the policy is cancelled or lapses. It does not give the landlord coverage under your policy. Some leases also set a minimum amount of personal liability, and we match it and send the landlord proof once the policy is issued.

Does my renters policy cover my car if a tree falls on it?

No. Damage to your car, including a falling tree or a flooded underpass, is handled by the comprehensive coverage on your auto policy. Your renters policy can cover personal items stolen from the car, subject to your deductible. Carrying both policies with one carrier can make a storm that damages both simpler to claim.

What do you need to quote renters insurance in Stratford?

The street address and unit, the type of building (a floor of a two- or three-family, a house, a condo you rent or an apartment complex), your move-in date, any insurance requirements in the lease, a rough total for what it would cost to replace your belongings and a list of higher-value items such as jewelry, instruments or bikes. Request a quote. There’s no obligation to buy. You can also start by calling (203) 859-6858; the quote form sits just above these questions.

Sources

This page offers general information for Stratford tenants and is not a quote, legal advice or a coverage commitment. Your policy wording, its endorsements and the insurer’s underwriting decide every claim, and the census and planning figures above will shift as new data come out. Questions about your own lease? Call (203) 859-6858.

Call Email Claims Payments