Natalie Carbonaro
Favorite Quote: “Your outlook is your outcome” AND/OR “your outcome is your outlook” tricky, tricky. It can be said both ways and still hold the same meaning
Favorite Book: The House in the Cerulean Sea (TJ Klune) & The Lost Bookshop (Evie Woods)
Favorite Movie: Wonder, Pay it Forward, Patch Adams
Favorite Pet: No such thing as a favorite, I am a huge animal lover! I currently have 2 senior cats (Alana and Sasha) and a senior dog (Saydii-Linda)
Contact Information:
603-431-4020
natalie@portsmouthatlanticins.com
Beginning her insurance career in early 2022, Natalie quickly developed a strong appreciation for the industry’s unique balance of analytical problem-solving and meaningful personal connection. As an Insurance Consultant at PAI, she brings an advisor-first approach to every client interaction, prioritizing education, transparency, and long-term relationship building.
Natalie is dedicated to serving as a trusted consultant and advocate, believing clients deserve more than just a policy—they deserve a professional who is truly on their team. Each coverage recommendation is approached with the same care and attention as if insuring her own assets and risks, ensuring thoughtful, customized protection tailored to individual needs.
She resides in Southern Vermont with her husband, Kyle, their two cats, Alana and Sasha, and their dog, Saydii-Linda. On most workdays, Alana can be found sitting on her desk, keeping her company while she works. Saydii-Linda would also enjoy being able to sit on the desk as well, if only she didn’t weigh 95 lbs.
Outside of the office, Natalie enjoys reading, hiking with Saydii-Linda, caring for and propagating houseplants during the winter months. In the warmer seasons, she spends time tending to her flower and vegetable gardens, enjoying time at the lake, riding motorcycles, and four-wheeling. She also has a passion for automotive culture and frequently attends car shows, drift events, and races of all kinds. Traveling the world with her husband is another favorite pastime, with fourteen trips (and counting!) to Mexico, as well as visits to the Dominican Republic, Canada, and Bahamas.
What clients say about Natalie
Google reviews that mention Natalie by name, shown exactly as the client wrote them. Across the agency, clients have shared 1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials.
Natalie was great super helpful and responded quickly to everything
PAI were great in helping me purchase home and auto insurance, working with Natalie Carbonaro was great!
Natalie was great to work with! Very responsive and put a lot of work into finding me the best policy to fit my needs. Would highly recommend!
Natalie at Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance was amazing to work with. She made the entire process of switching our home, condo, auto, umbrella, and flood policies seamless. She was responsive, knowledgeable, proactive, and always one step ahead. Excellent customer service from start to finish. Highly recommend!
I had an excellent experience working with Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, especially with Natalie. She helped me with my homeowners, motorcycle, and auto insurance, and the entire process was smooth from start to finish.
Natalie took the time to listen to my needs, understand what coverage I was looking for, and provided great advice and recommendations instead of just trying to sell a policy. She explained my options clearly and helped me find the right coverage that fit my situation.
She was professional, knowledgeable, patient, and truly great to work with. I highly recommend Natalie and the Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance team to anyone looking for honest guidance and excellent service!