By Jon Merwin, Founder and CEO, Licensed Insurance Advisor
About one occupied home in four in Milford is rented, roughly 5,460 in all, according to Census estimates for 2020–2024 (Census B25003). Those rentals range from detached houses and beach cottages to the two-, three- and four-family buildings that make up the city’s largest group of rented homes. The shoreline adds a twist: the city’s hazard plan says many homes in Milford’s coastal high hazard area are summer cottages that were converted to year-round dwellings (Milford hazard plan annex).
Portsmouth Atlantic Insurance, a family-owned independent agency since 2005, works with Milford landlords on dwelling, flood and umbrella coverage. We serve Milford and the rest of Connecticut from our nearby Fairfield office at 1885 Post Road, and by phone, email and online. We shop 40+ carriers for each rental. Reach us at (203) 859-6858 or insure@portsmouthatlanticins.com.
Key takeaways
- A home you rent out needs a dwelling (landlord) policy unless you live in one of its units.
- Milford now requires a city permit for short-term rentals of 1 to 30 days. Your insurer needs to know about short-term use too.
- Many Milford shoreline rentals are converted summer cottages in high-hazard flood zones.
- An NFIP flood policy does not pay lost rent. Some private flood policies can.
- Liability is the biggest exposure for most landlords. Match the limit to what you own and consider an umbrella.
1,000+ Google reviews and over 2,000 testimonials, and an A+ from the Better Business Bureau, come from years of helping owners like you.
Milford’s rental mix
Census estimates of renter-occupied homes by building type, 2020–2024. Survey figures have margins of error.
| Building type | Rented homes in Milford (approx.) |
|---|---|
| Detached single-family house | about 1,220 |
| Attached single-family (townhouse) | about 410 |
| Two-unit building | about 630 |
| Three- or four-unit building | about 1,060 |
| Five units or more | about 2,130 |
About 460 Milford owners live in a two-, three- or four-unit building they own (Census B25032). Those owner-occupants are landlords too, and the right policy for them is often different from the one for an investor who lives elsewhere.
Picking the right landlord policy
DP-3 for most rentals
For a one- to four-unit rental you do not live in, we usually recommend a DP-3 dwelling policy. It covers the building against direct physical loss unless a cause is excluded, generally at replacement cost, and it can include loss of rent and premises liability. The more basic DP-1 covers fewer named causes of loss, often at actual cash value, and leaves bigger gaps on an older building. Carriers we compare for Milford rentals include Vermont Mutual, Andover, Liberty Mutual, Hanover, Providence Mutual and Foremost.
Living upstairs, renting downstairs
If you live in one unit, a homeowners policy written for an owner-occupied multi-family often fits, covering your belongings and both or all units of the building. Tell the carrier about every rented unit.
Condo units you rent out
A rented condo needs a unit-owner policy set up for a rented unit, coordinated with the association’s master policy. Our Connecticut condo insurance page covers the master policy side.
Five units and up
Larger buildings often need a habitational policy such as a BOP written for apartment buildings. See our Connecticut apartment building insurance page.
Converted cottages on the shoreline
Milford’s hazard plan lists more than a dozen beach areas subject to coastal flooding, from Cedar Beach and Laurel Beach near Milford Point to Gulf Beach, Bayview Beach, Morningside and Woodmont. It counts 533 repetitive loss properties with 1,511 flood losses, and it notes that more than 100 homes have been elevated since Irene and Sandy (Milford annex). The plan also points out that elevated houses leave the unelevated cottages behind them more exposed, and that wind, rain and high tides now push sand into the streets.
For a landlord, a converted cottage raises questions carriers will ask:
- Is it truly year-round? Heating, insulation and plumbing in a former summer cottage determine whether pipes are protected in January.
- Is it elevated? Elevation can change flood rating, and the space underneath has its own rules about what is covered.
- What is the rebuild cost? Set the dwelling limit to what it would cost to rebuild to current code, not to the rent or the sale value.
- Who lives there, and for how long? Year-round tenants, summer renters and short-term guests are three different risks.
Milford’s short-term rental ordinance
Milford’s Board of Aldermen approved a short-term rental ordinance on May 4, 2026. It defines a short-term rental as furnished living space rented for 1 to 30 consecutive days, and it requires the owner to get a permit before offering, listing or operating one (Chapter 11, Article V). Among its standards:
- Un-hosted owners must live within 30 miles of the property or name a local agent who does.
- Each unit needs working smoke and carbon monoxide detectors and a working fire extinguisher mounted on every floor.
- Owners must give guests an information packet with the maximum occupancy, parking and emergency information.
- Residential beach stickers cannot be transferred to renters.
The city’s guidelines summarize the rules (permit guidelines). From an insurance standpoint, short-term use is a separate question from the permit. Many standard dwelling policies exclude or limit it, so tell us before your first booking and we will find a carrier that accepts it.
Loss of rent and flood
Loss of rent coverage pays the rent you lose while a covered loss is repaired. It is part of most DP-3 policies, but flood is a separate policy, and FloodSmart lists temporary housing and business interruption losses as things an NFIP policy does not cover (FloodSmart). For rentals near the water, we write NFIP flood through Selective and compare private flood options from Neptune, Beyond Floods, Flow Flood, Aon Edge, CatCoverage and TFIA, some of which can add loss of rent. Check your building on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center.
Your duties as a Connecticut landlord
Connecticut law requires landlords to keep a rental fit and habitable, keep common areas clean and safe, maintain the heating, plumbing and electrical systems they supply, and provide running water, hot water and reasonable heat (CGS 47a-7). Those duties line up with what carriers worry about: a failed boiler in a cold snap, a frozen pipe in a vacant unit or a broken stair in a shared hallway. Keep maintenance records, and check how your policy treats a unit that sits vacant between tenants.
Liability on Milford rentals
Slips on icy walkways, falls on porch stairs and dog bites are common landlord liability claims. A DP-3 can carry premises liability, and an umbrella policy adds a layer above it. For beach rentals with decks and outdoor showers, or short-term rentals with frequent new guests, a higher liability limit is worth a look.
More for Milford landlords
See our Milford insurance agency page, Milford flood insurance and Milford homeowners insurance. Our Connecticut landlord insurance guide covers statewide rules, and landlord insurance vs. homeowners insurance explains the differences. Nearby: Fairfield landlord insurance.
Get a quote for your Milford rental
Request a quote. There’s no obligation to buy. We compare 40+ carriers for each building and tell you what every quote covers and leaves out. About 90% of the quotes we prepare are ready within 24 hours, and we don’t charge additional fees. Our phones are answered 9 AM to 5 PM Monday through Thursday and 8 AM to 4 PM Friday, Eastern: (203) 859-6858. Or use the form below.
Where this fits: this page is part of our landlord insurance guide for New England. For statewide rules, see Connecticut landlord insurance. Own a larger building? Read Connecticut apartment building insurance, or Connecticut condo association insurance if you serve on a condo board. Nearby: Shelton and Stratford.
Frequently asked questions
Do I need a permit to rent my Milford house short term?
Yes. Under Milford’s short-term rental ordinance, adopted in May 2026, an owner needs a city permit before listing or renting a home for 1 to 30 consecutive days. If you do not stay on the property, you must live within 30 miles or name a local agent who does (Milford Code, Chapter 11, Article V). The city’s land use page says the application is not yet live (Milford Permitting and Land Use). Tell your insurer about short-term use too, because many dwelling policies treat it differently.
What policy do I need for a rental house I do not live in?
Usually a dwelling fire policy. The DP-3 form covers the building on an open-perils basis, typically at replacement cost, and adds loss of rent and landlord liability. A homeowners policy is written for the place you live, so it generally does not fit a house rented to someone else.
I live in one half of a Milford two-family. Landlord policy or homeowners?
Often an owner-occupied homeowners policy written for a two-family works, because it covers your own belongings and both units of the building. Tell the carrier how many units are rented, and add enough liability for tenants and their guests.
Does flood insurance pay my lost rent after a storm?
Not under the federal program. FloodSmart lists temporary housing and financial losses from business interruption among the things an NFIP policy does not cover (FloodSmart). Some private flood policies offer loss of rent as an option. If your rental is near the water, we can compare both.
Should my Milford tenants have renters insurance?
Yes. Your landlord policy covers your building and your liability, not your tenant’s belongings or their own liability. Many landlords require renters insurance in the lease and ask for proof each year.
What do you need to quote my rental?
The address, number of units, year built, the condition and age of the roof, heating, wiring and plumbing, whether it is rented year-round, seasonally or short term, any flood zone information and your claims history. Use the form below or call (203) 859-6858.
Does a landlord policy cover a short-term rental in Milford?
Not automatically. A short-term or seasonal rental is underwritten differently from a year-round lease, and some landlord policies limit or exclude it. Tell us how often the property is rented and for how long before you buy, so we can match the policy to the use. Call (203) 859-6858 with questions.
Sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 2020–2024, Milford city: tenure (B25003)
- Milford tenure by units in structure (B25032)
- Milford Annex, 2023 SCRCOG Hazard Mitigation Plan Update
- City of Milford ordinance, Chapter 11, Article V, Short-Term Residential Rentals (May 2026)
- Milford short-term rental permit guidelines
- Milford Department of Permitting and Land Use
- CGS 47a-7: landlord’s responsibilities
- FloodSmart: buying a flood policy and what it covers
- FEMA Flood Map Service Center
General information for Milford rental owners. It is not legal advice or a quote. Your policy terms decide coverage, and city ordinances, state law and survey figures cited here can change. Call (203) 859-6858 with questions about your property.
